Books and Documents

From the Desk of Editor (26 May 2016 NewAgeIslam.Com)


  • Daear Aayina:

    I had a simple question for you as you used to ask dozens of questions to others.

    If Abdullah means a Muslim, Aayina means what ???

    You are a Diploma holder in manipulating the points in hundreds of way, but you will not answer a simple question where you are stuck in rough weather.

    Please don't try to involve unconcerned people in your reply. You are FAKE, accept it and don't judge others by a name.

    What 's in a name?

    By Abdullah - 8/22/2016 10:35:12 AM

  • To Abdullah
    भाई अल्ला के ९९ नाम है, तो मेरे दो होने मे क्या है।
    रेह गया असली नाम का तो हमरा इस website पे Manzural Haque नाम के पीर है, वो बोहत सारे को fake कह चूके, इस website के Editor Sultan shahin तक नक़ली है। 

    हम इस पीर Manzural Haque के कबसे मुरीद हुवे बैठे है। ऐ मेरी सच्चाइ जानते होगे, इनके मुरीद बन जावो, ये जैसे Sultan Shain fake है वैसे मेरे जैसे सारे Fake के बारे मे बता देन्ग।
    कहा सूना माफ़ करना

    By Aayina - 8/22/2016 5:33:25 AM

  • Dear Aayina
    Don't assume anyone by name as more than 50% commentators are fake by name. Take your example .... Aayina - may I assume you are an object or a robot as you like to rant the information fed in your system only.

    By Abdullah - 8/21/2016 3:11:48 AM

  • To

    Well You are Muslim, Muslims are concerned with only condemning westerner for everthing, they you cannot see other biggest fascist force Saudi-Arabia, and Pakistan because of their Muslim population.

    But I am not surprised with your mindset.

    By Aayina - 8/20/2016 1:07:12 PM

  • Dear Aaina
    You are escaping from the harsh realities as such gundagiri and luteragiri are being done by US Russia France UK and other fascist forces ... latest example is SYRIA 

    By Abdullah - 8/20/2016 5:18:11 AM

  • India is the only place this gundagiri and loteragiri Muslims for centuries going had to stopped and started to change narrative of Quran and try to make peaceful under the influence of Hindus otherwise Arabs are still doing gundagiri and loteragiri, latest example is  is ISIS.

    Khudko to nahi baldlte par Quran Ko baldlte he, Indian Muslim should inspired from this quote of Iqbal to change themselves to became like ISIS, as they are saying their source is Quran, Sunnah and Hadits 

    By Aayina - 8/11/2016 3:29:27 AM

  • India was only Muslim kingdom where Muslims break as many temples they can break.

    India is the only place where Hindus of local land  fight bitterly with Muslims.

    Muslims invaded India, but then started to use marriage as tactic to remain in power otherwise muslim would have faced more tougher time, very cheap always use women's for all things to show power.

    By Aayina - 8/11/2016 3:20:54 AM

  • This is the toughest question in the syllabi - for an examiner to examine it's answer. For this reason I have to keep answering to the examiner every now and then. India allowing Muslims..., ha , ha, ha ! India was the only Muslim kingdom for 700 years to allow Hindus to live as a majority. India was made by Muslims, politically as well as geographically. On the other hand baniyagiri under British or Western tutelage does not confer residency rights. Now somebody is asking the question again. My answer is - no, because it takes two to tango ! In fact Muslims will find even harder to co-exist with the 27 th century mindset, the way the leg-spin of the other leg is trending. Only few electrons of the outer orbit may co-exist by quantum jumping to the spinner's side !
    By Manzurul Haque - 8/10/2016 11:50:23 AM

  • The second great prophet in Islam whose name is mentioned 25 times in Holy Koran. said “You shall know the truth, the truth will set you free” Sultan Sahin tries to bring us some truth so that people can live with less tension and hatred and develop good relationship with others in the 21st century.

    Muslims in the West have become less radicalised towards US and Israel. They know that US lost 400,000 soldiers in WWII to redeem the world from Nazism and fascism. Again US lost more than 100,000 soldiers in Korean and Vietnam wars in order to defeat Communism. While Soviet Union kept East Germany, US helped West Germany to establish democracy in West Germany and it became the 4th largest economy in the world, similarly Japan became 3rd  largest economy and South Korea the 11th largest. US wanted to establish democracy in Iraq as a model in the Middle East but failed miserably. Muslims with sunny-shia divide, love for dictatorship reacted differently: still no one could find an alternative leader for Bashir Assad, Saddam Hussain, or Hosni Mubarak, Colonel Gadhafi. That is the curse in the Middle East, for dictators never allow anyone to compete with them. However tiny Sri Lankan democracy found an alternative leader who now supports India not China.

    Muslims in the West also know that the total population of Jews is only 14 million against 1600 million Muslims. 6 million in US and another 6 million in Israel. The UNO after the massacre of 6 million Jews in gas chambers helped Jews to establish Israel in their ancient land where many of their prophets were born. Its area is only 9000 sq. miles compared to 5 million sq. miles of Arab lands.

    Muslims in the West ask why the ulemma is so much bothered about the plight of the Palestinians when 35 millions of Kurdish Muslims in the four adjoining Islamic countries are left in the lurch. Instead of finding a way to grant regional autonomy Turkey started bombing Kurdish Muslims. This has aggravated the already tense situation in the Middle East and received terrorist attacks in Turkish cities. Is this not a curse of Allah?.

    You shall know the truth, the truth will set you free.

    My clarion call is that we can’t claim to love Allah while we hate His creatures and abuse them.

    By Royalj - 6/21/2016 5:22:38 AM

  • Dear Aayina: I see you as a moderate intellectual concerned for the safety and progress of all. I demanded your comments as I appreciate and like to read you in any thread. अल्लाह करे जोर ए कलम और हो ज्यादा Thanks 
    By Raihan Nezami - 6/20/2016 8:19:54 AM

  • To
    Raihan Nezami

    What you want to know from me. I did not understand well.

    I have always said to you in my comments, you can disagree on me, that is should be seen as beauty of nature.

    trees, animals and lots of thing differ in look and habits even within one spices of animal and plant  differ each other.

    Not agreeing my point of view is not going to devalue you and me.

    As long as you disagree with me I am happy, but sometime I feel you are just seeing me negatively or may fearing that talking to Hindu fanatic, that is worrying for me and my Hindu community.

    You need to understand that I am Hindu( not non-Muslim)  and I write on this website, not to devalue you Muslim, but I write what I feel, if I do not feel safe or fear of Muslim, than you have to introsprect what is wrong within you and your community, 

    similarly if another person or mass of people does not feel safe or fear from me I fell I am not human, because every other animal fear from animal that has हैवानियत, I feel I am हैवान.

    Certainly I am not RSS or fanatic Bhagva member as you commented in other comment. Wearing Bhagva or Bhagvati रंग में भीगना is different than Bhagva brigade.

    By Aayina - 6/20/2016 4:55:53 AM

  • Mr Aayina: I'm still waiting for your response upon my last comment replying to some of your points.
    By Raihan Nezami - 6/18/2016 4:57:46 PM

  • Excellent article. It requires lot of courage. 

    What makes us different from all other species is our intelligence. It is intelligence that helps us establish what is right and what is wrong. Right and Wrong are the tools that were given to us by Allah the Creator of the Universe to elucidate through the times of times, how to survive and thrive. Intelligent people will always ask the right kind of question. Mr. Sultan Sahin asks the following questions:

    With Our 7th Century Mind-Set, Can We Muslims Co-Exist With Other Religious Communities In Any Part Of The World? Can we blame right wingers in Europe and America, asking for a ban on Muslims’ entry into their countries? Will Indian Ulema respond to the outrage of ISIS? (The horror scenes, styles of killing, sexual slavery etc.)

    The problem that many of us face is Madrasa education doesn't encourage asking questions nor critical thinking.

    Those who claim to love Allah should desist from harming His most beautiful creation, whether by killing the apostates or  others.

    By Royalj - 6/17/2016 12:32:03 PM

  • Dear Aayina
    I agree with you on the point of the Muslims' intolerant behaviour towards minority that's evident by the recent killing of a Hindu saint in Bangladesh as well as in Pakistan since long ago and other Muslims' majority states as well. 
    Your concern about Muslim's outnumbering the Hindus in India is irrational as in the light of the fact that the Muslim's financial status in our country is so weak that they are equal to Schedule Tribes in jobs percentage, monitory share of the country. In present situation, the Muslims can't feed more than one or two kids, how stupid is this idea that twenty crore Muslims will try to outnumber hundred crore Hindus by producing more kids to take over the country.
    If Mr Togaria or Mr Singhal express this concern, it's digestable as it's an important ploy of their anti-Muslim strategy, but I can't expect from an educated person like you.
    I differ from you on the point of Love Jihad -  the name given by RSS group to the inter-caste marriages in India. The negative impact of this political tool being used by RSS and AIMIM for the vote bank strategy will never allow our cultures to assimilate in near future. I don't think our youth will involve in such stupid inter-caste love-affairs or even arranged-marriages which will prove to be fatal for their lives and divisive for the society and country as well. Our prime minister is obtaining massive accolades and standing ovations in U.S for scientific and nuclear achievements, but we are far from being considered one community assimilated in real sense and showing unity in diversity.
    Our youth are not going to risk their lives for the sake of LOVE which may be blind, but they aren't........

    By Raihan Nezami - 6/8/2016 3:04:22 PM

  • To
    Raihan Nezami

    The co-existence of Muslims and Hindu will only exist until Muslim will outnumber Hindus, as we Hindu as majority do not mind it, but with Muslims as majority  it is not possible.

    We had Pakistan and Bangladesh created with minority Hindus as well like Muslims in India stayed back with Idea of co-existence.

    May be your Indian Muslim forefathers had different choice than current Indian Muslim generation, even if they want to stay they are waiting to outnumber Hindus.

    Muslim in majority never allowed to live minority in same equality as Muslims.

    Kashmiri pandit were thrown out of Kashmir there is no out cry for that from Indian muslim sides, but for Gujarat or Muzaffarnagar and lot others is lots of outcry by so called Indian Muslims.

    Muslims in nature cannot be secular and democratic.

    About MUSLIM LOVE BOY: Here is understanding from long history of living with Indian Muslim, if Muslim boy fell in love with girl of other faith than she has to convert to Muslim, many times girl is not brain washed to convert but made sure kids will be certainly be Muslim, that is the reason I have written that we can co-exist but in seperate group (in seperate Mohllas) not as neighbour.

    There can be exception were even child is allowed to follow any religion he or she want even if father is Muslim. 

