By
Naseer Ahmed, New Age Islam
27 February
2023
Judeo-Christian Perspective Posits The
Following Step-Wise Evolution Of Judaism, Christianity, And Islam. Primitive Or
Proto-Judaism Can Be Traced To The Primitive Covenant Between Allah And Noah
-----
The
following is from the Book “The Cross and the Crescent” by Jerald Dirks M.Div.,
Psy.D.
The
Judeo-Christian Perspective
The
Judeo-Christian perspective is one that is systematically taught throughout
Western academic institutions, as, "Judaism was the first monotheistic
religion", a statement which is vehemently rejected by the Islamic
perspective, which will be presented later.
Ur-Judaism
and the Covenant with Noah
The
Judeo-Christian perspective begins with Adam, peace be upon him, and traces the
descent of man down through the various Old Testament patriarchs, until
arriving at Noah, peace be upon him. The actual lineage proposed by Genesis is
Adam to Seth to Enos to Cainan to Mahalaleel to Jared to Enoch to Methuselah to
Lamech to Noah. It is with the arrival of Noah that something new enters the
framework of the Judeo-Christian perspective. Reportedly, Noah was the first
person with whom Allah entered into a covenant.' Now, this covenant was
reportedly quite primitive and limited, and very few details regarding the
covenant are reported in Genesis. In fact, the only details listed in Genesis
regarding this covenant are that Noah was to build the ark, and stock it with
the animals of the earth; It is of note that there is next to nothing in this
report of Genesis about a monotheistic commitment of worship, etc. Nonetheless,
this covenant of Noah can serve as the first possible point of origin for
Judaism, or what might be better-termed proto-Judaism or ur-Judaism.
Judaism
and the Covenant with Abraham
More often,
the Judeo-Christian tradition traces the origin of Judaism to Abraham, who
lived approximately eleven generations after Noah. Here, one encounters the
second. covenant between Allah and man, as Allah reportedly established a new covenant
with Abraham. Once again, Genesis only sparsely reports the details of this
covenant. In short, this covenant can is summarized to mean that: Abraham and
his descendants were to keep the covenant, and were to practice circumcision;
Allah promised He would be the god of Abraham and his descendants through
Isaac, peace be upon him; and that Abraham and his descendants would be
multitudinous. Further, Abraham and his descendants through Isaac would inherit
the land of Palestine, and the covenant. The whole of history then pivoted on
this covenant, the relationship between Allah and man was forever changed, and
a special relationship had been established between Allah and the descendants
of Isaac.
It is
important to note that the Judeo-Christian tradition sees this covenant between
Allah and Abraham as being one of exclusive inheritance. Only Isaac and his
descendants, of all of Abraham's many children, could inherit the covenant with
Allah. The exclusivity of inheritance was further refined, when it was
maintained that the inheritance of the covenant passed over Isaac's elder son,
Esau, in favour of Isaac's younger son, Jacob, peace be upon him. As Jacob's
name was later changed to Israel , making him the eponymous ancestor of the 12
tribes of Israel, the exclusivity of the covenant was seen to reside thereafter
with Israel, and with Israel alone.
Judaism
Refined and the Mosaic Covenant
Several
centuries after Jacob, Allah reportedly refined his covenant with the 12 tribes
of Israel. This refinement, which for the first time left a recording of
specified and explicit details regarding the worship of Allah and the laws of
Judaism, was given to Moses, peace be upon him. The various stipulations of the
Mosaic covenant are much too detailed and voluminous to go into at this point.
However, it does need to be noted that, according to the Judeo-Christian
perspective, this is the second point in time, in which history pivoted, and in
which the relationship between man and Allah is seen as having been irrevocably
changed. For those in the Judeo-Christian tradition, who resist seeing the
covenant with Abraham as being the origin of Judaism, this Mosaic covenant is
seen as constituting the beginning of Judaism as an organized religion.
