By
Mushtaq ul Haq Ahmad Sikandar, New Age Islam
27 July
2021
The
Personal Journey from Mohajir Qaumi Movement to Muttahida Qaumi Mahaz
Main
Points:
1. Mohajirs in
Pakistan always felt discriminated.
2. The paradox
of Pakistan is that it was comprised of those regions that never struggled for
creation of Pakistan.
3. The
discrimination felt by the Mohajirs is real and brutally honest.
------
My
Life’s Journey: The Early Years (1966-1988)
By Altaf
Hussain
Karachi, Pakistan Oxford University Press,
2011,
Pp 199.
ISBN 9780199063413
-----
The Indian
subcontinent was divided on the basis of religion in 1947, when the British
colonialist left. It was assumed by both Hindu and Muslim communalists that
religion formed the basis of Nationhood, hence Hindu and Muslim were different
Nations because of their religion, leading to the belief that they can’t
co-exist with each other. The consequences thereof being that India was
supposed to be the home of Hindu majority and the newly created Pakistan was
abode for the Muslims. The partition resulted in large scale communal riots and
mass migrations of Muslims from India, and Non-Muslims from Pakistan. It is
also a sad fact that Pakistan was carved out of those Muslim majority parts,
whose masses had never or scarcely strived and struggled for creation of
Pakistan. The migrant Muslims who had strived for Pakistan and in the due
course incurred heavy losses, had been uprooted from their native places
through migrations.
The present
book under review amalgamates the biographical details and the struggle of one
migrant (Mohajir in Urdu), for the rights of other migrants (mohajirun,
plural). The book is divided into two parts. The first part is based on a
lengthy extended interview carried with Altaf Hussain, founder of the Mohajir
Qaumi Movement (MQM) (The National Movement of Mohajirs), with journalist
Khalid Athar in 1988. This part documents his student life, early influences
and formation of MQM. The second part comprises of the “Notes on Important
issues and the Mohajir Movement”.
In his
Foreword, Matthew A Cook states, “Particular histories-like that of the
mohajirs-seem to indicate that nationalism is a failed project in Pakistan.
Since its citizens are not historically cemented into a more singular nation,
group distinctions (arising from Partition) continue to define everyday
Pakistani lives”. The book has two introductions written by Robert Nichols and
Brigadier (R) Abdul Rahman Siddiqui beside a Preface by Altaf Hussain.
The part
first of the book is titled as “The Struggle and Birth of the MQM”. It
describes Altaf Hussain as a Nationalist patriot who wanted to serve Pakistan
by joining army in the aftermath of 1965 India-Pakistan war. Before being
recruited in army it was mandatory to be a conscript in National Cadet Service
Scheme. As he was being trained, Altaf’s dreams were shattered by the treatment
of a sergeant, who labelled him incompetent and discriminated against him
because of his ethnicity.
Instead of
joining army Altaf chose to study Pharmacy, but here he was again
discriminated. Altaf was finally able to secure admission due to his relentless
protests. This marked the beginning of his student activism and politics. He
was surprised but shocked to face the reality that student unions fought
elections on ethnic lines.
Altaf
considered himself a Pakistani but was coerced to grapple with the brutal
reality of ethnic distinction. He was resisting the idea of division among
Pakistanis on ethnic lines, as he thought his biggest identity was that of
being a Pakistani, as it was they who through their sacrifices had created,
secured and now protected Pakistan. Altaf soon joined the anti-Bhutto movement
led by Pakistan National Alliance (PNA) and Nizam e Mustafa, for restoration of
Democracy and Free elections. Its cadetship didn’t allow him much liberty to
think about ethnicity, though inherent in the movement there was bias against
Altaf, because he wasn’t member of Islami Jamiat e Tulaba (IJT), the
student wing of Jamaat e Islami (JeI). Even this prejudice didn’t dampen his spirit
for the cause.
Altaf was
disillusioned with the PNA leadership and outcome of the Nizam e Mustafa
Movement after it succeeded in overthrowing Bhutto regime. Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto
was a Sindhis, and Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) led by Bhutto advocated ethic
distinction. Hence as a reaction to the ‘Sindhi revival” Mohajirs declared
themselves as a separate Nation (Qaum) too. Altaf’s perception was soon
shattered because the removal of Bhutto didn’t end the bias, discrimination and
marginalization against Mohajirs. Thus he formed All Pakistan Mohajir Students
Organization (APMSO) in 1978 at the University of Karachi. Then Altaf goes on
to describe the ordeal of APMSO, which included struggling for funds, obstacles
in keeping the organization running, surviving violent attacks by rival
organizations, being banished from working in colleges and universities.
APMSO came
to an end as the student life of Altaf and his mohajir friends was complete.
