Tunisia: Deleting Islam from the Constitution; Having No State Religion Can Be the Start of a New Era for This Muslim Country with a Long Secular Tradition
By
Arshad Alam, New Age Islam
28 June
2022
Separating
Religion from State Is One Thing That Muslim Countries around the World Need to
Work On
Main
Points:
1. Tunisia, a
Muslim majority country is all set to have a religion neutral state, to be
decided by a referendum next month
2. If
successful, it will take away the most important source of legitimacy of
Islamist politics
3. The
president is being accused of being dictatorial, but many also feel that he is
the last hope of secularism in the country
-----
Tunisian President Kais Saied (L), President receiving the new
constitution (R), images via Tunisian Presidency on Twitter
-----
Tunisia is
all set to drop Islam from its constitution. The new constitution has been
drafted by law professor, Sadeq Beleid, and a copy of it has been presented to
the president, Kais Saied. Incidentally, the president, whom many accuse of
being a dictator, has been a law professor himself, and is widely expected to
ratify the new constitution. However, before that happens, there will be a
referendum in the country on the issue in which citizens will have the
opportunity to discuss the merits and demerits of such a move. If ratified, it
will be for the first time in Tunisia’s history that Islam will not be a state
religion. It is noteworthy that although the majority of the population is
Muslim, the state is not governed by the Sharia law but by a European legal
code which was bequeathed to it by its colonial master. The country has had a
robust secular tradition but Islam has always remained on the statute
books.
What does
it mean to not have a state religion? And how will it impact state and society
relations? Firstly, analysts have pointed out that despite Tunisia being
governed by a western legal system, many in the judiciary keep making
references to Islam since it is part of the constitution. Once it is removed,
it will not be possible to make such references since the judiciary will no
longer be obligated to do so. We also need to understand that Sharia is an
important tool in the hands of Islamists. Wherever they have been, one of their
pet projects have been the demand to implement the Sharia. If the religion of
the state is Islam, then this becomes a rallying point for the Islamists as
they can always turn around and accuse the government of not being true to the
constitution. Removing the word Islam will make sure that that Islamists will
lose an important anchor to articulate their claims.
Pakistan is
a good example of how even a small band of articulate clergy can hold the
government to ransom in the name of Islam. As the state is committed to Islam,
it simply cannot wriggle away when demands to implement aspects of it are made.
It also
needs to be pointed out that Ennahda, the largest Islamist movement in Tunisia,
became the ruling government after the Arab Spring. However, due to its own
electoral compulsion and in order to show a moderate face, Ennahda made a
series of compromises, one of which was to abandon the demand for implementing
Sharia. In fact, in 2014, it declared that the party would no longer claim
political Islam but rather they should be seen as Muslim democrats. Observers
of the movement have argued that due to such flip flops, its social base within
the poor and lower middle classes suffered and today the party no longer holds
the authority that it used to earlier.
Moreover,
the Ennahda could never really win over the secularists as the latter were
always suspicious of its motives. This is certainly good news for the president
who would have faced tough resistance from Ennahda if it was in a powerful
position.
This is not
to suggest that Ennahda is on the side of President Saied. It opposes him, but
on the issue of tyranny and dictatorship, not so much on what the current
government is planning to do with Islam. Ennahda is not the sole opposition in
Tunisia, there are left leaning workers collective which are quite powerful but
none of them have criticized Saied for his proposal to remove Islam from the
constitution. They are certainly opposed to him for his failure to get the
country back to democracy. But those opposed to Saied are also opposed to the
Islamist vision of the Ennahda and hence would not like to align with on this
crucial issue.
It appears
then that when the referendum is held on July 25, Tunisia might become the
first country in that region to declare that the state will have no religion of
its own. Difficulties to achieve this remain. The country is facing
unprecedented economic crisis but the current president is hugely popular.
Surveys have consistently underscored his popularity, especially amongst the
youth. When successive governments loot and pillage the country, populist
leaders rise to fill the gap and this is what seems to be happening in Tunisia
too. For many in Tunisia, Saied offers the last hope to bring the country back
on the path of economic recovery. For many, he is also the last bulwark around
which secular forces can script a new chapter in Tunisia’s history.
Terrorist
groups must be watching the situation very closely. In 2015, Daesh attacked the
Bardo museum killing 22 people. Shortly afterwards, they attacked the Sousse, a
tourist resort killing 38 people and majorly affecting the tourism industry.
Terrorists always have multiple agendas to fulfil but one of the important one
is that they do not want moderate Islam to take root in any country. Tunisia is
at the cusp of such a transition and it would be a remarkable achievement if it
happens without overt violence. Separating religion from state is one thing
that Muslim countries around the world need to work on.
----
A
regular contributor to NewAgeIslam.com, Arshad Alam is a writer and researcher
on Islam and Muslims in South Asia.
URL: https://newageislam.com/islamic-society/tunisia-constitution-religion-country-secular/d/127345
New Age Islam, Islam Online, Islamic Website, African Muslim News, Arab World News, South Asia News, Indian Muslim News, World Muslim News, Women in Islam, Islamic Feminism, Arab Women, Women In Arab, Islamophobia in America, Muslim Women in West, Islam Women and Feminism