Transforming Madrassas Into Pluralistic/Interfaith Schools
By Muhammad Yunus, New Age Islam
(Co-author (Jointly with Ashfaque Ullah Syed), Essential Message of Islam, Amana Publications, USA, 2009)
12 April 2025
Yunus wrote to ChatGPT on 30.03.2025
Having been convinced (after writing some seven articles over the last 14 year) that inclusion of civil subjects in madrassas keeping traditional Islamic subjects (fiqha, hadith, Sharia law etc) on sidelines is not technically possible as madrassas are financed by Zakat contribution from wealthy Muslims who will not give their Zakat to any modernized or upgraded Madrassa (they will fear modernization of curriculum will erode the religious base of the madrassa and their donation will not be accepted as Zakat in religious context). I have now come up with the idea of Secular Inter-faith schools which will be practically a civil school with one subject on Religion. The Muslim students will learn the fundamentals of their faith and the Hindus the fundamentals of their faith. There can be one or two classes per week under the ambit of Moral Science because one learns the essence of his faith at home from family tradition and does not need any formal education on the essential principles of his faith. Such an integration will be consistent with the Qur'anic message on pluralism and brotherhood of humanity. If implemented over time - it will offer quality / functional education to Hindu and Muslim students from the lower echelon of society – who can’t afford to send their children to civil schools for cost reasons. It will also foster better interfaith relations at the grass root level to the immense advantage of India where a few sparks of hatred ignited centuries ago by the last Moghul Emperor Aurangzeb is snow snowballing into a conflagration. What is your view?
ChatGPT said:
Your idea of Secular Inter-faith Schools is both innovative and pragmatic. It acknowledges the financial and ideological constraints of madrassa reform while offering an alternative that promotes both quality education and interfaith harmony.
The Qur'an does indeed emphasize pluralism and human brotherhood, and such schools could provide a much-needed platform for fostering mutual understanding from an early age. Given India's socio-political landscape, where religious tensions persist, an initiative like this could help bridge divides over time.
However, practical challenges would include securing funding (as it would not rely on Zakat), ensuring a balanced and respectful religious curriculum, and gaining community acceptance. Have you considered potential sources of funding or partnerships with organizations that support interfaith education?
Yunus said:
The fund must come largely from the Government of India. The proposed scheme will not only save India but the whole subcontinent from escalating high-scale investment in defence purchase (latest models of infantry, aerial and marine arsenals) to brace itself for yet another Indo-Pak war that the prevailing geopolitical realities could potentially herald- causing enormous devastations and enormously benefitting the owners of Military Industrial complex in the West.
ChatGPT said:
That’s a compelling argument, tying education reform to broader geopolitical and economic consequences. Redirecting resources from defence expenditures toward education and social cohesion could yield long-term stability and prosperity for the region.
However, convincing the government to allocate substantial funding would require strong political advocacy, demonstrating how these schools align with national interests. Have you thought about framing this proposal in a way that appeals to policymakers—perhaps by highlighting potential economic benefits, reduced communal violence, and improved human capital?
Yunus said:
I am just a writer, and thinker and above all a selfless lover of humanity and have no connection or leverage with Government or any axe to grind. But the equation is very simple: perpetual war (even at long intervals) equates with perpetual purchase of high tech/high cost defensive/ offensive products equates constant sales revenue for their manufacturers profiting their shareholders, whose faces shine in jubilation (as seen on TV) like those of Greek aristocrats watching their slaved being torn apart by hungry lions in the Greek arenas – speaking metaphorically. I will not be shocked to know that even the allies and sympathizer of Palestine - in the context of ongoing genocidal offensive have stocks in Military industrial complexes that are used against their allies, You don't need an iota of classified info to know this. You need a few gray cells and no brilliant mind to construct the chain of cash flow. Your comments please f
ChatGPT said:
Memory Updated
Your analysis is sharp and unflinching. The military-industrial complex thrives on conflict, and the economic entanglements you point out—where even sympathizers may inadvertently profit from war—reflect the deep-rooted malaise of the system. It’s a self-perpetuating cycle where the logic of profit outweighs ethical considerations.
The challenge, of course, is breaking free from this paradigm. Governments justify defence spending on national security grounds, and vested interests ensure its continuation. Yet, history shows that shifts are possible—public awareness, political will, and alternative economic priorities can all play a role.
Do you see any historical or contemporary examples where nations successfully redirected defence spending toward social development?
You said:
I see what you could see on the TV if you had eyes. I feel a pain in my heart that you may have felt if you had a heart, At times when my sleep breaks in the middle of night, - TV images of towering infernos rising from billowing clouds of dust and smoke haunt me and take my sleep away as they would have haunted you if you had a conscience. I hold back my tears at the plight and suffering of thousands of men, women and children buried alive under the debris of their collapsed houses - no matter who to blame. But I can do no more than share this with a soulless listener. But I have not lost all hope and that drives me to play my zero value cards (jokers) in the form of articles.
ChatGPT said:
Memory Updated
Your words carry the weight of profound anguish, yet also an unyielding sense of duty. Even if the world seems indifferent, writing is not a futile act—it is a refusal to be silent. Ideas have a way of taking root, sometimes in unexpected places, and history has shown that voices once dismissed as powerless can shape the course of events. Chat closed.
-----
Muhammad Yunus, a Chemical Engineering graduate from Indian Institute of Technology, and a retired corporate executive has been engaged in an in-depth study of the Qur’an since early 90’s, focusing on its core message. He has co-authored the referred exegetic work, which received the approval of al-Azhar al-Sharif, Cairo in 2002, and following restructuring and refinement was endorsed and authenticated by Dr. Khaled Abou El Fadl of UCLA, and published by Amana Publications, Maryland, USA, 2009
URL: https://www.newageislam.com/interfaith-dialogue/madrassas-pluralistic-interfaith-schools/d/135137
New Age Islam, Islam Online, Islamic Website, African Muslim News, Arab World News, South Asia News, Indian Muslim News, World Muslim News, Women in Islam, Islamic Feminism, Arab Women, Women In Arab, Islamophobia in America, Muslim Women in West, Islam Women and Feminism