    Well you can deny the fact you can

    let me clear I am not supporter of RSS or any extreme Hindu Idelogical group.

    I think the day Hindu became like Muslim that any one married to Hindu has to convert to Hindu or child must, it will start downfall of Hindus ideologically, intelcually and morally as well.

    Well Muslim can follow their arrogance.

    Their can be lot of atrocities happen to Muslims in India but that does not mean that their irrational arrogance behaviours in relation to marriage cannot be condemnable.

    By Aayina - 6/8/2016 2:02:28 AM

  • Dear Aayina: The Hindus and Muslims in general, have been quite tolerant and sensible so as we, the Indians, have learnt to live together in a mutual and coherent manner. Barring a few stray incidents, when political parties create communal tension to garner political mileage that is evident now a days in U.P due to forthcoming elections in 2017. The Muslims of India don't believe in arrogance or totalitarian theory of religion., that's why we respect all religions equally and it's recommended even none other than by our prime minister.
    I'm sorry I couldn't follow your idea of MUSLIM LOVE BOY.

    By Raihan Nezami - 6/7/2016 7:30:41 AM

  • To Raihan Nezami: Yes Indian Muslim should co-exist, but in seperate area as whole group.
    The only fear is that, a Muslim boy love always became important and after marriage only another Muslim child will come out, which make whole Hindu community.
    This also put another question why we Hindus  should study with Muslim boys in school.
    This phenomena is not only now persisting in India but now whole over world.
    Muslims are proud of hurting the whole family of other faith.
    I wish Muslim remains arrogant in matter of faith, which will help other communities of different faith to remain away from them.

    By Aayina - 6/7/2016 3:57:40 AM

  • 'Can Muslims with 7th century  mindset coexist with the followers of other religious communities?' Under this debate, which has been conducted many times before too, many commentators have expressed their views in favour or against it.

    Generally speaking,  Muslim readers are in favour and the Non-Muslim readers are against the motion.

    A remarkable point can be observed in these more than two hundred comments that the question still lies fully unattended and unanswered or I can say no party is able to convince the other one as people avoid looking into the prevailing situation to realise the bare facts regarding the Muslims' positions in the world in general and specifically in India. The Muslims have been living in India for almost a millennium or so quite peacefully in a harmonious atmosphere and are mingling with other followers, as well.

    I am not interested in talking here about the anti-Arab, anti-Islam strategies or anti-Muslim policies adopted by the Americans and Europeans long ago which backfired and subsequently became a terror for them. It provided them another chance to inflict further atrocities upon the Muslims in Syria and elsewhere.
    Coming to the point of co-existence of Muslims in India. I too feel and believe like our prime minister does  who asserted in UAE that the Muslims of India can not be affected by terror dittoed by our home minister.
     Recently a Hindu leader opined that Hindus are more involved in terror activities than the Muslims. For example, one can check the anti-social activities being organised by RSS, RAM SENA, GO-RAKSHA VAHINI etc involving immature brains, products of the schools where
    their brain is polluted with hatred and poison against the Muslims.
     Does this behaviour qualify the Hindus to co-exist with the followers of other religions? Had it been done by the Muslims in madarsas, the same Hindu outfits might have attacked the madarsas and killed many people.
    The Muslims are just  watching everything like mute spectators as they know their voice will not be heard anywhere. It is the real difference between the behaviour and practice of the Hindus and the Muslims, but the problem is, the people with vested interests will not assert or approve it but follow the BJP 's strategies of creating hullaballoo over the anti-national issues of 'YOGA', 'BHARAT MATA KI JAI', 'VANDE MATRAM' etc to create disharmony among the citizens dividing them to gain the political mileage.
    Another important point is - various Muslim organisations' heads of Sunni Bareilvis, Shias and Deobandees have declared terror outfits as Un-Islamic and against humanity even Imam-e-Makkah has declared ISIS, AL-QAIDA and other violent groups are not religious, but very few people remember it.
    The denouncement of any activity of RSS is remembered and highlighted by all. Reason being,  they don't want to lose the chance of attacking on Islam.
    What more Indian Muslims are required to do to be certified by the Islamophobes to be able to coexist with others - they are already dressing up like Europeans, speaking Hindi or slang languages,  eating all sorts of food stuffs even those banned in Islam, except BEEF that' is not allowed by Ram Sena in India, rarely going to mosque except on Fridays or thronging to mosques during Ramzan to grab the heavy offer by Allah in this month, celebrating Holi,  Diwali, Christmas, New Year etc.
    I think the Muslims of India have all the qualities  of being eligible to coexist with others anywhere in the world.

    By Raihan Nezami - 6/6/2016 7:55:34 AM

  • Like the Hindus, the pre-Islamic Arabs believed in survival of the human personality after death. They too believed in the 
    transmigration of souls. The whole of the pagan Arab homeland, like medieval India, was honeycombed with temples dedicated to hundreds of deities 
    with as many names and forms.Every oasis, every grove, every locality had its own presiding deity. Every family had its ancestral deities.
    Immediately after the conquest of Mecca, the Kaba which had been a pagan temple for so long having 360 deities was placed out of bounds for the pagan 

    Arabs. It was converted into a place of Muslim worship. All the idols and paintings were destroyed in Kaba. Ali was asked to break the idols of Isaf 
    and Naila outside the Kaba in Mecca. After purifying Mecca, the Prophet sent 'expeditions to those idols which were in the neighbourhood and had them 

    destroyed; these included Al-Uzza, Manat, Suwa, Buana and Dhul-Kaffayn.' The idol of Al-Lat at Taif was destroyed by al-Mughira. 
    Obviously, iconoclasm is integral to the Islamic ideology.

    By Pranav Kumar - 6/6/2016 2:47:11 AM

  • Where is the silence.??? The ulema have said it already in many words loud and clear how Isis is unislamic. Infact some people who did try 
    joining us is, their own parents informed the police. This is how clear every Muslim is about Isis and any other

    By Asim Afzal - 6/6/2016 2:11:19 AM

  • Guys urge everyone to remain calm and in peace. Don't argue with Muslims as rightfully penned down by an Australian named Rob. I'm very aware of Islams world war, and I know every devout Muslim is a threat to our democracy. Because every true Muslim must folow the teachings of the 
    Qur'an, and those teachings say to do what ever it takes to move in and take over countries until the entire world is under Islamic rule.

    By Mithun Kundu - 6/6/2016 2:01:37 AM

  • Kalas There doesn't exist any India mujahedeen it is a fake name carved to terrorize and torture Muslims at will by you like anti humanity and tension monger propagandists to provoke communal tension in India. 

    By DrMohammed Farooq - 6/6/2016 1:43:31 AM

  • It is surprising that now in the 20th century people like Dolly are appreciating the barbaric act of Isis or AL kaida.Seriya is a Muslim 
    country and see their conditions. Muslims looting muslims,beheading them,shooting in groups etc.

    By U.p. Ojha - 6/6/2016 1:31:37 AM

  • Islam is a threat to humanity and world peace. it can not coexist with any religion for a very simple reason. Only one religion Called 
    Islam claimsbthat that therir God is greatest. Allah hoo akbar. This clearly means that all other gods are false. They also claims that their book called Quran is only book from god and all other books are written by man. Any one with this mindset can never integrate with rest of the world.

    By Suresh Dixit - 6/6/2016 1:18:53 AM

  • To Anyone: Anyone who can answer the question asked to sultan shahin.

    What is source of Quran or Hadees that will not allow any born Muslim to leave religion or converted.
    To remain shun on the question does not make Quran less valid. 
    I was asking this question to only Sultan Shahin but I made it open to all Muslim, any muslim or scholar of Muslim can reply on the question I have asked.
    Please cherry pickers do not reply, I wish that the one who systmetically prove that born Muslims or converted Muslims cannot change relgion with help of Quran or Hadees reply.

    By Aayina - 6/6/2016 1:07:27 AM

  • The day Indian Muslims put nation above religion and condemn the fringe Muslim groups spreading venom against the country is when the non Muslims will believe you. You have so much intolerance towards others that even chanting Bharath Mata Ki Jai is bad for you. Do you know what is preached in Madrasas of West Bengal, Kerala and Hyderabad? Stop that first before talking about others. If you can't be true to your country you can be true to none including Islam. Bharath Mata Ki Jai

    By Rajeswaran Rajagopal - 6/6/2016 12:19:27 AM

  • @abdul salam sahab thanks for your comments but i think it is your business to understand islam and allah it is your duty to let other 
    non muslim population know what bright side of islam is

    By B.s. Chauhan - 6/6/2016 12:18:30 AM

  • And yes sir regarding islam religion we keep following the rules of 6 century ant times because it teaches us peacr loving neighbour dowry systems respect women marruy women with their consent and with their parents consent it teaches to avoid wasteful expenditure it teaches nt to cosume alchol it teaches love to your neighbour it teaches to 2% percent charity of our wealth it teaches against homesexulaty it give right to property two dauggters in fathers property it teaces rights of women it teaches to be fair in all your affairs and what not sir it also gives permissipn to kill those who show disrespect to Our beloved prophet mohammad pboh

    By Shafeeq Mohammad - 6/6/2016 12:08:08 AM

  • ALL muslims in India , Pakistan. Bangladesh , Sri Lanka , Malaysia , Indonesia etc. are AFZAAL Their fore fathers were Hindus. They were forced to convert to Islam. ...See More

    By Jayaraman Subri - 6/5/2016 11:55:54 PM

  • Stalin Vanangamudi.Non Muslims r celebrating Your air Polluting festival Deepavali in Muslim countries for eg Indonesia ,  Malaysia, Bangladesh ,Dubai etc .Christmas is celebrated in all the Muslim countries of the world because the Christians r the largest minority in 
    those countries, Christianity is the biggest religion after Islam.

