Books and Documents

Islam, Women and Feminism (05 Jul 2019 NewAgeIslam.Com)

Why Zaira Wasim Quitting her Career Cannot be A Matter of Choice

By Arshad Alam, New Age Islam

05 July 2019

How should we look at Zaira Wasim’s exit from Bollywood? Wasim’s a very talented actress hailing from the valley. For many she was an inspiration not just in Kashmir but throughout the South Asian Muslim world. Her sudden decision to quit the film industry has left many bewildered and searching for answers. Many have said that it might be a publicity stunt before the release of another of her film. If that is the case, then she cannot be faulted as most major artistes in Mumbai have done it. However, the reiteration of her decision the very next day does indicate that she is serious about quitting the industry.

It is quite possible that this might be the rambling of a young adult not knowing how to negotiate with a new world. But we must remember that she has been negotiating such structures since the age of thirteen and therefore the thesis that her Facebook post might be a sudden burst of immaturity should also be put to rest. One can only come to the conclusion that what she wrote was well thought out and that she must have taken some time to come to the decision which she eventually took.

Zaira Wasim

Probably the best way to understand the motive behind her decision is to look more carefully at what she has written in her long Facebook post. Zaira did find lot of ‘love and support’ from her fellow travellers but then she states that she was ‘ignorant’ during this phase of her life. It must be underlined that the word ‘ignorance’ has special meaning in Islam which tells us that true happiness and enlightenment is only possible by treading on the path decreed by Allah. She highlights that there are two types of ‘diseases’ which afflict the heart: doubt and desire. It almost seems that she had started doubting the path of Allah and that various doubts crept up during this phase of her life. Rather than understanding doubt as a creative force, she decides to snub it altogether by announcing that there is ‘nothing greater than faith’ and that we should ‘not forget what we were created for’. Of course, her Islam told her that we were created for the express purpose of worshipping Allah and that everything else was secondary to this fundamental act of subservience which every Muslim must pursue. No wonder then that she realised that being in the industry that she was, her relationship with her Islam was threatened.      

Many have argued that this is her personal choice and that it should be respected. Really? Since when has religion become a matter of personal choice? All religions make demands from their followers; they make claims about the world and its creations and they fundamentally re-order the world around us. Religion, including Islam, is deeply political. And yet, there are people celebrating Zaira conversion as a personal choice. One does not have to be a feminist to understand the age old slogan that personal is political. It is rather disturbing that the same set of feminists is no longer using their feminist lens to analyse this problem.

Zaira’s decision must also be debated particularly within the Muslim circles because ultimately she has called Islam into question. Is this the kind of Islam we want? Is Islam intrinsically anti-women? After all, there have been many Muslim men working in the film industry but they never thought that their ‘line of work’ interfered with their faith. Why is it that this special sense of confusion, anxiety and resignation only reserved for women? Zaira’s post has only confirmed what many have started believing to be the essence of Islam: a religion which is orthodox, regressive and patently anti-women. The congratulatory comments in their hundreds which have been posted on Zaira’s wall only testify to the fact that hundreds of Muslim men and women are extremely happy with her decision. They simultaneously prove that these Muslim men do not want Muslim women to have any agency of their own; rather all their masculinity is spent thinking about ways in which they could domesticate them. And of course, it seems very clear that Islam gives them all the help that they require.

It is quite possible that Zaira was pressured into thinking that Islam forbids women to work in certain industries. Worse still, there are interpretations which suggest that Muslim women should not move out of their homes at all. This then is a telling commentary on the state of affairs within Muslim society. The collective conscience of Muslim society exerts pressure on individuals and some of them cannot resist it. This is then the problem of so called Islamic morality by which Muslim society lives today. There is very little space for individual dissent and those who chart out a somewhat different path have to bear the burden of near ostracism from society. Zaira’s choice therefore cannot be understood as just a personal choice made out of her free will. Rather we have to take a complex view as to how this choice came to be executed and understand how a new Islamist religious self is interwoven in this so called choice.

The Urdu press has made matters worse by arguing that many Hindu actors have also quit for ‘religious’ reasons. In this kind of a skewed understanding, Zaira’s case is being blown out of proportion with the express intention of giving a bad name to Islam. Those opposing Zaira Wasim are all necessarily right wing Islamophobes. This kind of framing of the problem does not help the Muslim community. This is not the time to compare her decision with that of Vinod Khanna or some other Hindu women actor. We live in times where there can be no comparison between Hindus and Muslims. One Hindu actor deciding to quit does not affect the prospects of that community. Hindus are a developed community as compared to Muslims. The ideas of social and religious reform run deep into this community. Muslims entered the modern age by opposing modern education while Hindus embraced it. Muslims are not at par with Hindus in any of the developmental parameters. And that’s why one Muslim Zaira quitting a promising career calls for a deeper introspection from within the community.

Arshad Alam is a columnist with NewAgeIslam.com

URL: http://www.newageislam.com/islam,-women-and-feminism/arshad-alam,-new-age-islam/why-zaira-wasim-quitting-her-career-cannot-be-a-matter-of-choice/d/119091

New Age IslamIslam OnlineIslamic WebsiteAfrican Muslim NewsArab World NewsSouth Asia NewsIndian Muslim NewsWorld Muslim NewsWomen in IslamIslamic FeminismArab WomenWomen In ArabIslamophobia in AmericaMuslim Women in WestIslam Women and Feminism


  • stop selling religion...
    By Utkarsh Mishra - 7/7/2019 7:56:36 AM

  • Due to lack of Quranic knowledge, we have allowed the Mullas to divide and rule us. We nearly worship the Holy Quran and its Arabic language as if Allah is Arabic knowing only. We waste our time and energy in learning of Arabic language with correct pronouncing and read, recite and memorize/HIFZ the Holy Quran without understanding to please our Mullas instead of Allah. Allah is more interested to know how far we have read, understood and followed HIS entire Mohkmaath/specific Guidance (3:7) to achieve HIS Blessings.There is no ORDER of Allah to learn Arabic language to read and understand the Holy Quran and also to simply read, recite and memorize IT. Hence being a Universal religion/Deen, we should all start reading the translation of Holy Quran to understand and follow it correctly and entirely to achieve Allah's Blessings. Actually Arabic is the common language of the Arabs: Muslims, Christians, Jews and others and contains as usual good and bad words, songs and dances, scolding etc.as in any other language. Allah is above all languages and dialects and HIS three previous Holy Books were not bestowed in Arabic but in the prevalent languages of the time to warn and guide the then deviated and erring humanity to HIS Right Path. Thanks.     
    By Syed Sadruddin Hussain - 7/5/2019 11:50:37 PM

  • Religion may not be a matter of personal choice but whether to adhere to its dictats and how  thoroughly to do so are of course personal choices. We can express our views on the subject but we cannot say that our views apply to everyone.

    Muslims who applauded her decision only reveal their orthodoxy. I strongly root for success and career advancement of Muslim women (and men). The argument that success in the after-life is more important than success in this life is very harmful to our community.

    By Ghulam Mohiyuddin - 7/5/2019 12:56:31 PM

Compose Your Comments here:
Email (Not to be published)
Fill the text
Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in the articles and comments are the opinions of the authors and do not necessarily reflect that of NewAgeIslam.com.