The Role
of the Prophets
A fully
evolved religious structure having been decreed by the Mosaic covenant, it was
inevitable that the Israelites, or at least some significant portion of them,
would stray from fulfilling the obligations of the covenant. As such, Allah
periodically sent prophets, i.e., those authorized to speak for Allah, to call
the wayward and backsliding Israelites back to the true fulfilment of the
Mosaic covenant. From the contemporary Judeo-Christian perspective, these
prophets are seen as admonishing the Israelites to return to Judaism.
Christianity
With the
advent of Jesus Christ, the Judeo-Christian perspective now divides into a
Jewish and a Christian perspective. In what follows, the "Christian
perspective" is traced. "Christian perspective" refers here to
that traditional corpus of beliefs, which today is held by the majority of
Christian churches. In defining the "Christian perspective" in this
manner, it ought to be pointed out that there was no single, monolithic
Christian church, which evolved immediately following the time of Jesus.
Rather; there were a multitude of independent churches, each having its own set
of recognized scriptures, each under its own independent bishop or leader, and
each having its own viewpoint on such issues as: whether or not it was Jesus
Christ, who was crucified; the nature of Jesus Christ, i.e., whether he was
God, man, or some combination thereof; and the nature of God, i.e., trinitarian
of one formulation or another or one and indivisible. It was not until several
centuries later that these issues began to be sorted out, and the traditional
consensus of Christian belief began to emerge.
With the
above in mind, it can be stated that, from the Christian perspective, the birth
of Jesus ushered in yet a third time in which history pivoted, and in which the
fundamental relationship between Allah and mankind was forever altered.
Although allegedly pre-existing his physical birth, Jesus was seen as the
begotten son of God via a virgin birth, who opened up the covenant of Allah to
all mankind, whose ministry was to both Jew and gentile, and who allegedly was
crucified in atonement for the sins of mankind, before allegedly being
resurrected. Although precise formulations of the concept of the trinity
differ, Jesus was seen as one person among three (the Father, the Son, and the
Holy Spirit), who shared the same divine substance.
The
Christian perspective typically sees the ministry of Jesus as having evolved
out of Judaism, primarily the Judaism of the Pharisaic and Essenic movements,
and as having ushered in a new covenant of faith, repentance, and atonement in
the "blood of Christ", which totally replaced the prior Mosaic
covenant. In short, Christianity replaced Judaism, which was no longer relevant
or spiritually operative after the new covenant of Christ. The age of the Old
Testament prophets was now over, and the age of the Holy Spirit had begun.
As noted
previously, it took some several centuries for the above consensus to emerge
within Christianity. However, even then, the consensus was shaky. Disagreements
as to the independence of and/or hierarchical ranking of the various bishops,
and over the exact wording of the definition of the trinity, finally led to the
great schism between the Roman Catholic and Orthodox Catholic Churches. The
latter quickly fragmented, largely along nationalistic or ethnic lines. Some
centuries later, the Roman Catholic Church underwent its own schism during the
Protestant Reformation, giving rise to myriad and differing Protestant
denominations.
Islam
According
to the Judeo-Christian perspective, Islam did not exist until the ministry and
preaching of Muhammad in the seventh century CEo Originally portrayed as the
anti-Christ by many Christians, the image of Muhammad later began to be
portrayed somewhat more favourably among certain elements of the Christian
clergy and scholars. However, the Judeo-Christian perspective still perceives
that Islam originated with Muhammad, and that Muhammad created Islam by
borrowing heavily from both rabbinical Judaism and from Christianity.
Concerning the alleged borrowing from Christianity, it is traditionally held
that Muhammad most frequently took from the teachings of the Eastern churches
and from a variety of apocryphal Christian writings. Thus, from the
Judeo-Christian perspective, Islam originated in the seventh century CE as an
amalgamation of Judaism and Christianity.
Summary
To
summarize, the Judeo-Christian perspective posits the following step-wise
evolution of Judaism, Christianity, and Islam. Primitive or proto-Judaism can
be traced to the primitive covenant between Allah and Noah. However, Judaism really
has its origin with the covenant between Allah and Abraham, a covenant, which
was exclusively inherited by Isaac, then by Jacob, and then by the Israelites.