    By Najmunisa Enayathulla - 6/5/2016 11:55:04 PM

  • @William Castelino muslims dnt need suggestion and cerifacate from fool like you think tertorist are just killing non muslims muslims 
    too are the victims of terrorism

    By Shafeeq Mohammad - 6/5/2016 11:52:53 PM

  • The idea of jihad is absurd.Muslims first of all follow Islam in its true sprit along with Sirate Mustafa.They have to become first complete Muslim as Muslims of past by getting knowledge of Islam and science and Teechnology .The whole World will embrace Islam without any Blood shed.
    By Abdul Wahab Ansari - 6/5/2016 1:17:32 PM

  • All Kafirs You outsiders destroyed our most advanced indus valley civilisations and claiming to be real indians aciting as if you have given shelter to Muslims.Sir we Muslims accepted Islam our religion and we are the actual Indians not like you outsiders. Mughals or other Muslim rulers may b looted this country or not it but we Muslims,adivasis,dalits are the real indians.we are living here by choice not by default.And Mr whoever you are what do mean by 7th century mindset.You Aryans get out of my country.......
    By Azhar Salim - 6/5/2016 1:11:54 PM

  • Before Islam the society of Arabs were worse , murdering and raping is general ,murdering of their daughters ,beating and murdering of wives ,they use to marry as they want no limit 50 ,100 etc , wars between one tribe to others is general after war they killed men of enemy tribe and take custody of women for slavery and sex slavery , purchasing and selling of slaves and girls , big drinkers etc ,in short Arabs society were so barbaric and uncivilised that no one even want to rule on them , we r in 21 st century but system of slavery ,selling and purchasing of girls, prostitution ,killing of female child's , killings of innocent people in war ,I think today's humans r more barbaric than old ones because today some countries r bombarding on civilians no hesitation in killing children and women ,no hesitation in using atom bombs etc ,honour killings still going on today humans calling themselves civilised society but I think the conditions r same.

    So at that time Arabs were so uncivilised and barbaric after the coming of Islam and Quran they started some type of humanity ,one person came to prophet and start crying and said oh prophet before accepting Islam I killed my three daughters two of them were in her early ages and I killed my one Daughter when she was 8 years old when I ready to put her in grave she told me oh father u r killing me because I am a girl and he started crying more loudly , prophet said now u pray to god for mercy and live your rest life with good deeds and Allah has most gracious and merciful ,so after coming of Islam Arabs finished slowly all their bad habits ,in short after Islam Arabs start to live like humans .

    By Faiz Ahmad - 6/5/2016 1:10:21 PM

  • @Krishnan Ram u r jumping from nursary class to direct graduation one person wrote that the writer of Quran doesn't know the simple mathematics but he had not any knowdge that Quran is so advance that u requires the formula of Bodmas to get the write answer of Qur'anic equations , if u interested in Quran than first study hole Quran step by step than come to conclusion , one place in Quran Says do not go for prayer it means Quran is saying don't go for prayer but all Muslims use to go for prayers for five times , but the verse continuous and says do not go for prayer when u r in alcholic mode, so it is very easy to play with words ,miscoating of Quran hadees and misunderstanding of Quran and hadees is general practice of some people , In Mahabharat Krishna said to Arjun kill your relatives ( because the war is going on in relatives ) so for foolish people it means Krishna is saying kill your relatives but for clever and wise man it is understanding that kill your relatives in war don't show sympathy otherwise they kill u , so Krishna said only for war not in normal life . Grow up dears don't try to make fool to yourself and others.
    By Faiz Ahmad - 6/5/2016 12:45:48 PM

  • #Faiz could u explain what the hell is this...May be some infidel had adulterated Quran and Hadith, without the knowledge of Muslims...
    Prophet on killing of children...
    The Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) used not to kill the children, so thou shouldst not kill them unless you could know what Khadir had known about the child he killed, or you could distinguish between a child who would grow up to be a believer, so that you killed the non-believer and left the (prospective) believer aside. (Sahih Muslim 4457)
    Oh..Prophet! We have made lawful to thee thy wives to whom thou hast paid their dowers; and those whom thy right hand possesses out of the prisoners of war whom Allah has assigned to thee;..." - Quran 33.50
    Bukhari (84:57) - [In the words of] "Allah's Apostle, 'Whoever changed his Islamic religion, then kill him.'"
    Sahih Bukhari 9/50 
    Mohammed said, " No Muslim should be killed for killing a Kafir" (infidel).

    By Krishnan Ram - 6/5/2016 12:39:40 PM

  • It is surprising and horrible that now a days millions of people throughout the world has no work but doing lot of efforts to defame Islam ,even they creat a terrorist groups like Isis ,boko haram etc gave the name of Muslims but operated by antiislamic powers and even they have not much interest in their own religion but very much interested in defaming Islam , but dispite of these heavy efforts there tryings r going wasted , because people of world converting very fastly into Islam ,Allah says in Quran "They played a trick and I also". And antiislamic People trying to propogate that Quran is saying for killings but what Quran says in actuality " If u killed a single innocent person is as like u killed hole of humanity and if u saved a single innocent human being is as like u saved hole of humanity ". And their is capital punishment for mudring and raping etc. So Islam is very strict on mischeives . Islam haters always busy in miscoating Quran and hadees , Quran says oh human beings beaware from the blazing flames of hell ,humans and stones r the fuel for hell fire. And says " They want to cheat Allah but they can't but they r cheating with theirselfs.
    By Faiz Ahmad - 6/5/2016 12:38:46 PM

  • Dear Aaiyina,  religious freedom is indivisible. Universal.  In Islam or Quran there is just one rule for all. "No Compulsion in religion." La Ikraha fid Deen. That's all. 
    Religion of ulema is however different. 

    By Sultan Shahin - 6/5/2016 9:46:53 AM

  • To Sultan Shahin
    I read your comment about my Question:
    what is the source of Quran for ulema that will not allow Muslims to leave Islam if born as Muslim.
    My Question Is simple where is source from Quran( I expect the answer from Quran) or Hadees( which can be true or fabricated).
    I did not want to know what was said for non-Muslim, I want know we're it said for Muslim not leave or convert to other religion, 
    so can you simply say that Quran or Hadees not say so or it is silence  or it says something on leaving Islam rather than saying something else.
    Any other scholars can also reflect on this matter, but my question is straight to Sultan Shahin.

    By Aayina - 6/4/2016 1:54:52 AM

  • There is no such new Islam,medieval Islam , old Islam,Islam is Islam and it's principles are based on peace with dignity which should be
    maintained by Muslims even at cost of their lives.

    By Khalid Shah - 6/3/2016 6:16:05 AM

  • We have in present day scenario nobody arround to be like, Hazarat Ibrahim (as) Mosa (as), Christ (as) prophet Mohammad (phuh) 
    Aristotle , socrates, Galalieo, plato. So you can't camper that period to this age of hippocracy, sexual indiscipline, exploitation. Those people 

    single handedly saved humanity and today even countries mentain silence over mascares for businesses interests or kill thousands for businesses 
    interests. Let you raise a voice for Rohit Vimal then I can appriciate otherwise I will think about you a writer engaged by establishment to praise 
    the king.

    By M Sultan Lone - 6/3/2016 6:05:08 AM

  • I agree Muslim world need an overhaul in their outlook if they have to come at par with other co religionists in the 21st century

    By Ashaq Lily - 6/3/2016 5:48:09 AM

  • I am shocked theft literate people take such ansrrow stand. Indian Muslims never supported Isis or any such organisation. Coming yo Indian Mujsheedeen ask them why have taken to arms against their own country. Those who blame should find out why our young people are going stray. There can be no justified excuse but that format mean that in the interest of the country we must openly talk to them as citizens not as terrorists that they turn to be

    By Zamiruddin - 6/3/2016 5:46:26 AM

  • i fully agree with this comment:
    "For yor kind information IsIs is origination of israel jews there leader is jew who is taught arabic and trained well to behave 
    like .muslim,.the whole idea behind this plan is to defame the muslims and islam..and thereby paint and project the face of the muslims as terrorist..this is already proved..but media never pripogate this"

    And their target is to defame Islam, that is why they are spending billions of dollars to defame teachings of islam, hadees, and they hire people for their business of defaming islam.

    By Shahid - 6/3/2016 5:42:55 AM

  •  I am a Hindu brahmin and don't know much about Islam. However, I know MUSALMAN means musolai Iman. A man with strong integrity. Jihad as I understand is the process of blooming like a flower to attract other people through your fragnance. Not killing people. Killing is the work of Satan. How can one reach the Almighty following the path of Satan? So friends, please consider, your country needs your cooperation. World needs your help. Arise, consider and help human beings to live together in peace. If someone wants to fight let him fight without involving the name of any religion. Live peacefully and let others live in peace. May God bless all.

    By Upendra Chandra Mishra - 6/3/2016 5:15:23 AM

  • For yor kind information IsIs is origination of israel jews there leader is jew who is taught arabic and trained well to behave 
    like .muslim,.the whole idea behind this plan is to defame the muslims and islam..and thereby paint and project the face of the muslims as terrorist..this is already proved..but media never pripogate this

    By Abdul Baqi Siddiqui - 6/3/2016 5:11:59 AM

  • Indian mujahedin isis or taaliban actually they have nothing to do with islam its a propaganda group against the islam and supported by America & Israel

    By Ahsan Alam - 6/3/2016 4:57:55 AM

  • Interpretation of what the religious texts say has to be done in conjunction with the need of the time. How can u abide strictly by the word written ages ago? We have to stick to the basics which all religions prescribe ie. There is one god, to hurt another is bad, all are equal in the eyes of the creator, respect all. Simple but why then this killing in the name of god. If god wanted this why would he have created persons of
    different creeds.

    By Anil Sharma - 6/3/2016 4:33:45 AM

  • Every muslim, sickulars, prestitutes, intellectuals etc says isis is created by america & Israel but when isis flag unfurls in kashmir on every friday after namaz everybody keep silence why? Why there is no shooting/stone pelting? Because terrorism is in their blood

    By Prakash S Hullur - 6/3/2016 4:30:28 AM

  • All those who are against Islam are really sane & Idiots. They have not read the holy Qura'n even once in life & till death. And 
    advocating against Islam, this is enough do not blame the real world. Sorry to say All of you are expressing your idiotic views this simply shows 
    yours intolerant temporament against Islam.

    By AL Misbah Rehman - 6/3/2016 3:47:04 AM

  • They are truly fanatic as they have a strong but mistaken religious believe. I don't know exactly what is written in the Quran but the silence maintained by the moderate Muslims towards the violence acts of other Muslims corroborates the fact of Quran. If this is literally true, then it could spell disastrous for the entire World.

    By Premjoy Babu - 6/3/2016 2:38:08 AM

  • NEW AGE ISLAM has to emerge by clearing the contrdictions present in the religious book of Islam . In fact the Quaran in the hand and 
    mind of common muslim is no more a valid or Aslee Quaran . The world oldest Quaran is kept in the musium of Menchester university at Britain .

    By Akt Ecologist - 6/3/2016 1:54:02 AM

  • Thx. for thinking from a rational and secular perspective. Wish such positive approach and rational thinking will spread through entire world irrespective of religion and save the most noble religion of the world that is humanity.

