New Age Islam
Wed Oct 28 2020, 10:39 AM

Current Affairs ( 23 Aug 2018, NewAgeIslam.Com)

Kuldip Nayar (1923-2018): ‘Injustice still hurts me, as it did 70 years ago’


By Meera Dewan

August 24, 2018









Hai Maut Is Qadar Qariin, Mujhey Na Aayegaa Yaqiin (That death could be so near, this I cannot believe).” The single line from one of Kuldip Nayar’s many beloved poets, Hafeez Jalandhari’s popular song ‘Abhi to Mein Jawan Hoon’ could well sum up the rich, action-packed and meaningful life of South Asia’s beloved chronicler. This was the theme song of the film he and my team made together on his work, life and passions. However, this last line was kept safely tucked away within the terabytes of the hard drive nicknamed “KN footage and music”. Today it must be unearthed.

Come Wednesday, 12 noon, an email would pop up with his weekly article: “Between the Lines” by Kuldip Nayar. No Wednesday was missed for the past five decades, when he started India’s first syndicated column, after leaving The Indian Express, post Emergency. An initial survival strategy that was to become South Asia’s most widely circulated column. As in every venture, he was partnered by his wife Bharti, who would travel with a bagful of envelopes to be mailed out at Western Court post office. By Wednesday evening, he would be as excited as a child, discussing the pros and cons of the coming week’s theme.

The Jalandhari lyrics conclude “Nahin Nahin, Abhi Nahin, Nahin Nahin, Abhi Nahin.” Since that time has now arrived, let me start with his future plan, at age 95 years, before the backward glance. I believe he would like me to share his unfinished story, as he had recounted it in our recent biopic.

Kuldip Nayar’s upcoming project was to be a book on Ballia, a small town in UP, the shortest-lived Republic ever. As I sit to write this tribute to Nayar Sahib, beside me are a heap of documents and handwritten notes from the 1950s onwards that remain to be compiled.

“Ballia is a story which much be told because that is the saga of our Independence. Ballia is a small town on the border of UP and Bihar. On Gandhi’s Quit India call in 1942, these people ruled themselves for seven days, declaring themselves an independent Republic. The atrocities which the British committed on them are indescribable. Freedom fighters were hanged from trees. There was a Commissioner whom we used to call the Butcher of Ballia. So don’t tell me the British are a benevolent people. What type of atrocities was committed because they wanted the native to learn the lesson! “You dare not revolt, you will not revolt. Or else this will be your fate”. It is still a matter of local pride in Ballia that before the flag fell; another grabbed and supported that symbol of national struggle. Eleven men were killed one after another by the soldiers of the Crown. I am obsessed by the idea of writing about Ballia because of not only one Ballia but of several uncelebrated Ballias”.

Nayar Saab was not short on obsessions. Contemporary politics, Indo-Pak friendship, Urdu poetry, Kababs and sweets, grandchildren and Noor Jahan are just some of his loves, as he confesses on screen. “The real love is only your first love,” he adds. I’d say his first love was deep in his veins. “Injustice still hurts me, as it did seventy years ago. My instincts from a very early age have been to recognise people who suffered victimisation and marginalisation. The plight of others has touched me so deeply that I’ve sometimes made their sufferings mine. Looking back, it now seems obvious that I was destined to embrace the world of journalism, exposing injustice and highlighting heroes, regardless of the consequences.”

Once, on being particularly regaled by yet another story, where he requested Prime Minister Bhutto soon after an interview in Islamabad, with a request to meet Noor Jahan, I spontaneously asked him how many biographical films had been made on his work. “None. The Left believes I’m not Left enough and the Right thinks I’m Left”. The expression on his face when he said this instantly took me back to some understanding of why his mother’s nickname for him was Bhola. Discreetly, though cheekily, I took the liberty of using it a few times myself at special moments. He didn’t seem to mind.

One such occasion was when we, along with the film crew, went to Tihar Jail where he had been confined during the Emergency. I hoped this revisit would not bring back memories to haunt the now 94-year old former detainee. The remembrances his optimism threw up instead were the poetic inclinations of the jailor at the time and his poetry which he shared with the present Director General, Prisons, and detainee-waiters at the wonderful Tihar Café. This modest Kavi Sammelan was in-between checking on the latters’ legal status and future plans on release. All this over two heaped plates of Dahi Baras, followed by Mithai.

Spokesman to ministers, defiant detainee, editor of leading national dailies, he was born in Sialkot, a home he was compelled to uproot himself from when he was 24 years old; Amritsar, where he arrived alone and penniless, as did millions like him; Delhi’s corridors of power and Parliament; Wagah border where for decades he lit candles for peace on August 14th, a birthday he shares with Pakistan; the winding lanes of Ballimaran, Dilli, where he started his career as an accidental journalist — all home to him, who was once displaced.

The poetry of Baba Farid, Faiz, Makhdoom Mohiuddin Hafeez Jalandhari, Amrita Pritam, Gulzar and the rendition of Hans Raj Hans resonated his inner voice of fearlessness, sense of childlike wonder and compassion.

At 95 years and 7 days, his life has been both as active participant and witness towards the journey of India 2019. “Abhi to Mein Jawan Hoon”.

Meera Dewan is an award-winning filmmaker and director of a biopic with Kuldip Nayar, “In his Inner Voice”, for Films Division, Ministry of Information and Broadcasting.



Fearless Kuldip Nayar, Journalism’s Conscience

By Coomi Kapoor

August 24, 2018

Kuldip Nayar wore so many hats in his eventful life that the tired old cliché, ‘a doyen of Indian journalism’, does not really fit. As a newsman, he scooped some of the biggest breaks in political journalism in his time and gained a reputation for chronicling political events in the country over half a century, providing extraordinary insight and insider information in his popular column, appropriately called ‘Between the Lines’.