Hence he upgraded APMSO, to Mohajir Qaumi Movement in 1984. Then a different
bloody ordeal for MQM started, as other political parties and exploiters
weren’t in favor of United Mohajirs.
The second
part details the experiences and struggle of Altaf and his friends for running
MQM. He was arrested many times, tortured and he details his jail experiences
too. A couple of murderous attacks were also carried against him that compelled
him to seek political asylum outside Pakistan. The MQM also participated in
elections and many of its cadres were elected as councillors in Karachi.
Altaf’s nationalism didn’t keep him confined to fighting for Mohajir rights
only but he also fought for the restoration of Sindhi people’s rights too.
Altaf also details the supportive role of his family without which his struggle
would have been impossible.
The book is
a living testimony of the fact that religion can’t form the solitary basis of a
modern Nation-State. The other identities are essential too. The creation of
Bangladesh from East Pakistan in 1971 was a deathblow to the Two Nation Theory.
It was a whistle blower and a warning to the rulers of Pakistan to stop
discriminating among its people on ethnic, regional, linguistic, cultural and
sectarianism lines. But as the book describes Pakistani rulers and dictators
haven’t learnt a lesson from Bangladeshi example. The book as the title aptly conveys details
the early years (1966-1988) of Altaf Hussain’s life, but a void seems
insurmountable because since 1988 much time elapsed and new changes have
incurred within MQM.
The
greatest change came in 1997 when Mohajir Qaumi Movement changed its name to Muttahida
Qaumi Movement (United National Movement). It needs an academic
deliberation and serious analysis as to why a movement for one class assumed a
nationwide character instead of retrograding into a secessionist one like
Bengali nationalism? The Mohajir nationalism and movement needs more
discussion, which the book fails to provide.
Also one
can’t agree with these views of Altaf Hussain, “The concept of Pakistan and the
Two Nation Theory developed many years prior to partition. Sir Syed Ahmad Khan
laid the foundation of this theory. It is therefore historically justified to
proclaim that Sir Syed was the architect of the Two Nation Theory.
However,
one has to remember that the two nation concept of today is different from Sir
Syed Ahmed’s because he had envisaged all the Muslims of the subcontinent as
one nation and all the Hindus as another. But what we have done today is that
we have recognized the people of the majority Muslim provinces as one nation
while excluding the Muslims of the Muslim minority provinces from being a part
of the Muslim nationhood. Before Sir Syed put forward the Two Nation Theory,
the Indian populace never regarded religion as a differentiating factor. But
Sir Syed’s far sightedness made him realize that the Hindus political efforts
were completely energized towards achieving goals which were solely in their
own interest and they also enjoyed the blessings of the British while the
Muslims had failed in bringing any sense of order in their own political ranks.
Hence he came upon the realization that the Muslims and Hindus of the
subcontinent were two separate nations” (P-129-130).
Nothing can
be far from truth as Sir Syed was the champion of the Hindu- Muslim unity, but
Altaf wrongly ascribes him to be the founder of Two Nation theory. These
statements of Sir Syed rebut Altaf’s claims "Centuries have passed since
God desired that Hindus and Musalmans may share the climate and produce of this
land and live and die together. So it appears to be the will of God that these
two communities may live together in this country as friends, or even like two
brothers. They form the two eyes of the petty face of India' Sir Syed again
advised, "I have frequently said it many times and I say it again that
India is like a beautiful bride blessed by two attractive eyes – the Hindus and
the Muslims. If one of them is lost, this beautiful bride will become
ugly". Then he commented" It is our desire that between the Hindus
and Muslims of India friendship, fraternal feeling and love may grow daily and
such progress may be achieved in their mutual social relations that, except
only in mosques and temples the Muslims and Hindus be not distinguished”. Sir
Syed hoped against hope as he believed "O Hindus and Musalmans, do you
inhabit any country other than India? Do you not both live here and are you not
buried in this land or cremated on the Ghats of this land? Remember that Hindu
and Musalman are words of religious significance, otherwise Hindus, Musalmans
and Christians who live in this country all constitute one nation".
Overall the
book is a welcome addition to the literature on the intra-nationalist clashes
in Pakistan. It is an essential read for anyone interested in Mohajir struggle,
politics and their rights.
-----
M.H.A.
Sikander is Writer-Activist based in Srinagar, Kashmir.
URL: https://www.newageislam.com/books-documents/mohajir-pakistan-altaf/d/125132
New Age Islam, Islam
Online, Islamic
Website, African
Muslim News, Arab
World News, South
Asia News, Indian
Muslim News, World
Muslim News, Women
in Islam, Islamic
Feminism, Arab
Women, Women
In Arab, Islamophobia
in America, Muslim
Women in West, Islam
Women and Feminism