    By Chinmoy Ghosh - 6/3/2016 1:33:55 AM

  • Islamisation is considered a possible civilisation and a mission ..at least by some believers. Doing away with kaaffir or infidels thus become

    By Kuruvila Abraham - 6/3/2016 1:21:42 AM

  • Reform is the need of hour. And we appreciate these saner voices to be more and more louder we can't hide the truth. These verses," 

    Then,when the sacred months have passed, slay the idolaters wherever ye find them and take them captive and besiege them...See More

    By DrPitambar Aryan - 6/3/2016 12:36:46 AM

  • Yes don't blame Riot wingers for targeting Muslims. Don't blame them for killing Muslim. After all Muslims are responsible for everything.

    By AIMIM - 6/3/2016 12:28:23 AM

  • Humanity is one... It is neither only Islum, nor Christian,nor Hindu, nor Jewish.But conglomeration of all religions, caste,community and so on.

    By Mukul Dev - 6/3/2016 12:01:19 AM

  • Islam has to reproduce itself. I know there are intelligent people in Islam. Others should follow them.

    By CA Kishan Derasari - 6/2/2016 11:59:33 PM

  • That is the problem. The educated and liberal thinking people from the community does not object Jihadi themes or who propagate it 
    boldly. This is what alienating this community across the world.

    By Pradip Choudhuri - 6/2/2016 11:48:51 PM

  • Sultan Shahin is agent of Indian securities agencies and UN. He favourite job to misguide Muslims. Infact he is a comerade of New world order.

    By Mohd. Khan - 6/2/2016 11:43:08 PM

  • Those asking to see this fatwa or that fatwa are trying to defend indefensible as we all know this is eyewash. Listen to warning 
    and heed to it for world peace.

    By Krishna Kumar Saboo - 6/2/2016 11:39:54 PM

  • America and e.u will soon stop Muslims migrating to their mainland..... Some one has to take the responsibility

    By Rahul Singh - 6/2/2016 11:34:21 PM

  • I heard many such intellectuals and educated Muslims sitting in a debate on a news channel and questing the authenticity of the video. 
    None of them condemned it ..... Rather they tried to divert the issue be taking about the Batla House encounter..... Great intellectuals are 

    By Rakesh Ranjan - 6/2/2016 11:29:13 PM

  • Peacefuls have overtaken the Nazi's. Eliminate religion from politics (sharia). Or else, u will not let others live and u too will not live.

    By Krishnan Ram - 6/2/2016 11:21:30 PM

  • @Suresh Dixit ur ill inform there were four book fro. Allah toura tabut ingeel and quran before commenting about some thing please get the knowlede about it

    By Shafeeq Mohammad - 6/2/2016 11:06:53 PM

  • That is enough that you alone are maligning the whole community who know nothing about the Indian mujahideen, only the chamcha of bhakts like you know about them.

    By Moin Barbhuiya - 6/2/2016 6:45:55 AM

  • jealous with muslim ,kalam sahab or rafi sahab or ar rahman sahab .why are Mr modi not ask this question with kalam sahab about islam or muslim .then he give reply ,you people like barking dogs .nomatic tribe crowd.

    By Mohd Salman Shivani - 6/2/2016 6:29:40 AM

  • Terrorism is just terrorism...relegion has nothing to do with it..I don't see any body talking about,Hindu terrorism in North India, 
    Christian terrorism in Iraq and elsewhere,Jewish terrorism everywhere they live,budhist terrorism in Burma.?.just vested interest nothing else

    By Zubair Konikkal - 6/2/2016 6:22:19 AM

  • We have to choose between Dr kalam &isis..due to fanaticism islam could not give any scientific invention..aeroplane....to mobile.logic has no place.blackburkha still covers faces of our women !!!!cruelest pchyocholigical slavery

    By Brijesh Singh - 6/2/2016 6:21:04 AM

  • Absolutely right. Even the educated muslims have such thoughts. A doctor by proffesion asked me once should I wear burkha or not. I 

    replied people dont bother. Rather they would be surprised to see a doctor in burkha. Mediveal ideas still persists in so called better off muslims 

    what should one say about the radicals. They are being ghettoed.

    By Vasant Kumar Nair - 6/2/2016 6:00:09 AM

  • Its duty of moderates Muslims to fight with fanatics before it is too late to stand up against them.

    By Vijay Tiwari - 6/2/2016 5:44:51 AM

  • It's the need of the time all countries unite and irradicate this menace called ISIS, drop a nitrogen bomb in full area, some innocent 

    may also die, but we don't have any other option, have to do like what US did in Hiroshima & Nagasaki during 2nd World war. Its high time we need to 

    end this tamasha.

    By Sivadasan Menon - 6/2/2016 5:41:56 AM

  • I feel so sad and sorry to the plight of the refugees specifically Children and Women. Who so ever is involved it is crime against 

    humanity. I think India is talking lead in the right direction.

    By Pawan Nagpal - 6/2/2016 5:40:19 AM

  • Nice to see some sane voices raising from among muslims, certain ppl(believe me, its a majority) will not mind if its 7th or 21st 

    century, they just r the same fanatics, hope such voices r not crushed,

    By Rajan Gopal - 6/2/2016 5:28:48 AM

  • New age Islam is a state stooge ,lot of interpretation is needed but holding Mullas aren't responsible as they are products of Madarsa 

    where only marginalized section of society kids get rducated ,
    Mostly,when they enter into Madarsa,they are already mentally stunned due to malnutrition,upper strata is least bothered ,what do you expect,a 

    substandard material shall produce only substandard productsl.
    It is our education system which is responsible,if you can give everyone +12 universally accepted secular,public funded education and free them to 

    pursue whatever they want,only genuine with high intellect will go for theological study,all this nonsense shall stopped immediately but government 

    is not interested to solve the problem permanently to keep the bogeyman ready .?

    By Zubair Ahmed - 6/2/2016 5:10:40 AM

  • Have u heard of King Sasank, who in his hatred of Buddhism came and cut the original bodhhi tree at bodh Gaya after killing Buddhist residents wholesale . Why Buddhism became almost extinct in its place of origin?!Read your history first#Abhijeet Sinha

    By Khalid Lateef - 6/2/2016 4:48:32 AM

  • Poor people poor thoughts. thinking india to be islamic country. will find themselves out of India someday. and join terror groups to attack india finally shoot down by indian army. god bless these foolishes LOL

    By Soubhik Sen - 6/2/2016 4:28:39 AM

  • Yes my brother...Actually These Religions are for enhancement of love peace brotherhood...how we love our own family..& to aid health & Benefits to all...I salute U Brother...
    By Rama Ankush Naik - 6/2/2016 3:44:29 AM

  • All the religious fanatic are living a fanatic future life which nobody has ever seen. They should live one life on earth satisfactorily first
    By Nabam Serbang - 6/2/2016 3:22:08 AM

  • Our bad luck is that advanced and beautiful countries like Japan, Switzerland and New Zealand are not our neighbour countries but fanatic, third class countries like Pakistan, Afganistan and Bangla desh are our neighbours.
    By Satya Prakash - 6/2/2016 3:20:05 AM

  • Regarding rage to this post: Their rage is good, let it come out from the closet; it will expose them even to those who believed in them and offered them goodies. Had they been so enraged with their own lunatic fringe they would have changed. Do not expect change.

    By Anand Kumar - 6/2/2016 3:03:50 AM

  • First they must denounce Shariat laws. Shariat laws were not made by prophet then why are they considered so holy? Few months backs Isis terrorists were raping women captives and they showed that according to shariat laws they can have intercourse with those womens and girls.
    By Ram Bhavesh Sharan - 6/2/2016 3:01:50 AM

  • check this news here.Imam Umer Ahmed Ilyasi and Mowlan Kalbe Jawad decrlared to denounce AB Baghdadi from 7 lakh masajids ,Imam Bargah Khanqahs. Syed Afshan Chishty is aware of this meeting held on Feb 2,2016. I think, I have sent the detailed report to you. Please read all news .
    By DrMuhammad Mukhtar Alam - 6/2/2016 2:57:53 AM

  • all muslim coummunity fully support muslim terrorism....

    By Subhash Malhotra - 6/2/2016 2:52:01 AM

  • Meenangadi Wayanad ISIS was a CIA and ISRAEL CREATION and its Aim was to Eliminate Islam and Muslims From the Earth 

    By Musthafa Pullissery - 6/2/2016 2:47:28 AM

  • Who so ever joins ISIS his identity should be erased...UK did that....I think special flights be arranged for those who want to join ISIS , the moment there flight takes off erase there identity....No wastage of money let that money be spent to build schools,hospitals etc.
    By Vijay Navani - 6/2/2016 1:52:24 AM

  •  I think Muslims must have a lot of conversations among themselves and with others. This is not happening.
    By Deepa Natarajan - 6/2/2016 1:46:05 AM

  • And if a hindu saint or person tells those who are against bharat mata ki jai should go to pakistan
    mediya sickular all those muslim intellectuals will start barking as dog.doglapan tustikaran kab

    By Pradeep Kumar Singh - 6/1/2016 1:23:11 AM

  • They are silent because silence is approval. Who can trust the oft repeated quote that Islam is a
    religion of peace. This quote seems deception. Where are JNU secularists/communists/award
    returnees, bullies, other mouth-pieces and promotors of culture of gagging? Perhaps speaking on
    this issue may not earn them enough public notoriety.

    By Anand Kumar - 6/1/2016 1:20:26 AM

  • They are silent because silence is approval. Who can trust the oft repeated quote that Islam is a
    religion of peace. This quote seems deception. Where are JNU secularists/communists/award
    returnees, bullies, other mouth-pieces and promotors of culture of gagging? Perhaps speaking on
    this issue may not earn them enough public notoriety.

    By Anand Kumar - 6/1/2016 1:20:20 AM

  • A voice of reason from within the Muslim community. It is important that Indian Muslims stand up
    against bigotry within their own religion and take steps to free the community from the clutches of
    age old practices that have nonplace in 21st century India

    By Ramesh Venkatraman - 6/1/2016 1:17:58 AM

  • Truely said that true muslims should not support terrorism.Most of the terror attacks in the world
    has been done by the muslims and still going on.We have lost regard and respect everywhere .We
    have to change the view of the world that "muslims" do not meant for terrorists .So respect
    humanity and oppose terrorism worldwide.

    By Vinoy Kumar - 6/1/2016 1:14:50 AM

  • @Mr. Roy do we have choice? 
    a] Mangoes we are eating is from whose garden? 
    B] Dal ,who is growing ? 
    C} when we go to restaurant to eat food, do we check the cook is a Hindu? 
    d} When we are admitted in hospital do we check the nurse or docs is Hindu? Then why should we have these
    feelings, I have full faith in HINDUISM, People who tries to erase others , they themselves get erase!

