New Age Islam
Sun Apr 11 2021, 11:21 AM

Debating Islam ( 14 Dec 2012, NewAgeIslam.Com)

Comment | Comment

An Intellectual Muslim Mafia Movement That Won’t Allow Any Freedom Of Thought In Islam, Says Deen Institute, A Muslim Debating Forum Which Promotes Critical Thinking


Muslim Opposition Highlights Growing Influence of Creationism and Literalist Interpretations of the Quran


Debate on Islam and evolution has to be called off after revolt by student societies


Jerome Taylor

14 December 2012


Organisers behind a British conference on Islam and evolution say they nearly had to cancel the event after receiving a torrent of opposition from Muslim students at one of the country’s top scientific universities, The Independent has learned.


The Deen Institute, a Muslim debating forum which promotes critical thinking, had hoped to hold a conference entitled “Have Muslims misunderstood evolution?” early next year. Among the speakers invited to attend included Muslim scientists, imams who have promoted the compatibility of Islam and evolution as well as those who preach a form of Islamic creationism.


The initial plan was to hold the event next month at Imperial College London, one of the country’s foremost universities for scientific exploration and debate, in cooperation with the local Islamic student society. But the Deen Institute said it was forced to pull out when it became clear that opposition to the event from supporters of creationism began mounting. It is now being held without input from any Muslim student society at Logan Hall, a conference centre owned by the University of London.


“We eventually had to give up of getting any support from student societies because it was seen as simply too controversial,” Adam Deen, co-founder of the institute, told The Independent. Deen, who describes himself as a “conservative Muslim” who encourages critical thinking, said he was surprised to receive such opposition at a place of scientific study, particularly as he had made sure to invite all sides of the debate including those who preach creationism.


“It’s symptomatic of a bigger problem in the Muslim world where people representing practical Muslims have to be seen to be more literalist,” he said. “It’s almost like there’s an intellectual mafia movement who won’t allow any freedom of thought.”

Usman Siddiqui, president of Imperial’s Islamic student society, insisted that they were unable to co-host the event for “logistical reasons” rather than ideological ones.

“I did not say that Imperial ISoc have no qualms with the event - it's just that we did not reach the stage where we were to make that decision,” he said. “They wanted to use Imperial as a venue, it didn't work out, and now they have a new venue.”


However it is clear that opposition to the event has been increasing ever since the Deen Institute began publicising it. One source involved with preparations said: “As soon as it went live I was inundated with complaints. It’s sad because student societies should be desperate to host this kind of debate.”


Mr Deen’s public Facebook account illustrates many of the concerns people raised. In one comment Mohammad Ali Harrath, the founder of the highly influential Islam Channel, wrote: “This debate is a big mistake. It is shifting debate to make it a Muslim issue rather than an issue between atheists and creationists.”


Another commenter, Zeshan Sasjid, added: “Evolution is not Islamic. Prophet Adam did not have parents. A Muslim can’t believe that Prophet Adam.”


However others criticised their fellow believers for being overly literalist and shunning scientific research.


“If our faith is strong we can only gain from looking at, hearing and understanding difference,” wrote Amina Crashaw. “If this were not truth I would not be Muslim. Understanding difference include being open to finding something new to learn from the Qur’an. Not new facts but new depth.”


The row is informative because it illustrates some of the controversies currently occupying the Muslim world about the compatibility of science and whether critical thinking is being closed down by more literalist schools of thought.


Muslims believe the Qur’an is the indisputable word of God and therefore any scientific discovery which risks proving something within their holy book as incorrect is highly controversial, particularly among the more literalist schools of thought. For example, most Muslim scholars have long accepted scientifically proven cosmology but even up until his death in 1999, Sheikh Ibn Baaz, the Grand Mufti of Saudi Arabia, continued to insist that the Sun revolved around the Earth based on his interpretation of Islamic texts.


Until recently evolution caused little friction with the majority of Muslim jurists and academics broadly accepting Darwin’s findings – albeit in a theistic sense. But in recent years creationism – much of it inspired by similar Christian right movements in the United States – has begun to receive wider acceptance.


Much of this newfound enthusiasm for attacking evolution has been pushed by Harun Yahya, a prominent Turkish theologian whose writings have been seized upon by literalists and those who exhibit a theological suspicion of science. Dr Oktar Babuna, a representative from the Harun Yahya movement, is scheduled to speak at the conference alongside Shaikh Yasir Qadhi, an influential imam who accepts evolution at a micro level but refuses to countenance the idea that man evolved from anything other than Adam himself.