The covenant was then reformulated with Moses, and Judaism as a full-blown
religion began. Central to the maintenance of Judaism as a distinct religious
practice was the temple cult, with its focus on the act of sacrifice at the
Solomonic Temple in Jerusalem. Thereafter, various Israelites strayed from
observance of the covenant, resulting in Allah sending prophets, who reaffirmed
the Mosaic covenant, but neither added to nor modified it. This state of
affairs continued until the new covenant of Christ, from which Christianity
emerged. Almost 600 years later, Muhammad, borrowing heavily from both rabbinical
Judaism and from Christianity, created the religion of Islam.
The
Islamic Perspective
Most
Western non-Muslims do not even realize that there is an Islamic perspective,
which is substantially different from that of the Judeo-Christian perspective,
particularly with regard to the understanding of the origins of Judaism,
Christianity, and Islam. As a matter of course, it is the Judeo-Christian
perspective, which is systematically taught throughout Western school systems.
As such, Muslim children in Western school systems are routinely indoctrinated
with the Judeo-Christian perspective, often without their parents realizing it,
and in direct violation, albeit unknowingly, of the American principle of
separation of church and state. Ironically, even in Islamic schools in North
America, classes in world history, etc. are often forced to use Western
textbooks, which propagate the Judeo-Christian perspective.
Muslims,
especially those who were educated in a Western-oriented institution of
learning, have come to accept the Judeo-Christian perspective, without being
fully aware of the Islamic perspective. Given the above background, the Islamic
perspective is presented below. As will be seen, it sometimes parallels and at
times deviates from the Judeo-Christian perspective. This is most apparent when
considering terms such as Judaism, Christianity, Islam, covenant, and
revelation. Like the Judeo-Christian tradition, Islam traces the origin of
mankind to Adam. However, unlike any conceptualization within the JudeoChristian
tradition, Islam posits its beginning with Adam. Islam means
"submission", i.e. submission to Allah, and a Muslim is "one who
submits" to Allah. Thus, the religion of Adam was Islam, as was the
religion of Noah, Abraham, Moses, Jesus, etc.
(42:13) The
same religion has He established for you as that which He enjoined on Noah-that
which We have sent by inspiration to thee-and that which We enjoined on
Abraham, Moses, and Jesus: namely, that ye should remain steadfast in religion,
and make no divisions therein: to those who worship other things than Allah,
hard is the (way) to which thou callest them. Allah chooses to Himself those
whom He pleases, and guides to Himself those who turn (to Him).
This is
not, however, to say that the Islamic religion of Adam was the same in every
detail as that of Noah, or of Abraham, or of Moses, or of Jesus, or of Muhammad. In fact, it was not.
However, to understand that difference, one has to understand the Islamic
concepts of covenant and of progressive revelation.
Covenant
and Revelation
As noted
above, the Judeo-Christian tradition perceives the concept of covenant to
represent a fundamental re-ordering of the cosmos, in which the relationship
between mankind and Allah is completely redefined, and in which an entirely new
concept of religion is introduced. Covenants are thus seen as being few and far
between, represented only by: 1) the primitive or proto-covenant with Noah; 2)
the defining covenant with Abraham, which was exclusively inherited by Isaac, by
Jacob, and then by the Israelites; 3) the revision and elaboration of the
Abrahamic covenant with Moses, with inheritance of the covenant limited to
Israelites and Jews; and 4) the new covenant with Jesus, which for the first
time was open to participation by non-Jews.
In marked
contrast, Islam affirms a multiplicity of covenants between Allah and mankind.
Every prophet of Allah, most of whose names are not even known to contemporary
man, has had his own covenant, which was inherited by that prophet's people,
The following quotations from the Qur'an serve to illustrate this latter point.
(2:125) Remember
We made the House a place of assembly for men and a place of safety; and take
ye the station of Abraham as a place of prayer; and We covenanted with Abraham
and Isma'il, that they should sanctify My House for those who compass it round,
or use it as a retreat, or bow, or prostrate themselves (therein in
prayer)"
(3:81) Behold!
