By Ishaan Tharoor
November 5, 2019
The expert view is that we’re living in an age of democratic retreat. Strongmen in de facto single-party states have consolidated or expanded their rule, while nationalist populists and would-be autocrats in democracies are systematically undermining or corrupting their countries’ liberal institutions. In some places in the Arab world, where democracy has long struggled to take root, peaceful protests are still being met with murderous state brutality and repression.
Then there’s Tunisia. At this point, you probably know the cliche. The small North African nation remains the one “success” story of the 2011 Arab Spring, the sole nation to throw off its long-ruling dictator in that epochal wave of upheaval and preserve the democratic transition that followed. It just held three elections in the space of a month; the last episode of that process took place a few weeks ago, when Kais Saied — a retired-law-professor-turned-independent-anti-establishment-politician — won a presidential runoff election in a landslide.
Saied’s victory delivered a clear message of voter dissatisfaction. “In a region ruled by monarchs, autocrats and family dynasties, Tunisia once again showcased its unique position in the Arab world,” wrote my colleague Sudarsan Raghavan last month. “Millions headed to the polls to choose between two political outsiders in the runoff of its second-ever presidential elections. In doing so, they showed contempt for the nation’s political establishment for not solving the high unemployment rate, rising prices and lack of opportunities that helped spark the revolution.”
Saied alone can’t start addressing the anxieties that catapulted him into power. He formally became the country’s head of state last week, but Tunisia is still waiting for the formation of its next government. That may take some time. Not unlike elections on the other side of the Mediterranean, Tunisia’s parliamentary results were fragmented, delivering no clear mandate to any single party. The faction to come out with the most seats — 52 out of 217 — was Ennahda, a moderate Islamist party. But it is still preparing for formal negotiations that will likely prove tricky.
Zied Ladhari, Ennahda’s secretary general, is confident about his party’s ability to follow through. “This is a challenge for us, but it’s something we can handle,” he told Today’s WorldView in a recent interview. Ladhari, who also served as Tunisia’s minister for development in the country’s previous government, was in Washington for meetings. His name has come up as a possible prime minister.
Ladhari’s party, though, has ruled out partnering with two of its nearest competitors — a secularist faction whose leader is implicated in a corruption scandal and another party linked to the old guard of the country’s lapsed dictatorship. It will attempt to cobble together a motley coalition of other secularists, leftists and Islamists. Since 2011, Tunisia has endured rounds of political crises, assassinations, mass protests and the worrying departure of hundreds of its citizens to join the ranks of the Islamic State.
Despite real ideological divisions between Ennahda — which, like its Egyptian ideological cousin, the Muslim Brotherhood, had been suppressed for decades — and secularist forces, the country has fitfully lurched onward through consensus and unity governments, culminating in the adoption of a new democratic constitution in 2014.
“Tunisians kept returning to the ballot box — or taking to the streets to express their dissent,” noted Post opinions editor Christian Caryl. “And so they’ve managed to keep their remarkable democratic experiment grinding along. They passed laws protecting minority rights; civil society groups have continued to press vocally for reforms. (And the fact that Tunisian democracy continues to exist at all remains the most eloquent possible rebuke to the Islamist militants.)”
“The country has succeeded in consolidating democracy and making it irreversible,” said Ladhari, adding that “the kind of partnership emerging between different political families” in Tunisia is “something we are not really familiar with in other countries” in the neighbourhood and is a mark of Tunisia’s maturing democracy. He stressed that Tunisia would never try to export its system elsewhere. But he suggested that his nation did “offer a model of both political and economic inclusion” at a time when pro-democracy protests are flaring once more in the Arab world.
“Tunisia very clearly demonstrates that democracy is possible in this part of the world, something completely compatible with the Islamic values,” he said.
Analysts point to certain unique factors that make Tunisia different from other nations swept up in the 2011 Arab Spring, including its relatively small size. But Tunisia was “never deemed to be exceptional prior to 2011,” observed H.A. Hellyer, a senior associate fellow at the Royal United Services Institute think tank in London.
“On the contrary, the bigotries of low expectations were applied to Tunisians just as much as they were to any other community in the wider Arab world,” Hellyer wrote in an op-ed for the National newspaper. “If any exceptional qualities are to be ascribed to Tunisia, there are perhaps just two; firstly, the country has autonomy over its own political process, rather than extensive foreign interference. Secondly, because political power is so diffuse in the country, no one could hope to play a zero-sum game and win. So in that regard, Tunisians are again winners, proving the generalizers and essentialists about Arabs and Muslims wrong.”
But rather than celebrating this achievement, Tunisia’s politicians are feeling the heat. The country faces a glut of structural problems, a slumping economy, rising food prices, a lack of jobs and a populace clamoring for greater social services. Saied swept to power on a wave of anger over corruption and social inequity. The sense of woe is so rife, noted Raghavan that some Tunisians have found themselves feeling nostalgic for the relative stability of the days of dictatorship.
“They are still waiting for the economic dividend of the revolution and are unhappy with the performance of the government in terms of actually improving their everyday life,” said Ladhari of his countrymen, pointing to the real unfinished work of Tunisia’s transition to democracy. “The main challenge is to actually prove that democracy leads to prosperity. Freedom is important, but also having more economic opportunities and jobs is also important.”
Original Headline: In a world of crisis, Tunisia’s democracy marches on
Source: The Washington Post