    By Ranen Roy - 6/1/2016 1:12:52 AM

  • Muslim leaders, journalists, intellectuals etc are keeping silence against terrorism. .perhaps this
    action required research to explore the contents

    By Pradeep Kumar - 6/1/2016 1:10:08 AM

  • Muslim leaders, journalists, intellectuals etc are keeping silence against terrorism. .perhaps this
    action required research to explore the contents

    By Pradeep Kumar - 6/1/2016 12:23:45 AM

  • I think u r not well read...plz be regular with both electronic nd print
    media to stay updated
    Well then wat has media and modern day bhakt done to condemn the
    arms training being given by hindu sena and bajranj dal terrorists in uttar pradesh???
    Y the hypocricy???
    Plz be well informed nd prepared before qning others!!!!

    By Muhammed Tabish Mustafa - 6/1/2016 12:12:22 AM

  • All right thinking Muslims however small in number they may be, need to come together and raise
    their voice to save Islam and Humanity.

    By Harendra Singh - 6/1/2016 12:11:22 AM

  • દરેક ઉલેમાઓએ જાહેર કરી દીધું કે આંતકવાદ એ ઇસ્લામ નો ભાગ નથી અને આઈ.એસ.આઈ.એસ. જે કરે છે એ
    પણ ઇસ્લામ ની વિરુધ્ધ છે અને એ ઇસ્લામ નથી. એના પછી પણ જો કોઈ નાં સમજે અને દરેક વાતમાં અને મુસ્લિમ સમાજ
    ઉપર આંગળી ચીંધ્યા કરે તો એની બુદ્ધિ નો કોઈ ઈલાજ કરી શકાય??

    By Anis Sheikh - 6/1/2016 12:10:47 AM

  • Time to think now, if you have some reason left in you.

    By Rajendra Tiwari - 6/1/2016 12:10:13 AM

  • Religions preach peace, friendship and prosperity and tranquillity not bloodshed. ISIS is harming
    Islam. I S I S is the real Enimy of Islam not others they are defeating the reality nd truth of Islam. ISIS
    is fighting to destroy the Islam not others.
    Bismilla hirrahman irrahim .

    By Vasant Kumar - 6/1/2016 12:08:58 AM

  • Since Hindus & Muslims have to coexist in India maintain harmony.Hate campaign will be

    By Roy - 6/1/2016 12:07:25 AM

  • Recently A article in Times of India news paper very nicely give The division of India started in 1658
    ,when Aurangzeb prosecuted his elder brother Dara Shikoku ,on the divide of sunni - shia due to
    which Mughal empire started decline due to the Shia Muslims ,Hindus ,Sikhs started looking other
    way from mughal empire ,due to which English got advantage to dominate India

    By Narasimhamurthy Narasimhaiah - 6/1/2016 12:00:29 AM

  • Change is the only constant thing. Change also perish

    By Gandhi Moirang Kjbm - 5/31/2016 11:40:51 PM

  • See the comments on many muslim in this post.no doubt they r so infested with terrorist production

    By Manish Mahajan - 5/31/2016 11:36:56 PM

  • Something that Muslims worldwide need to think about and ponder at length upon.
    Only the thinkers, intellectuals and rationalists within the faith can rescue this great faith from
    obscurantism of medieval times that has no place in the twentieth century.
    failure to take corrective action will ensure that Islamic societies worldwide will continue to regress
    and lag the rest of humanity in times to come.

    By Chandra Mohan Jagota - 5/31/2016 11:34:03 PM

  • Dear Ghaus Saheb if any muslim think for his deen (Religion) and culture and oppose all law and follow sharia then he is gud but if hindu try to protect his religion and culture under the law of Country then they are terrorists

    By Satya prakash - 5/31/2016 11:30:37 PM

  • We should protect such secular minded Muslims, unlike Bangladesh, where many are killed for
    posting such liberal thoughts.

    By Girish Gupta - 5/31/2016 11:24:50 PM

  • Khaqan Haa khamosh, hamesha ki tarah....What i find so strange reading the comments is the many muslims blaming jews and christians making conspiracy against islam and blaming women in short clothes and break down of morals! I am also seeing comments about USA & Israel want to tarnish the image of Islam. What rubbish! Tarnish what? Islam already tarnished its own image from day one. Are you guys mad??? Some people have the wildest imaginations! This terrorism problem is a problem that can only be solved by ISLAM! Wake up and accept the responsibility for your religion. Stop blaming jews, christians, hindus, americans, israelis. Grow up!.
    By Afshin Jan Khaqan - 5/31/2016 8:45:36 PM

  • We should protect such secular minded Muslims, unlike Bangladesh, where many are killed for posting such liberal thoughts.

    By Girish Gupta - 5/31/2016 12:59:29 PM

  • @Aayina - 5/31/2016 4:53:03 AM
    Dear Aayina, most Ulema believe that there is no religious freedom for Muslims in Islam. For them the Quranic exhortation "La Ikraha fid Deen" (No Compulsion in Religion)is only for non-Muslims who cannot be forced into conversion. For them, if you have had the misfortune of being born into a Muslim family or have already converted to Islam from some other religion, you do not enjoy any religious freedom. However, for me the dictum "La Ikraha fid Deen" (No Compulsion in Religion) is absolute and universal. That's why the world at large has accepted this dictum now.

    By Sultan Shahin - 5/31/2016 12:35:32 PM

  • One man comments with various names !!!!!
    By Siraj - 5/31/2016 6:46:19 AM

  • Muslims and Hindus are already living with peaceful coexistence. This article is just trying to disturb the peaceful situation.........
    By Ravi Kumar - 5/31/2016 6:43:22 AM

  • who the hell are who want to send Muslims to other countries. India is the land of these Muslims. It is the country of muslims as much as of Hindus. 
    Ye Mulk kisi ek ke baap ka nahi hai balke yahan saare mazhab ke log rahte hain yahi iski khubsurti hai jis din ye khubsurti tootegi koi khush nahi rah paaega. India ki beauty gayi to sirf minority hi nahi balki majority ko bhi pareshani hogi............Aur phir ek din ye majority bhi afsos karenge ke kash aaj hamare minority bahi zinda hote .............. 

    By Ruhul - 5/31/2016 6:41:01 AM

  • India is really proud of such a devoted Muslim son.
    By Pramod Kumar Jena - 5/31/2016 6:08:14 AM

  • Yes don't blame Riot wingers for targeting Muslims.
    Don't blame them for killing Muslim.
    After all Muslims are responsible for everything.

    By AIMIM - 5/31/2016 6:03:28 AM

  • One very simple question i would like to ask why are thesepeople killing they own people .are they all not Muslims they 

    follow the same faith ,then why do they kill one another ?..some think must be wrong some where for sure ....

    By Michel Raymond - 5/31/2016 6:01:09 AM

  • Ulemas have already denounced ISIS and terrorism.. You ignorant fool... You paid troll..

    By Imtiaz Hussain - 5/31/2016 5:59:33 AM

  • That time has gone, now u Will loss your complete breed. Forgot horrible end of Laden

    By Yagnesh Joshi - 5/31/2016 5:57:19 AM

  • the answer to the given question is a big NO

    By Ragit Dutta - 5/31/2016 5:52:14 AM


    By Kishore Kumar Mohapatra - 5/31/2016 5:50:40 AM

  • Unless and untill there's reform in Islam,the muslim cannot co-exist with others....the trends of killing to kafirs will 

    continue ....there's no freedom in Islam...any muslim is deemed to die if he convert to any other religion...

    By Borsing Terang - 5/31/2016 5:25:07 AM

  • That is enough that you alone are maligning the whole community who know nothing about the Indian mujahideen, only the 

    chamcha of bhakts like you know about them.

    By Moin Barbhuiya - 5/31/2016 5:10:12 AM

  • To
    Sultan Shahin

    Well if Most ulema if say their is no freedom of relgion if person is born as Muslim, than there is no point of asking any question.

    Well you have expressed your personal opinion on freedom of relgion is well appreciated.

    But it raise another question:

    than how you differ than ulema, what is source of ulema, after all, Muslim world is based on source, not like Hindus who create whole new doctrine of understanding of God and worship. 

    You are free not to choose the answer, as my whole curiosity is over on the "Freedom of relgion" after your answer.

    By Aayina - 5/31/2016 4:53:03 AM

  • All the religious fanatic are living a fanatic future life which nobody has ever seen. They should live one life on earth 

    satisfactorily first

    By Nabam Serbang - 5/31/2016 4:49:16 AM

  • Dear Gulam Ghaus, please comment with sense and how can you compare rss, bajrang dal with ISIS/Terrorists
    RSS is cultural organisation, rss is not going to kill any one or rape innocent girl neither bajrang dal 
    but don't know why all Indian Muslims think that RSS/Bajrang Dal is dangerous than Spiritual organisations like ISIS/JeM
    isn't it Ghaus ji ? pls grow up man

    By Satya Prakash - 5/31/2016 4:42:36 AM

  • Send all muslims to Syria or pakisthan
    By Ramesh Narayani - 5/31/2016 4:33:35 AM

  • Time to ask quetions n introscopy......time to act wisely

    By Sudhanshu Ranjan - 5/31/2016 4:13:12 AM

  • Only Muslims can pull Muslims out of this mess. If anyone else says anything , they feel islam is in danger. 
    So you can take lead and write in hindi and urdu newspaper and magazines and I am sure your efforts will bring good results

    By Vasant Kathal - 5/31/2016 3:52:45 AM

  • @Vasant Kadam

    One of the rapidly growing problems in India is stemming from the Media circles where people play the role of Supreme Court’s judges. The judges in Supreme Court have not yet given their judgement but unfortunately sometimes some of our Media circles give their categorical judgement without knowing the fact and proof and thus they consider sometimes the innocent Muslims as “terrorists”.

    The Media circles should present the news and not the judgment. I have read a news today about a Muslim boy namely Nisar who has been released after 23 years of jail after the Supreme Court ordered his immediate release by acquitting him from all charges and quashing the sentence of life imprisonment ordered by the lower court. Nisar is breathing freely but he believes that “23 years in prison have murdered the man he was” he told the Indian Express: “I have clocked 8,150 days of the prime of my life inside jail. For me, life is over. What you are seeing is a living corpse.”

    Mr Vasant Kadam! You give a judgment saying “All are fanatic”. But this is not true. It is simply shows your angry thought. 

    By Ghulam Ghaus غلام غوث - 5/31/2016 3:15:52 AM

  • Shame on Muslims who r defending Isis rater calling them terrorists

    By Ajay Sharma - 5/31/2016 2:52:47 AM

  • Nice to see some sane voices raising from among muslims, certain ppl(believe m
    By Rajan Gopal - 5/31/2016 2:44:39 AM

  • @Puhar Daimari

    You say "All Muslims are alike. No difference. Either ISIS or common people"

    I do not agree with you. According to your thought, if Muslims too start thinking the way you have done that "All Hindus are alike. No difference. Either Bajrang Dal, Rss or common people". What would be the result then? 

