Muslims Must Confront Islamist Terror Ideologically: An Islamic Reformation Required
By Sultan Shahin, Editor, New Age Islam
9 Jan 2015
We seem to be living
in an era of Islamist terror. Massacre of journalists in Paris has followed the
massacre of children in Peshawar. Thirteen years after 9/11, the world is
facing a more complex, more diverse and a more dangerous threat. While the world has focused on fighting the
terrorists militarily, the challenge of their ideological narrative has gone
essentially unchallenged.
The Jihadis have
worked out a complete theology of violence, a coherent narrative of hate and
intolerance, totalitarian and akin to
fascism that is capable of attracting large numbers of gullible Muslim youth
and desensitize them to human instincts of compassion and kindness. Normally,
persuading someone to commit suicide should be the most difficult job in the
world. But an army of suicide bombers emerge from Muslims societies, capable of
untold cruelty, wherever and whenever some determined, resourceful group needs
them. This is obviously the attraction and power of the Islamist ideology,
vastly different from the understanding of Islam the overwhelming majority of
Muslims have had for centuries.
Under mystical, Sufi influence, Muslims have prided
themselves on having an inclusive, tolerant religion which came to reiterate
and revalidate the truth of all previous religions. Muslims believe their
religion is a blessing for mankind.
So when a supremacist, exclusivist, intolerant
interpretation of Islam started being propagated with the establishment of
Saudi-Wahhabi monarchy early in the last century, Muslims rejected it out of
hand. But the phenomenal oil wealth and cold war imperatives helped the
ideology spread rapidly. The international community did not hamper the process
even after 9/11. Indeed it even created several new swamps for terrorists to
prosper.
However, despite
rapid radicalisation, many Muslims still remain moderate, firmly anchored in
the Sufi traditions, who consider Islam a spiritual path to salvation, an
ethical, moral standard to follow. They believe in modernity, inclusiveness,
pluralism, gender equality and democracy. Prophet Mohammad called his community
ummatan wasata, the median community, centred and balanced. Extremists have
existed among Muslims throughout Islamic history. But ultimately, the peaceful
majority has always defeated them. Hopefully, we will defeat the powerful
Petrodollar Islam and its offshoot
Jihadism too.
But this is easier
said than done. Moderate Muslims are facing an uphill task. The methods Sufi
saints used to spread moderate, mystical Islam cannot work in the internet age.
Sufis used to emphasise the positive teachings of Islam and simply ignore the
rest. But the age of brushing things under the carpet is gone.
Moderate Muslims have
to think of new strategies. I believe that moderates must expose the radical ideology
in all its perversity, and refute it, along with emphasising Islam's moral
teachings.
Jihadism's enormous
success in capturing Muslim imagination lies in the following core beliefs,
among others.
a) For several
centuries now Ulema have encouraged Muslims to develop an unquestioning belief
in the Quran as an uncreated, divine book, almost like God.
This is a dangerous
proposition. If Quran is created, that is, if it is a compilation of verses that came from
time to time to guide the prophet as the need arose, the contexts of the verses
become important and only verses that do not require a context to be understood
assume universal applicability.
But if it is
uncreated, as all the madrasas teach, then each and every verse is of eternal
applicability and has to be followed without reference to the context. The very
distinction between essential, constitutive part of the revelation and the
contextual, instructive part is lost, making it easier for extremist ideologues
to misuse the contextual as essential, the instructive as constitutive.
That is why all our
madrasas that teach the uncreatedness of Quran are creating radical literalists
who see no reason why they should apply their mind. So, If the Quran says
somewhere, in whatever context, "kill the kafir," they can go out and
kill the kafir, regardless of the fact that this exhortation was made in a
certain historical context and was valid only for that time. No wonder all
Jihadi ideologues quote a number of combative verses of Quran in their justification
and use them for indoctrination of the gullible literalist. Unsurprisingly , they have an army of killers
available who are prepared to make even suicidal strikes for killing innocent
men, women and children, believing that they will be in heaven soon.
b) Great reverence is attached to Hadees or
so-called sayings of the Prophet. Jihadi literature makes full use of a large
number of possibly fabricated ahadees to further their cause. Compiled up to
300 years after the demise of the Prophet, Ahadees simply cannot represent
authentic sayings of the prophet, though it is possible that the prophet said
something like what is narrated in some of the ahadees.
No wonder, a number
of apparently fabricated ahadees are used to justify indiscriminate killings of
civilians as what is now called collateral damage (for instance, Bukhari Volume
004/Book 052, Hadees 256 or 019/4321), though there are also many more ahadees
that prohibit such killings in any situation. Indeed another hadees (for
instance, Bukhari, 021/010 (Mu’watta) prohibits not only killing "women or
children or an aged, infirm person," but also asks not to "cut down
fruit-bearing trees, destroy an inhabited place, slaughter sheep or camels
except for food, burn bees and scatter them."
When God perfected
our religion (Qur'an 5:3) in the last days of the Prophet, who are we to create
new scriptures like Hadees centuries later?
c) Muslim scholars of
all persuasions give Shariah divine status. In fact it is a man-made body of
laws, codified by different ulema over a century after the Prophet's demise and
has been changing since. There is no question of it's being divine.
The malaise of Islam
is clearly far deeper. The problems are basic, fundamental to Islam. But ulema,
the supposed custodians of faith, continue to be in denial.
What does the larger
society do? I think the world needs to first inform itself of what is going on
within the Muslim community. We should have credible surveys to find out the
extent of radicalisation, monitor Friday sermons, study text books of different
madrasas, and confront the ulema with
the fundamental questions raised here. If the ulema really want to save Islam
from being considered synonymous with terrorism, they should at least make the
following commonsensical declarations, which are also consistent with the
faith:
1. Quran is a created book of God,
not divine as God Himself;
2. contextual, particularly militant verses,
in Quran are no longer applicable to Muslims;
3. Hadees is not an Islamic scripture a la
Quran.
4. Shariah cannot be considered divine.
What the ulema,
intellectuals and politicians have done so far amounts to nothing more than a
cosmetic endeavour; they have been hoping and perhaps praying that the issues
will go away. But radicalism is deepening and intensifying. It is attracting
more and more converts.
So clearly Muslim
theologians will need to go beyond superficial statements, walk further in the
direction of rationality, prepare a coherent theology of peace and moderation
and propagate it among the masses of Muslims, if they want Islam to survive as
a moderate religion, a moral standard, and a spiritual path to salvation rather
than allow Islamic scriptures to degenerate into terrorist manuals.
If the ulema do not
agree to walk their peaceful talk, the larger society should encourage and
support those few moderate, progressive Muslims who are willing to go out on a
limb, perhaps putting their heads on the chopping block in this process. This
section should be able to go to the community directly, bypassing the ulema and
campaign for sanity.
New Age Islam, Islam
Online, Islamic Website, African Muslim News, Arab World News, South Asia News, Indian Muslim News, World Muslim News, Women in Islam, Islamic Feminism, Arab Women, Women In Arab, Islamophobia in America, Muslim Women in West, Islam Women and Feminism