Allah took the covenant of the prophets, saying: "I give you a book and
wisdom; then comes to you a messenger, confirming what is with you; do you
believe in him and render him help." Allah said: "Do ye agree, and
take this my covenant as binding on you?" They said: "We agree."
He said: "Then bear witness, and I am with you among the witnesses."
(33:7) And remember We took from the
prophets their covenant: as (We did) from thee: From Noah, Abraham, Moses, and
Jesus the son of Mary: We took from them a solemn covenant.
Further, a
prophet of Allah was sent to every people, not just to the Israelites. There
are many passages in the Qur'an referring to the fact that a prophet was sent
to every people. The following represents a brief sample of those passages.
(6:42) Before
thee We sent (messengers) to many nations, and We afflicted the nations with
suffering and adversity, that they might learn humility
(10:47) To
every people (was sent) a messenger: when their messenger comes (before them),
the matter will be judged between them with justice, and they will not be
wronged.
(16:36) For
We assuredly sent amongst every people a messenger, (with the command),
"Serve Allah, and eschew evil": of the people were some whom Allah
guided, and some on whom error became inevitably (established). So travel
through the earth, and see what was the end of those who denied (the truth)
(35:24) For
We assuredly sent amongst every people, as a bearer of glad tidings, and as a
warner: and there never was a people, without a warner having lived among them
(in the past).
Thus,
between the time of Adam and Muhammad, covenants were plentiful, and were
non-exclusive. Every person, regardless of ethnic, national, or racial descent,
had the potential opportunity to inherit a covenant with Allah, and to enter
into a proper, worshipful relationship with Allah.
This concept
of a multiplicity of covenants is linked with the Islamic concept of
progressive revelation. Since each prophet received his own covenant with
Allah, the revelation of Allah as to how. best to worship Him was progressively
revealed over an evolutionary period. Unlike the cosmic re-orderings followed
by long periods of revelatory stagnation posited by the Judeo-Christian
tradition, Islam affirms a gradual evolution in the relationship between man
and Allah and in man's worship of Allah. Prior revelations could and were
modified, elaborated, and abrogated. In fact, such evolution and progressive
revelation occurred not only between prophets, but also within a given
prophet's own message and revelation. With regard to this, one needs only look
to the progressive revelation within the lifetime of Muhammad, which led from
no prohibition against alcohol, to prohibition against alcoholic consumption
interfering with the performance of mandatory prayers, to total prohibition of
alcohol. This concept of progressive revelation is summarized in the following
passages from the Qur'an.
(2:106) None
of Our revelations do We abrogate or cause to be forgotten, but We substitute
something better or similar: knowest thou not that Allah hath power over all
things?
(13:38) We
did send messengers before thee, and appointed for them wives and children: and
it was never the part of a messenger to bring a sign except as Allah permitted
(or commanded). For each period is a book (revealed). Allah doth blot out or
confirm what He pleaseth: with Him is the mother of the book.
(10:37) This
Qur'an is not such as can be produced by other than Allah; on the contrary it
is a confirmation of (revelations) that went before it, and a fuller
explanation of the book wherein there is no doubt-from the Lord of the worlds.
(16:101) When
We substitute one revelation for another-and Allah knows best what He reveals
(in stages)-they say, "Thou art but a forger": but most of them
understand not,
Given the
above, it can be seen that Islam began with Adam, gradually evolved through the
different covenants and progressive revelations given to the various prophets,
and finally culminated in the final revelation given to Prophet Muhammad. In
this regard, the contrasts between the Judeo-Christian and Islamic perspectives
are dramatic. The Judeo-Christian perspective posits a few stages of religious
evolution, each of which is markedly different than the one before it.