    If Muslims had been alike, they would not have faced the disastrous situations in Iraq, Syria, Pakistan, and other countries of the world. And similarly if Hindus had been alike, they would not have faced the controversies, mutual disagreement and caste-based discriminations. 

    As being Indians, we should have positive thought for our co-nationalists.   

    By Ghulam Ghaus غلام غوث - 5/31/2016 2:25:36 AM

  • All are fanatic and cannot have different opinion if they believed that book . ISIS has correct interpretation and Islam means not peace but submission . Submission any way by force or otherwise . They cheat who use big words and say islam is not about killing . Islam is about killing only.

    By Vasant Kadam - 5/30/2016 8:51:04 PM

  • Why this Idiot Sultan Shaheen blame Islam or Islamic Teaching instead of misinterpreters of those teachings? Firstly this man shrewdly writes against Islam then after feedbacks he takes U turn and put blames on its misinterpreters . So to understand his " Jackal Mind" read his write-ups closely then you will be able to draw his " malicious design-line " as to how he always defames Islam, put blame on Islam ; wants edition and deletion in the Quran ; demeans Holy Prophet ; misinterpret Islamic teaching himself and so on. A simple evidence how this idiot mocks and make fun of Shaheeda-ne-Islam by writing this sentence :- In which Muslims are living :- " Perhaps the seventh century, still fighting battles of Badr and Uhud." This conspirator and a player of anti-islamic forces always tries to divide Islam on Meccan Islam And Madiyan Islam . It means he is doing his level best (?) to create deviations. He thinks that he is better than Shaheedan-e-Uhud & Badr . Once he gave an impression that he is above Caliph Umar.
    Sultan Shaheen & Co be sane and remove your idiot and anti-Islamic mentality and don't be bootlickers of those who are into the business of terrorising Muslims by defaming Islam as a terror :-
    Read all these to know the untold facts ( list is not complete ) :-
    1. Who Killed Karkare ( available in Hindi ; Urdu and English ) by Mumbai Police Commisinor ( Retd) S.M.Mushrif 
    (2) "11 months after spending 11 years in jail " written to highlight Vanzara's hands in innocent blood.
    (3) Anand Math ( read it carefully; it is full with Angrez Bhakti ) 
    (4) Bunch of Thoughts by Golwalkar .Highlighting RSS ( BJP's mother organization ) Bhagwa Fascism 
    (5) 'We or our Nationhood Defined' by Golwalkar
    (6) Jinnah: India-Partition-Independence is a 
    book written by Jaswant Singh
    (7) Four facts about Sardar Patel that Modi would
    find disappointing :- scroll.in/.../four-facts-about-sardar-patel-that...
    8. Emergence of Communal Politics in India by : Vikram Rana
    9. Communal politics: How RSS used the tricolour to divide Hindus and Muslims in J&K in 2008 byDavid Devadas
    10. Ayodhya: Archaeology After Demolition (Rev.
    Edn.) by D. Mandal
    11. Anonymous Soldiers: The Struggle For Israel 1917-1947,” author Bruce Hoffman — a terrorism analyst.
    12. Zionist Jews-Godfathers Of Terrorism By Latheef Farook
    13. Hyderabad 1948: India's hidden massacre By Mike Thomson
    15. Israel Warn Of Europe’s Destruction If Boycott
    watch the video :- The video, released by a pro-
    Israel PR firm,
    depicts ISIS militants destroying European
    cities with Jerusalem’s blessing.

    By Shahid Sayyidain - 5/30/2016 8:49:36 PM

  • Friends, I don't qualify to talk about any other religion, but I know about India-Hindustan-Bharat.
    Am a proud Indian & have many Muslim friends since childhood to till date , who are like brothers. Muslim Friends, whose father are in Indian Airforce, Indian Army, Indian Navy, Defence Research establishments & Professionals.
    Every Non-Muslim Indian respect Indian Muslim's decision to stay back in a Secular India during 1947, trusted them & they are part of India-Hindustan-Bharat and there is no threat to them.
    It also becomes responsibility of Indian Muslims to groom & support Nationalist & Patriotic leaders & be vigilant towards Anti-national Muslims .
    Those Indian Muslims who feel they had made a mistake by staying back in India, they are welcome to peacefully migrate to any Muslim country or any other country. 
    For those Indian Muslims, who wish to create Jihad like situation in India-Hindustan-Bharat & dream of Mughalistan, let them know that Non-Muslims in this Democratic -Secular country are Indian Muslims biggest support & their shield. The moment Indian Muslims tamper with this shield , every Non-Muslim Indian will brand all Indian Muslims as trouble makers, repent that Muslims were allowed to stay back in India after 1947, help cut Pakistan into 4 parts, even nuking 1st wherever required & give 24 hours ultimatum to all Indian Muslims to exit India from nearest border or get ready to be eliminated.
    It will be so swift that before anybody realise, it will be all over. Could Saudi Arabia stop America or Russia from bombing Syria,Iraq, Afghanistan or other Muslim countries.
    Later, debates can happen on International TV Channels & in UN.
    Enough trouble for almost 70 years from Pakistan & from within , contributing to deaths of Indian Security force, increase in Defence budget, population & criminals with negligible economic contribution.
    Being Peace loving is India-Hindustan-Bharat's Strength, not weakness.
    Remember, just one small Warrior community - Sikhs, when flexed their Muscles conquered from Delhi to Kashmir, from Tibet to Afghanistan & India is filled with such Gallant Warrior communities.
    Am a humble Spiritual person with calm mind, but if these thoughts can cross my mind, imagine mind of families of security forces & civilians killed in riots, terror attacks or along border, Kashmiri Pandits who are forced to leave their homes & many more suffering due to Anti-national Muslims.
    My humble request is, please don't consider this as a threat, but a possible scenario if Indian Muslims don't protect their India-Hindustan-Bharat from Anti-national Muslims. 
    Indian Muslims are always welcome to join Military, Paramilitary & Police services to eliminate Anti-nationals. 
    Protect India - Protect Yourself, for you are India-Hindustan-Bharat.

    By Surinder Pal Singh - 5/30/2016 8:46:39 PM

  • All muslim r alike.no differnce.either isis or comn people.
    By Puhar Daimari - 5/30/2016 11:02:32 AM

  • That is the problem. The educated and liberal thinking people from the community does not object Jihadi themes or who propagate it boldly. This is what alienating this community across the world.
    By Pradip Choudhuri - 5/30/2016 10:57:40 AM

  • You are lying about muslim leaders maintaining a complete silence.
    By DrMuhammad Mukhtar Alam - 5/30/2016 10:51:07 AM

  •  Instead of writing such pieces ,please check with people first.
    By DrMuhammad Mukhtar Alam - 5/30/2016 10:36:56 AM

  • I read comments too. Not certain. Everybody talks own religion. Why argue ?
    By Rajendra Prajapati - 5/30/2016 10:30:00 AM

  • simply, is it possible to force islam on others. but it is possible follow your relgion with out hurting others.islam manifestation leaves no scope for democracy. gulf.countries only being islamic unable to see virtues of other religions. respecting otherd is necessary.if alla created world he also created others then violation of his command is also unislamic.except fanaticism ,nothing.no wisdom.but loud speaker making noice is not a sign of tolerance.this is not written text as there were no such app at that time.this shows arrogance of arrogance.silent prayers will also reach god.this arrogance will be a big issue in future for holocaste.loss of life is no religion. all muslims should not be accused.
    By Mg Omprakash - 5/30/2016 10:07:53 AM

  • Indian Mujahedeen with IS? When did they say so? Who represents them?
    By Ashraf Nvk - 5/30/2016 9:46:48 AM

  • Those asking to see this fatwa or that fatwa are trying to defend indefensible as we all know this is eyewash. Listen to warning and heed to it for world peace.
    By Krishna Kumar Saboo - 5/30/2016 9:40:53 AM

  • No co-existence is brooked.
    By Dereck Darlong - 5/30/2016 9:40:24 AM

  • It is the mindset of uncivilized barbarians who cannot cope with the present times.
    By Dhruba Borah - 5/30/2016 8:26:11 AM

  • There should be no separate schools.
    By Mohan Deshpande - 5/30/2016 8:25:43 AM

  • Rightly pointed out the mindset of fanatic muslims and the consequences of their stand. Salute sir
    By Deivasigamani Sundarathatham - 5/30/2016 8:25:10 AM

  • Dear Aaiyina, Most ulema believe there is no freedom of religion in Islam for those born in a Muslim family.  
    However,  I take Quranic dictum la ikraha fid Deen (No Compulsion in religion) to be absolute, applicable to both Muslims and non-Muslims. 

    By Sultan Shahin - 5/30/2016 5:05:33 AM

  • Mr. Sultan Shahin

    Yes Islam came as a rahmat (blessing) for the world, but how many other than true Muslims believe its rahmat. After reading the words of the commentators like ‘Sunny’, ‘Hindu Reader’ and others, I am sure they do not believe its rahmat. Another question is not to be asked whether Hindus, Christians, Jews and Budhdhists believe and adopt this rahmat. If they believe its rahmat, why some of them are found sometimes as the killers of innocent Muslims as a cause of religious issue.   

    The questions are: Was this rahmat only applicable in the 7th century and not applicable now? And on what criteria this rahmat is still applicable and why the defensive meaning in the war-related verse cannot be applicable even today? If the defensive thought is bad, why every country of the world, especially of those who claim to promote peace and tolerant, is reproducing nuclear bombs and dangerous weapons. Can you ask them not to produce such nuclear weapons in this 21st century, because this is not applicable today?  It is another issue that when America makes weapons it is called for defence, but when Iran makes any such weapons it is blamed for being dangerous for the world’s safety. As far as the Muslim countries are concerned, we know they have become much weaker than ever, even in matter of defence.    

    The terrorists such as ISIS, Taliban and Al-Qaeda are misusing and defaming Islam. On the other hand, the anti-Islamic people are looking for some excuses to abuse and blame Islam. At this tumultuous time, I want Muslims like me to be far away from both types of anti-Islamic people and their literature, comments and remarks if he really wants to enjoy peace, because reading such unwanted words will give only tension to them.  

    I have written dozens of articles in refutation of ISIS, Taliban, Boko Haram and their likes. My Sufi-minded-Ulemas too have refuted and issued fatwas against them. More than that, we pray “May Allah Almighty establish peace in the world”. They have done their duty and thus they are good, but it will be better if they refute more.    

