Editorial in Daily Times, Lahore
August 2, 2010
Opiate of the masses
The news of a band of clerics from a religious party constructing an illegal mosque on government property in Green Town, Lahore, served as a reminder to our authorities that their writ was being challenged. It was good to see that the Lahore Development Authority (LDA) took quick action late night after Daily Times’ exclusive reportage and demolished the illegal building. A case has also been registered against 50 people and so far seven people have been arrested. Since the clerics in Green Town had threatened to kill people on blasphemy charges if the illegal construction is stopped, they should be locked up behind bars. More such illegal encroachments should be identified and demolished. When religion is used as a tool to create fear amongst the masses, it is time to think logically and aim for a secular state instead of letting the state be a tool in the hands of vested interests.
Building illegal mosques is not a new phenomenon in this land of the pure. In the not-so-distant past, the notorious Lal Masjid issue started with the demolition of illegal constructions by the Capital Development Authority (CDA) in Islamabad. Mosques built illegally were razed but the Musharraf government acquiesced in the demands of the Lal Masjid clerics to rebuild them after they terrorised the citizens of Islamabad. This only made things worse as the fanatics, high on their ‘religious’ power, started making demands that bordered on absurdity. If there is a lesson to be learnt from that whole fiasco, it is that the state should never give in to the demands of religious zealots. Islam does not teach us to occupy land illegally to build mosques or seminaries. These so-called religious clergy have to be taken to task for maligning the true meaning of our religion.
Pakistan should take a leaf out of its old wing, East Pakistan (now Bangladesh), where its Supreme Court has struck down the bulk of the controversial 5th Amendment by reinstating a ban on Islamic political parties. Bangladesh’s original constitution was secular in nature but following a coup in 1975, the constitution was amended and given a religious tinge. Bangladeshi Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina said that she was “not in favour of banning any political party”. This may have more to do with the fact that the Jamaat-e-Islami is a large political party with some clout. Earlier, the Bangladesh High Court had outlawed punishments handed down in fatwas (religious edicts), after a series of cases of Muslim women being beaten and caned. Not only that, the Bangladesh government has also banned books by Maulana Maududi because they “encourage terrorism and militancy”. It is time that Pakistan follows in the footsteps of Bangladesh, also a Muslim country but which is paving a path towards the traditions laid down by its founding fathers. Mr Jinnah had also visualised a secular Pakistan but this was not to be. Soon after his death the Objectives Resolution inseminated the seeds of religious intolerance into our body politic. The religious parties in the Indian subcontinent were the most vocal in their opposition to the new state, but as soon as Pakistan came into being, they became its ‘guardians’. Appeasement of religious fundamentalists has led to an intolerant society where hate-literature is sold freely and religious minorities are persecuted. The state’s role has been far from ideal. State support to militant and sectarian outfits has bloodied our soil while our history textbooks have adopted a religious colour.
John Locke introduced the idea of separating the church from the state back in the 17th century and since then many countries have adopted this secular, democratic model. In Pakistan, there is a misconception about secularism being ‘anti-religion’ when it is actually ‘religion-neutral’. If we are to make this country a progressive state, we must get rid of obscurantist and reactionary ideas so as to imbibe religious tolerance amongst our ranks and make Pakistan a state that can hold its head up high in today’s world.
Source: The Daily Times, Pakistan
Mr. Haque says, "you are also a double-standard ‘banner’?"
I had clearly said, "I am against banning of books."
Hello Ashok Sharma.
You state that "When in minority, whether in the USA, Canada, UK, or, India, the Muslim intellectuals and middle classes are in the forefront of struggle for secularism and minority rights. However, in Muslim majority societies they behave as if it is not their concern."
I have to say that your words of wisdom do ring true on the whole and you have to wonder why?
Of course, you will find rare examples like the late Wahid who supported Christians in their hour of need in Indonesia. Wahid spoke up for all minorities and he rebuked Islamists and I know a few other examples, but these individuals are rare.
Lee Jay Walker
Not even from libraries and mandirs, Mr.Mohiyuddin? ....So, you are also a double-standard ‘banner’?
It is good to hear that Bangladesh has banned Islamic political parties and has also banned the books of Maulana Maududi from libraries and mosques. India too should ban religious political parties such as the BJP and the Muslim League. However I do not favour banning the books of Savarkar or Golwalkar because I am against banning of books.
With some reluctance I write these:In these articles I see a losing battle of the pant–shirt types. Some of us Hindus and Muslims on this side of the border are wishing them success in their struggle against the beard-cap types but I am afraid the chances are very, very bleak, because the shirt-pant types are actually hypocrites and confused. We are betting on the wrong horse in fact. Use of words like ‘Mulla mafia’ and ‘opiate of the masses’ may highlight the shirt-pant type’s dexterity in the use of words but beard-cap types are no more ‘oil selling Persian experts’ so as not to know the meaning of these words.This Zardari, (Known to be Mr.10% ) who wants his 21 year old son to succeed as the next leader of Pakistan and whose grown-up daughter’s pants brilliantly reveal the rotundity of her buttocks, is the Head of the Islamic State of Pakistan!! Taliyan!! What Islam! What Muslims! And what Pakistan!
It is really unfortunate that the silent majority among Muslims, especially the middle class and intellectuals have not raised their voice against the individuals/organisations who are trying to send the society back to middle ages. Either it is due to the fear of being dubbed as un-islamic or, due to general apathy that they do not see the writing on the wall. When in minority, whether in the USA, Canada, UK, or, India, the Muslim intellectuals and middle classes are in the forefront of struggle for secularism and minority rights. However, in Muslim majority societies they behave as if it is not their concern. The result is obvious. They are today the worst sufferers of the so-called exremist ideologies gaining momentum in islamic societies.