Two Muslim scientists, American biologists Ehab Abouheif and Fatimah Jackson, will also speak alongside Usama Hasan, a British imam who preaches the commonly held scientific view that man is descended from ape-like forebears.


Hasan’s inclusion is particularly controversial because he enraged Muslim literalists in his own mosque in Leyton, east London, when he began preaching about evolution and criticised literalists for having a “children's madrasa-level understanding” of science compared to their Islamic forebears who once used to lead the world in such fields. The arguments eventually became so intense he was eventually forced out by hardliners.


In a recent interview with Forbes magazine following a similar conference in the United States, biologist Dr Abouheif explained why he felt it was important to begin challenging literal creationists.


“There’s a lot at stake here because it’s well beyond evolution,” he said. “If it’s not about the evidence, if you reject science, if you reject evolution as a science and you’re not willing to listen to evidence, then that means that for all of science, when it comes into contact with sociological, political conflicts, then you won’t believe it either.”


 He added: “What got me out of my seat, my lab chair … is my want of the Muslim world to become innovators and to share in being leaders. In technology and innovation, and share in production. And not just be consumers.”




Pioneering Conference To Explore Islam’s Stance on Evolution

Written by Adam Deen 


Press release 6th December 2012

The upcoming conference will debate the compatibility of contemporary Evolutionary science and the Islamic faith, bringing together a variety of scientific and theological perspectives.


The Deen Institute proudly announces its first ‘Dialogue within Islam’ event. The conference entitled: Have Muslims Misunderstood Evolution? will for the first time in the UK witness prominent Muslims tackling the controversial topic of evolution in a public forum.


The all-day conference will be held on Saturday 5th January 2013 at the Logan Hall, London.


“Dialogue within Islam” events seek to engage with challenging ideas of concern to Muslims, in a setting that allows for critical dialogue.


Historically, Muslims have held conflicting opinions on the theory of evolution and whether science and Islamic theology share a point of convergence. In recent years, a polarised debate on the topic has left many Muslims confused as to what Islam does, or doesn’t say, about human evolution.


The Deen Institute will therefore provide a platform to different viewpoints so that the topic might be debated and examined in an honest, respectful and tolerant environment.


The panel of Muslim theologians, speakers and scientists discussing the issue will include: Shaykh Yasir Qadhi, Resident Scholar at Memphis Islamic Centre and Lecturer in Rhodes College (USA); Dr Usama Hasan, Imam at the Masjid al-Tawhid Mosque in Leyton (UK); Professor Fatima Jackson, Professor of Biological Anthropology and Director of the Institute of African-American Research (USA); Professor Ehab Abouheif, is Canada Research Chair in Evolutionary Biology at McGill University (Canada) and Dr Oktar Babuna, a leading speaker with the Harun Yahya movement (Turkey).


The conference will elucidate the issue of human evolution from an Islamic viewpoint, in order to provide the audience with a clear understanding of the points of convergence between contemporary scientific theories and Islamic theology.


What: Have Muslims Misunderstood Evolution?


Where: Logan Hall, 20 Bedford Way, London WC1H 0AL

When: Saturday 5th Jan 2013, 10am – 6pm.

For enquires or press passes, contact:

Yusuf Ahmet (Director of Operations): +44(0)7539 553144  |



The Deen Institute

As Muslims living in modern society, we must engage with a diverse range of ideas and belief systems. The Deen Institute has been established to provide students with the necessary tools of understanding and dialogue. Our aim is to navigate this challenging situation in light of the Islamic tradition; through our commitment to knowledge and learning. Taught in a comfortable and welcoming environment, our structured courses cover a range of subjects and levels.


The Deen Institute welcomes all who are curious and eager to learn, regardless of faith or background. With this in mind, the Institute's primary objectives as represented by each pillar are as follows:


1.    To help the wider public understand the Islamic tradition in light of contemporary ideas and beliefs.


2.    To raise awareness about the sound use of critical thinking and intellectual thought throughout Islamic heritage, and to share this wisdom with modern day thinkers and intellectuals.


3.    To supply the UK with a platform where common issues and questions can be openly examined from various viewpoints, with mutual respect and civility.


4.    To release research publications focused on the Islamic perspective on common issues pertaining to topics such as ethics, philosophy, history and science.


5.    To promote critical thinking and rational thought within philosophical cogency in the educational sector and to revive intellectuality within the Muslim community.