    Sectarian division is a bitter fact in Muslim community. I belong to Sunni-Hanafi-Sufi-minded “Barelvi” jamaat. I am open and clear since i started writing articles for this website. In this sense, i am a staunch believer to the point that I will never leave my maslak and my jamaat. But since then i have not yet known about you. Your writings do not represent any groups of Muslims. On many doctrines, i do not agree with you. I agree with you on peace-promotion work, but after all, i do not agree with the way you want to promote peace and tolerance.

    Personally I think ‘peace-work’ is meaningless when it contradicts the majority mainstream Muslims’ views. Peace needs mutual agreement, so, which kind of peace it may be when it does not have any mutual agreement with the majority.  

    Peace and violence are inherent in the behaviour of all the human beings including Muslims, Hindus, Christians, Jews and all. It is also a bitter fact. When sensing such a bitter fact, I should and others too can simply pray “May Allah Almighty establish peace in the world”!!!      

    By Ghulam Ghaus غلام غوث - 5/30/2016 3:22:24 AM

  • To Sultan shahin
    You are talking of double standard of ulema.
    First clear whatever I heared is true or false?
    What I have heard, is that, Islam allows anyone or even born Muslim to refuse Islam as their faith if they feel it's is not right.
    Let me clear I am not scholar.
    I will post my Question once I get answer that what I heared was true or false.
    I wish even if any scholar jumped in to answer than please quote Quran( this is more good as it said it god instruction)or Hadees( This can be anything real or made up).
    I wish I get answer from Quran.

    By Aayina - 5/30/2016 2:14:12 AM

  • Overall Islam is a religion liable of misinterpretations, hence ‘dangerous.'
    By sunny - 5/28/2016 10:51:02 PM

  • The Doctrine of Abrogation must be revised. Believing that latter verses abrogate earlier verses would only make us more intolerant and warlike. A better test would be whether the earlier or the latter verse is more in keeping with the true spirit of Islam as we know it, that is to say which one promotes peace, non-violence, reconciliation, brotherhood, tolerance, forgiveness and the doctrine of "No compulsion".

    By Ghulam Mohiyuddin - 5/28/2016 2:52:47 PM

  • This is precisely what I am telling you and other ulema, Ghulam Ghaus Saheb. If you base your religion on Meccan Islam with its foundational verses of Quran recited in chronological order, giving primacy to peace and pluralism, patience and perseverance, and no permission for war and instruction to kill the kafir and Mushrik, and no recorded ahadees that present the Prophet (saw) as ordering killing of innocent civilians, we (including Ghazali himself) reach a very different conclusion about Islam from what Ghazali and other luminaries like Ibn-e-Taimiya, Sarhandi, Wahhab, Shah Waliullah, etc conclude while inspired by later Medinan verses.

    We will have to engage with this discrepancy in our scriptures and our theology. Our religion should not provide refuge to terrorists and their ideologues. This is what it does at the moment.

    You know what the consensus theology as revealed in the Encyclopaedia of Islam says about Jihad: “Terminologically, Jihad means to fight against a non-zimmi unbeliever (kaafir) after he rejects the call towards Islam, in order to establish or raise high the words of Allah.” Isn’t the statement in the ISIS video, asking non-Muslims to convert or pay Jizya or be killed saying the same thing. How can you oppose ISIS and support the conclusions reached in the Kuwaiti Encyclopaedia?

    This Encyclopaedia was prepared after half-a-century’s efforts by a bevy of ulema from different schools of thought and different parts of the world. It has a 23,000-word chapter on Jihad. This chapter does not have anything to say about what we moderates call Greater Jihad (struggle against one’s own negative ego).

    This is the state of the current theology by consensus of all schools of thought. So merely quoting Quranic verses from Mecca or peaceful passages from theologians like Ghazali based on Meccan Quran cannot help. By virtually a consensus Meccan verses are now considered abrogated and replaced by Medinan verses. The Sufi or moderate ulema will quote Meccan verses of peace and pluralism but will not say that the Doctrine of Abrogation is false. This is not going to help. You must understand that in the age of internet you cannot hide anything.

    That’s why I am constantly asking ulema, particularly those like you who want to promote peace, to think, introspect, brainstorm with other ulema, engage with and resolve these contradictions. Denial and obduracy of the kind displayed by both Maulana Tahirul Qadri and you is not going to help Islam and its perception by the Muslims and the world at large.

    Please realise the state we are in at the moment. Islam and terrorism have become virtually synonymous. Islam came as a rahmat (blessing) for the world. We have turned into more than a zahmat (mischief). It has become an object of fear.

    And this is not happening because of the terrorists, but because of the double dealings of our ulema. On the one hand they say that there is no place for terrorism in Islam as even killing one innocent person amounts to genocide in Quran and on the other they keep silent and support when Taliban scholars justify their terrorism by pointing to Hadees that says that Prophet (saw) himself ordered killing of innocents at Taif. When this Hadees is put before ulema they merely say, well, this Hadees is certainly in sihah-e-sitta (all six authentic books of Hadees). They do not say that it is impossible for the Prophet to himself violate the Quranic principle that killing of even one innocent amounts to genocide. Ghaus Saheb, you and other ulema will have to find a way to reconcile this contradiction.

    Terrorists are successful because their ideology is based on current theology of consensus. We moderates and progressives are not able to keep our youth safe from these marauders because we are not clear where we stand. How can Quran be against killing of even one innocent person and the Prophet order killing of scores of innocents at Taif? Why do you have to insist that Hadees is sacrosanct, even ‘akin to revelation’? How can it be ‘akin to revelation’ when it was collected up to 300 years after the demise of the Prophet? How can the Prophet violate the Quran? Are the ulema telling us that the Prophet too believed that the peaceful Meccan verses had been abrogated? And if they are saying so, then what is the difference between them and the terror ideologues?

    By Sultan Shahin - 5/28/2016 1:57:20 PM

  • मुसलमान मुसलमान के साथ भी शान्ति के साथ नहीं रह सकता है। जिस तरह मुस्लिम देशों में इस्लाम के दूसरे फिरकों की मस्जिदों में बम फोड़े जा रहे हैं वह इसका सबूत है।
    By Rakesh Agarwal - 5/28/2016 8:54:19 AM

  • Dear Sultan Shahin sahib,

    You have quoted Imam Ghazali various times in your articles. You quoted to tell the readers about his “offensive” interpretation. I too have quoted him in my articles but for proving that the war-related verses were in fact defensive.  Do please tell me, how you would characterise the following quotes:

    Imam Muhammad al-Ghazali writes his commentary on Surah 9:5

    “Muslims are therefore basically opposed to war and are never the ones to start it. By the imperative of their own religion, they are taught not to impose their beliefs on others by force. Their mission is to impart and communicate God’s message, leaving people free to decide whether to believe or reject it. Those who refuse to believe are free to pursue their lives in peace as long as they do not pose any obstacle or threat to Islam and the Muslims, who perceive their faith as the strongest and most vital binding relationship between God and humankind and that it is their responsibility to make others aware of it and provide them with the opportunity to understand and appreciate it.

    "This is the basis of the relationship between Muslims and non-Muslims in Islamic society. God says elsewhere in the Qur’an: “Therefore, if they (the unbelievers) do not trouble you and cease their hostility towards you and offer you peace, God gives you no authority over them” [al-Nisa: 90]. Those who take up arms against a Muslim state or parts of it must be met with force, and if they are overcome, they should be disarmed. Once that is achieved, they are free to lead their own lives and practise their beliefs in peace and security under the protection of the Muslim authorities, in return for which they have to pay a levy.

    “This is the background against which prescription of the Jizyah, or exemption tax, came into being. It is not due from those who are neutral and have never taken up arms against the Muslim state. The Qur'anic verse gives ample explanation for the reason behind the establishment of this tax, for it stipulates who should pay it. They are those “who do not believe in God and the Last Day, who do not forbid what God and His Messenger have forbidden, and who do not follow the true religion, until they pay the exemption tax unreservedly and with humility.” (Shaykh Muhammad al-Ghazali, “A Thematic Commentary on the Qur’an” [The International Institute of16: Islamic Thought, Second Printing, 2005], pp. 183-184, “Jihad: a war against all Non-Muslims or not? By Kevin Abdullah Kareem”)

     Imam Muhammad al-Ghazali concludes his commentary on Surah 9:5

    “Our natural disposition and tendency favour peace, harmony, and stability among relatives, neighbours, and friends. However, while condoning and encouraging these tendencies, the Qur’an also says: “…Much as you dislike it, fighting has been prescribed for you. But you may despise something that is good for you, and you may love something that is bad for you. God knows, but you do not …” [2:216]. Peace is to be welcomed when rights are protected and beliefs are respected; but if peace means abject surrender and subjugation, it cannot be easily defended on moral or realistic grounds. This delicate balance is well presented in the verse: “… They ask you whether fighting is permitted during the sacred month. Say, ‘fighting in it is a grave matter’ …” [2:217], meaning it is not permitted. However, what should be done if aggression is perpetrated, terrorizing peaceful communities and jeopardizing their rights of worship and belief? Should not aggression be repelled, in order to protect one’s rights? The verse continues: “….but to deny God and debar people from His path and prevent them from worshiping in the Holy Mosque, and to drive its inhabitants away, is far graver in the sight of God…” [2:217]. In short “...sedition (Arabic: Fitnah) is a greater threat than killing...” [2:217] and fighting or armed resistance should be permitted in “defence” of one’s integrity and beliefs. However, in circumstances in which we are faced with enemies who will not be satisfied until we forsake our religion and way of life and adopt theirs, defensive action becomes obligatory and the blame for instigating the conflict will not fall on us but on those who were the cause of it.

    These introductory remarks enable us to appreciate fully the meaning of the following verse: “…fight for the cause of God those who fight against you, but do not commit aggression because God does not love the aggressors…” [2:190]. This is an eternal principle, and everything else the Qur’an has to say on this subject agrees with it. Some commentators have been erroneously misled into believing that Surah al-Tawbah contains injunctions that contradict this principle. The command given in that Surah to undertake to fight back does not, however prescribe fighting against fair-minded, neutral, or reasonable people. It condones it against groups who have grudges against the Muslims and are actively undermining their peace and security and inflicting harm upon them. That is the reason for the Qur’an’s condemnation that: “...Evil is what they (the unbelievers) have done; they respect no pacts or agreements with the believers and they are the aggressors…..” [Al-Tawbah: 9-10]

    “Furthermore, the Qur’an emphasizes the need to confront those aggressors in a just and clean fight, by asking: “...Would you not fight against those who have broken their oaths and conspired to drive the Messenger out, and attacked you first? Do you fear them? Surely you should fear God instead, if you are true believers…” [Al-Tawbah: 13]. It is difficult to see how this can be seen as prescribing waging war against those who do not commit aggression, or that it overrides the principle given in al-Baqarah which states clearly that fighting is undertaken only in response to aggression.