Metaphorically, one can compare the Judeo-Christian perspective to the drastic
revolutions involved in the developmental stages of the caterpillar, cocoon,
and butterfly. Each stage is fundamentally different in appearance than the
stage before it. In contrast, the metaphor for the Islamic perspective would be
that of the budding and opening of a flower, in which the message of Adam
represents the first budding'", and in which the final message of Muhammad
represents the flower in full bloom. However, even within that first bud of
Adam's message, there were two fundamental truths, which have never been
abrogated or modified, and which continued to be the centrepiece of the message
of every later prophet: I) there is no god but Allah, Who has no partners, and
Allah is to be worshipped and served'"; and 2) avoid evil and wickedness,
for there will be a day of final judgment.
The Role
of the Prophets
In order to
affect a proper comparison between the Judeo-Christian and Islamic
perspectives, this discussion of the role of the prophets is limited to those
prophets, who are recognized in some capacity by both the Judeo-Christian
tradition and by Islam. As noted previously, the Judaeo-Christian tradition
posits that these prophets were sent by Allah to call the backsliding
Israelites and Jews back to Judaism. In contrast, the Islamic perspective
affirms that these prophets represented the progressive revelation of Islam,
and were sent by Allah to bring the people back to Islam. However, many did not
listen to the prophets, did not repent of their ways, and did not return to
proper submission to Allah. Apostasy and deviation existed, and eventually
certain of these deviations came to be codified and ritualized. Such
codification and ritualizing of deviation from Islam were the origin of
Judaism, i.e. of one of the two branches of the People of the Book. This is
illustrated by the Qur'anic emphasis on the Jews having distorted and perverted
their revealed scriptures. In short, Judaism arose much after Islam, and was
the codified remains of deviation from Islam. As such, the prophets were not
sent to call the people back to Judaism, but were sent to call the people back
to Islam from Judaism, from other forms of deviation, and from frank unbelief.
(3:19) The
religion before Allah is Islam (submission to His will): nor did the People of
the Book dissent therefrom except through envy of each other, after knowledge
had come to them. But if any deny the signs of Allah, Allah is swift in calling
to account.
(42:13) The
same religion has He established for you as that which He enjoined on Noah-that
which We have sent by inspiration to thee-and that which We enjoined on
Abraham, Moses, and Jesus: namely, that ye should remain steadfast in religion,
and make no divisions therein: to those who worship other things than Allah,
hard is the (way) to which thou callest them. Allah chooses to Himself those
whom He pleases, and guides to Himself those who tum (to Him).
(42:14) And
they became divided only after knowledge reached them-through selfish envy as
between themselves. Had it not been for a word that went forth before from thy
Lord, (tending) to a term appointed, the matter would have been settled between
them: but truly those who have inherited the book after them are in suspicious
(disquieting) doubt concerning it.
One other
point of difference between the Judeo-Christian and Islamic perspectives on the
role of the prophets needs to be stated. As noted previously, the
Judeo-Christian perspective frequently portrays the prophets of Allah as being
backsliding sinners, who engaged in all manner of reprehensible behaviour. In
marked contrast, the Islamic perspective is that these prophets were men of
virtue, piety, and high moral character.
(3:161) No
prophet could (ever) be false to his trust.
Jesus
And The Origin Of Christianity
Islam
affirms the virgin birth of Jesus, but sees this not as an act of begetting,
but as an act of miraculous creation, caused by Allah's verbal command. The
following represents but one of several passages from the Qur'an that testifies
to the virgin birth of Jesus.
(3:45)
Behold! The angels said: "0 Mary! Allah giveth thee glad tidings of a word
from Him: his name will be Christ Jesus, the son of Mary, held in honor in this
world and the hereafter and of (the company of) those nearest to Allah; (46) He
shall speak to the people in childhood and in maturity. And he shall be (of the
company) of the righteous. (47) " She said: "0 my Lord! How shall I
have a son when no man hath touched me?" He said: "Even so: Allah
createth what He willeth: when He hath decreed a plan, He but saith to it,
'Be,' and it is!"
However, in
regard to the virgin birth, the miraculous origin of Jesus is seen as being
akin to the creation of Adam. Just as Jesus was without a father, so Adam,
having been created from the earth'", was without a father and a mother.