But Nayar was much more than just a newsperson. He was an author of many bestsellers, champion for civil liberties and freedom of speech, an untiring activist for peace between India and Pakistan and conscience keeper of the nation.

Even governments not in tune with his views often turned to him for advice on relations with Pakistan since he remained in close touch with politicians, the intelligentsia media and people of Pakistan, many of whom he knew intimately. He was on the bus when then Prime Minister, Atal Bihari Vajpayee, rode in the historic inaugural journey between Amritsar and Lahore in 1999. His stature earned him recognition in the form of numerous honours and awards, including a nomination to Rajya Sabha, the prestigious post of High Commissioner to the UK and member on several commissions and committees.

Unlike some of his contemporaries in the media, Nayar never retired. He continued his flourishing syndicated column, translated into practically every major regional language and distributed in dozens of newspapers, not just in India but also in Pakistan, Bangladesh and the Middle East.

He was my editor and mentor at The Indian Express and he kept in regular touch with not just with me but numerous former colleagues. Less than a month ago, he chided me that I had of late been lax in arranging our regular get-togethers with the old Express hands at the India International Centre. The lunch was fixed for later in the month, but alas, he broke the appointment. He took ill with chest congestion a few days ago and passed away, at age 95, in hospital Wednesday night.

Some of my most vivid recollections of him are from the Emergency. When censorship was introduced by Indira Gandhi and we reporters at The Indian Express were still in a state of shock and inertia, Nayar called us to his office to give us a pep talk. He advised us that even if we could not write about the unfolding events in Delhi because of the blanket censorship, we should privately keep a daily diary for posterity. It was invaluable advice which, unfortunately, none of us followed.

Within a few days of the Emergency, he courageously called a meeting of Delhi journalists to protest against censorship and the arrest of two editors. The memorandum to Mrs Gandhi was signed by some 100 journalists, largely from The Indian Express and the Hindustan Times. When V C Shukla, then Information and Broadcasting Minister, demanded he hand over the list of signatories, Nayar refused.

A few days later, Nayar was arrested under the dreaded MISA and sent to Tihar jail. He was released shortly afterwards when the government learnt that the Delhi High Court was planning to rule in his favour, striking down the MISA provision that barred a detainee from seeking relief from the courts. Justice Rangarajan, however, ruled in Nayar’s favour despite the government arguing that the case had become infructuous since he had already been released. Incidentally, while he was in jail, he met his father-in-law Bhim Sen Sachar, a well-known Gandhian who had been imprisoned for also petitioning against the imposition of the Emergency.

Nayar had a way with people, never pulled rank and acquired legendary contacts, from peons in government offices to top ministers. Consequentially, he had many spectacular scoops to his credit. Reporting for the United News of India (UNI) from Tashkent, he was the first to get the news of Prime Minister Lal Bahadur Shastri’s death while his rivals were at a party celebrating the declaration of the Tashkent agreement between India and Pakistan. Getting hold of a government telephone line, the enterprising Nayar managed to convey the news to his office and convince the sleepy sub-editor on duty that this was no hoax. UNI released the news past midnight and many newspapers stopped their presses to publish the report.

On January 16, 1977, Nayar put out a report which rocked India. He declared that Mrs Gandhi was going to declare elections in March that year, although Emergency was still in place and people feared that there was no early end in sight. Nayar realised that his neck was on the line and so was the future of The Indian Express, if the report proved untrue. But Express owner Ram Nath Goenka courageously gave him the go-ahead. A decade later, Nayar was the first to report, after an interview with Pakistan’s A Q Khan, that Pakistan had acquired the knowhow for a nuclear bomb.

Ironically, the man who made history as a journalist had in fact envisaged a career in law. Nayar studied at the Law School in Lahore where Khushwant Singh was one of his teachers. But when Partition came, Nayar and his family were forced to flee their home in Sialkot. He reached Delhi as an impecunious refugee who had to build a new life for himself. He first joined an Urdu newspaper and later the Indian Information Service. He studied for his Master’s degree in journalism at North Western University, USA, and moved on to English journalism. He had the privilege of working as information officer for both Lal Bahadur Shastri and Govind Ballabh Pant, when they were Home Ministers. His work with the two ministers brought him into close contact with all big names in the Congress party of that era.

After his stint with the government, Nayar was invited to head the struggling UNI wire service which had been completely overshadowed by the Press Trust of India (PTI). Later, he moved to the Statesman as Resident Editor, where he began his celebrated column ‘Between the Lines’. Shortly afterwards, Ram Nath Goenka, owner of The Indian Express, hired the fabled newsgetter to start the Express News Service. Despite the plaudits he earned for building the most active and informed news network in the country, he decided to leave when he felt he was not in tune with a new editorial appointment. He used to joke that Goenka, by forcing his hand, had done him a huge favour because he then pioneered the concept of syndicating his column and news stories all over the country. The reach of his syndicate was phenomenal. He made far more money on his own than he could have ever dreamed while working for a newspaper.

Nayar believed fervently in mending ties with Pakistan, no matter what the provocation from hardliners on both sides of the border. He realised his nostalgia and sentimental attachment to the region he grew up in was increasingly out of sync with a younger generation of Indians. Once he narrated to me laughingly that when he asked his grandson what he thought of the film ‘Border’, his grandson replied jocularly, “You won’t like it, it’s pro-India.’’ He never gave up hope for peace in the neighbourhood and continued with his symbolic candle light vigils on the border on the eve of Independence Day with like-minded people from the other side, even if the number of marchers kept diminishing.