(3:59) The
similitude of Jesus before Allah is as that of Adam; He created him from dust,
then said to him: "Be": and he was."
Islam
affirms that Jesus was a prophet of Allah", and that Jesus was the Messiah
or Christ. However, Islam denies the crucifixion of Jesus'", and denies
the divinity of Jesus. Like those prophets of Israel before him, Jesus' message
and ministry were confined to the remnants of Israel and to the Jews, and were
a call to return to Islam and to proper submission to and worship of the
Oneness of Allah. It's worth noting that one part of the message of Jesus was
the prophecy of an additional prophet yet to come, who would be called Ahmad,
which is a variation of the name Muhammad.
(61:6) And
remember, Jesus, the son of Mary, said: "0 children of Israel! I am the
messenger of Allah (sent) to you, confirming the law (which came) before me,
and giving glad tidings of a messenger to come after me, whose name shall be
Ahmad." But when he came to them with clear signs, they said, "This
is evident sorcery!"
Jesus was
not the founder or originator of a new religion, or even of a new religious
movement within the Judaism of his times, but was one in a succession of
prophets of Allah to the people of Israel. Likewise, attempts to link Jesus
with this or that particular school of Judaic thought, whether Pharisaic,
Essenic, or other, are rejected, as they distort the fundamental truth that
Jesus was a prophet of Allah, who was bringing a portion of the progressive
revelation of Islam. All of which is not to say that there was no new component
to the message that Jesus brought. The Islamic concept of progressive
revelation allows for the possibility that the revelation to Jesus may have
partially altered, added to, or abrogated some parts of the revelations of
earlier prophets.
So, then
how does one account for the origin of Christianity? The Islamic answer is that
others, e.g., Paul of Tarsus, quickly distorted the message, ministry, and
gospel of Jesus. Probably, none of those who distorted Jesus' message had been
an eyewitness to Jesus' life and ministry, and none were actual disciples of
Jesus. The actual and complete gospel of Jesus is nowhere to be found in the
contemporary New Testament. However, bits and pieces of that gospel probably
have been preserved by subsequent "Christian" authors of the various
books of the New Testament, all of which were written two decades to one
century after the completion of Jesus' ministry, and none of which were likely
authored by anyone who had first hand contact with Jesus' actual ministry.
Additional fragments about the ministry of Jesus were probably preserved in
parts of the so-called apocrypha of the Christian era.
In short, just as distortions of earlier
revelations from Allah to the prophets had resulted in the formation of
Judaism, so distortions of the message of Jesus resulted in the formation of
Christianity.
(43:63) When
Jesus came with clear signs, he said: "Now have I come to you with wisdom,
and in order to make clear to you some of the (points) on which ye dispute:
therefore fear Allah and obey me. For Allah, He is my Lord and your Lord: so
worship ye Him: this is a straight way." But sects from among themselves
fell into disagreement: then woe to the wrongdoers, from the penalty of a
grievous day!
(5:14) From
those, too, who call themselves Christians, We did take a covenant, but they
forgot a good part of the message that was sent them: so We estranged them,
with enmity and hatred between the one and the other, to the Day of Judgement.
And soon will Allah show them what it is they have done,
(57:27) Then,
in their wake, We followed them up with (others of) Our messengers: We sent
after them Jesus the son of Mary, and bestowed on him the gospel; and We
ordained in the hearts of those who followed him compassion and mercy, but the
monasticism which they invented for themselves, We did not prescribe for them:
(We commanded) only the seeking for the good pleasure of Allah; but that they
did not foster as they should have done. Yet We bestowed, on those among them
who believed, their (due) reward, but many of them are rebellious
transgressors.
(As a brief
digression, it is interesting to note how the second passage above, with its
emphasis on the "enmity and hatred between the one and the other"
Christian groups appears to predict so accurately the abuses and barbarities
perpetrated by Christians upon Christians during the Protestant Reformation,
the origins of the Anabaptist movement, and the infamous Inquisition.)
Muhammad
and the Final Revelation of Islam
Muhammad
did not originate or create Islam, nor was Islam originated based on the
revelations given to Muhammad by Allah. Rather, Muhammad was the Seal of the
Prophets, i.e. the last in the line of Allah's prophets, just as a seal at the
end of a document is the last thing affixed to that document. It may be noted that
Westerners and adherents to the Judeo-Christian perspective frequently
attribute hierarchical significance to the title "Seal of the
Prophets", as though Muslims claim that Muhammad was the greatest or best
of the prophets of Allah. This type of thinking is contrary to Islam, and is
specifically prohibited by the Qur'an, which states that Muslims are to make no
hierarchical distinctions among the prophets of Allah. Like all the prophets
before him, Muhammad was not divine, but was only a man endowed with the
message of Allah.
However, it
was through the progressive revelation given to Muhammad that Islam was
perfected and completed. This revelation abrogated, elaborated, and altered
parts of the revelations given to earlier prophets, was memorized and written
down by the early companions of Muhammad, and became known as the Qur'an. Thus,
Islam finds its final evolution in the message of Muhammad, not its genesis.
Further, as the Seal of the Prophets, Muhammad was the
"international" prophet, bringing Allah's message not only to the
people of Muhammad, whether defined as Makkans, the members of the Quraish
tribe, or Arabs, but to the people of the world at large.
(25:57) Say:
"No reward do I ask of you for this (Qur'an), nor am I a pretender. This
is no less than a message to (all) the worlds.
Summary
The Islamic
perspective affirms the following evolution of Islam, Judaism, and
Christianity. Islam began with Adam, and has evolved in accordance with the
progressive revelations given by Allah to His various prophets. This evolution
of Islam finds its perfect culmination in the final revelations of Allah, which
were bestowed upon Prophet Muhammad. Early on, among the descendants of Prophet
Jacob, distortions of the basic message of Islam were codified and ritualized,
giving rise to the religion of Judaism. Subsequent prophets to the house of
Israel continually warned the Israelites and Jews to return to Islam, and to
forsake their deviations, which included Judaism, and their unbelief. Among
those prophets, whose ministry was limited to the Israelites and Jews, was
Jesus (the Messiah or Christ, and the son of the virgin Mary). However, Jesus'
message and ministry were also distorted, giving rise to such concepts as the
begotten son of God, the crucifixion of Jesus, and the trinitarian concept of
God. This distortion of the message of Jesus by Paul of Tarsus and others
became codified as Christianity.
Conclusions
Words are
sometimes deceiving in their ability to mislead others. This is especially the
case when words are used to represent abstract concepts or complex systems or
thoughts. As has been shown in the above discussion, words such as
"revelation", "covenant", "Judaism",
"Christianity", and "Islam" have radically different
meanings for Muslims, than they do for adherents to the traditional
Judeo-Christian perspective, which typically is the only viewpoint expressed in
Western academia. Likewise, names such as Jesus, Muhammad, Moses, Abraham,
etc., convey different images and associated concepts, depending upon the
religious orientation of the individual. By contrasting the Judaeo-Christian
and Islamic perspectives on the origins of Judaism, Christianity, and Islam,
some of these differences have been identified and discussed. Allah willing,
this endeavour may contribute to better and heightened communication among the
adherents of these three religious traditions.
-----
A frequent contributor to NewAgeIslam.com, Naseer
Ahmed is an Engineering graduate from IIT Kanpur and is an independent IT
consultant after having served in both the Public and Private sector in
responsible positions for over three decades. He has spent years studying Quran
in-depth and made seminal contributions to its interpretation.
URL: https://newageislam.com/interfaith-dialogue/judaism-christianity-origins/d/129206
New Age Islam, Islam Online, Islamic
Website, African Muslim News, Arab World News, South Asia News, Indian Muslim News, World Muslim News, Women in Islam, Islamic Feminism, Arab Women, Women In Arab, Islamophobia in America, Muslim Women in West, Islam Women and Feminism