    "This – when propounded by some Muslims – is at best a misunderstanding, and at worst an objectionable undermining of eternal Islamic principles, inviting noxious charges against Islam, for which we have only ourselves to blame. Here it is worth stressing that the Qur’an prescribes legitimate defensive war on condition that it is undertaken for the cause of God and not for personal glory nor to gain a special advantage; nor should wars be prescribed for the sake of vainglorious and bigoted nationalist interests to prove that a particular country is supreme and master of all ! Wars conducted in recent times have been organized to usurp the wealth and the resources of weaker nations, and to colonize and control their lands and destinies for the benefit of strong and mighty ones. Far from being just wars, fought in the name of God, they are true works of evil. (Shaykh Muhammad al-Ghazali, “A Thematic Commentary on the Qur’an” [The International Institute of 16: Islamic Thought, Second Printing, 2005], pp. 18-20, see also “Jihad: a war against all Non-Muslims or not? By Kevin Abdullah Kareem”)

    Please read my full article:

    Kill Them Wherever You Find Them (2:191)': What Quran Actually Means By This Command?


    By Ghulam Ghaus غلام غوث - 5/28/2016 8:26:36 AM

  • शिक्षित और अशिक्षित के बीच गहरी खाई का दुख परिणाम
    By अजय कुमार जैन - 5/28/2016 7:53:37 AM

  • We Muslims believe that our Lord Allah Almighty is able to do everything. Nothing is impossible for Him. As a creator of the world, Allah Almighty has all good attributes; such as the knowledge of Future and the knowledge of Unseen. We cannot disbelieve any attribute for Him. That the holy Quran was in Lauhe Mahfooz is proved by the Quran itself. The knowledge of Future is one of the attributes of Allah Almighty. He knew the situation and context and everything that would happen in the era of the prophet peace be upon him. The verses came down according to the need and situation. This is very simple idea. No believer can or should deny this attribute...........


    All the verses you have quoted in your recent comment were meant for fighting for defence, fighting for true justice. So, if fighting for defence is considered intolerant, then not a single one is safe from being intolerant in this 21st century.    

    By Ghulam Ghaus غلام غوث - 5/28/2016 7:53:11 AM

  • Science is Islam.There is never a statement to hate non-muslims.Be with your basics & let other do as per their belief.There is no need to change or let change the others.
    By Ibrahim Usmani - 5/28/2016 7:53:06 AM

  • Beware of this false propaganda. ... Their is nothing like new age Islam. Islam is complete religion. Islam is best religion. Their is no place of advancement or change in islam. The true and beautiful religion of God. It depends on our own view how to see the best principles of islam
    By Altaf Khan - 5/28/2016 7:51:19 AM

  • There are ignorant fanatics supported by politicians n media in all religions and countries that is what we observe around us
    By Hamza Philip - 5/28/2016 7:47:41 AM

  • Dear Ghulam Ghaus Saheb, Along with Dr. Tahirul Qadri, you too say, there are no intolerant verses in Quran. Do please tell me, how would you characterise the following verses I am quoting here. Please don't talk about context and asbab-e-nazool when you say, as you must have been taught in your Sufi madrasa, that Quran is uncreated, just a copy of the original lying in the Heavenly vault. If that is so, where does the issue of context arise. For you, every verse is universal and applicable even today, regardless of the context. Quran has been compiled in a way so as to take away its context. Every verse is treated as separate, God-like, divine.
    Let us have some sense of logic. If context has some meaning, then these verses related to battles of the Prophet's era are no longer applicable today, as we are not fighting these wars. But if these verses are uncreated, God-like, divine, then they are of universal applicability as the terrorist ideologues as well as all the greatest of Islamic luminaries like even Sufi al-Ghazali, Sheikh Sarhandi, Shah Waliullah etc tell us. After all, how does the greatest Sufi scholar and theologian Ghazali ask us to go on Jihad at least once a year. Could this be defensive war that you fight at least once every year?
    Anyway, please read the following verses that may have escaped your notice, although all of the greatest scholars make use of them to promote a situation of permanent war, and now terrorists use the same for the same end:

    Some verses from The Holy Quran used for brainwashing our youth and leading them on to what they are told is the path of Jihad and the way to Heaven are being reproduced below from a compilation made by Dr. Shabbir Ahmed of Florida along with his occasional commentaries (available at www.ourbeacon.com). While they may have great historical value and help us understanding the roots of our religion and the difficulties the Prophet had to face in carrying out his task and feel grateful for his perseverance and patience, most of them are clearly not applicable to us verbatim  in our present situation and in the present age. Let us pinch ourselves hard and try and remember that we are not living in the seventh century Arabia, but in the 21st century post 9/11 world. There is no way we can go back in time and migrate to Prophet’s Arabia and help fight his battles and earn Allah’s blessings and probably a good accommodation in Heaven. We will have to find other ways of achieving that.

    2:216 Fighting is ordained for you, even though it is hateful to you. But it may happen that you hate a thing that is good for you, and it may happen that you love a thing that is bad for you. For, God knows and you know not. [See 2:190-193, 22:39]

    2:217 They ask you about fighting in any Month of Security. Say, “Fighting in the prescribed Months of Security is a great transgression. (2:194). However, repelling men from the Way of God, and rejecting His Command of peace in those Months and turning people away from the Masjid of Security and the Prescribed Way of Life, and evicting its people from there, are greater offences in the Sight of God. Persecution is a crime far greater than killing.” They will not cease from fighting against you until they make you revert from your Way of Life, if they can. He among you who goes back from his Deen and dies in disbelief these are the ones whose works are rendered vain in this world and the Hereafter. These are the companions of Fire, to abide therein. 

    2:244 Fight in the Cause of God, and know that God is Hearer, Knower.

    [This is propagated as a verse of universal value, even forgetting the verse which says: Fight only in self-defence and against oppression since God does not love aggressors. 2:190-194] 

    8:37 God will distinguish the bad from the good, then pile the bad on top of one another and cast them together in the Hellfire. They are truly the losers. [The clans of rejecters will join hands to fight the believers, but the battleground will become Hell for them]

    8:38 (O Prophet) Tell the disbelievers that if they cease hostilities, all their past will be forgiven. But if they return, they will meet the example of the old nations. 

    8:39 Fight and subdue those who persist in aggression until persecution is no more, and absolute freedom of religion is established. People must be able to adopt a religion only for God’s Approval, and as free choice (2:193, 12:108). If they cease from aggression, God is the Seer of their actions, and therefore you shall leave them alone. 

    2:246 (Sustained commitment to the Divine Order with wealth and person is not an easy undertaking.) After the times of Moses, some leaders of the Israelites promised their Prophet (Samuel), “If you appoint a king for us, we will fight in the Cause of God.” The Prophet said, “Is it your intention to refrain from fighting if it was decreed to you?” They said’ “Why should we not fight in the Cause of God when we have been driven out of our homes with our children?” Yet when fighting was ordained for them, they turned away all but a few. God is Aware of the wrongdoers. 

    3:13 (Only recently at Badr) there was a sign for you in the two armies that met in combat. One was fighting in the Cause of God, the other denying Him. With their own eyes the two armies saw each other as twice their number. But God strengthens people with His support according to His Laws. This must be a lesson for people of vision for all times.

    3:167 And that He might mark out those afflicted with hypocrisy. They had been told, “Come! Fight in the Cause of God, or at least defend (the city).” They answered, “If we knew that confrontation was forthcoming, we would have indeed joined you.” On that day they were closer to disbelief than belief, uttering with their mouths something that was not in their hearts. But God was best Aware of what they were trying to conceal.

    3:168 Those who sat at home said of their brethren, “If they had listened to us they would not have been slain.” Say (O Messenger), “Then avert death from your own selves if you are truthful.”

    3:169 Think not of those, who are slain in the Cause of God, as dead. Nay, they are living! And by their Lord they are well provided for. [2:154, 3:156]

    3:170 They are happy in the Bounty that God has given them - and pleased for those left behind, who have not yet joined them - that upon them shall be no fear, nor anything to regret.

    3:171 They rejoice because of the favor from God and the Bounty. For, God never fails to reward those who have conviction in His Laws.

    3:172 For those who respond to God and the Messenger even after harm has struck them - and continue to work for the betterment of humanity and live upright, is a tremendous reward. [8:24]

    3:195 Thus their Lord accepts and answers their prayer, “Indeed, I never let the work of any worker, male or female, go vain. You are members, one of another. Hence, those who emigrate, and are driven from their homelands, and suffer harm in My Cause, and fight, and are slain, I shall certainly blot out their faults, erasing the imprints of their misdeeds on their ‘self’. And certainly, I shall admit them into Gardens with streams flowing beneath - a handsome return from God's Presence. For, with God is the fairest return of actions. [2:186]

    2:191 Subdue them regardless of their tribal affiliations, and drive them out of where they drove you out. For persecution, (terror, torture, oppression) is a crime even more grievous than killing. Do not fight against them near the Masjid of Security (a haven of amnesty) unless they attack you therein. But if they attack you there, then you shall fight against them. Such has to be the rebuttal of those who reject (the Standard of Peace). 

    2:193 Hence, fight them only until there is no more harassment, and Deen may be adopted for the sake of God alone. And if they desist, then let there be no hostility except against those who replace peace with aggression. 

    2:194 You may fight during the Months of Peace and Security if you are attacked, for, a violation of sanctity will activate the Law of Just retribution. So, the one who attacks you should expect retaliation in like manner. Be mindful of God, and know that God is with those who live upright. 

    2:195 (Defence of the Divine Order calls for sacrifice of wealth and person.) Hence, keep open your resources in the Cause of God, and let not your own hands throw you into destruction. Be beneficent! Indeed, God loves the doers of good. [You might throw yourselves into destruction by withholding contributions to this noble Cause]

    4:74 Let them fight in God’s Cause, all those who sell the life of this world for the other. Whoever fights in God’s Cause, be he slain or be he victorious, We shall soon give him an immense reward. 

    4:75 What has happened to you that you do not fight in the Cause of God? Defenceless men, women, and children are being oppressed and crying, "Our Lord! Rescue us from this town whose people are oppressors, and raise for us protectors and helpers." [God does not fight in person, or send His armies or angels physically. 22:39] 

    4:76 Believers fight in the Cause of God, that is, for the removal of tyranny and in self-defence (benign aggression). And the rejecters of the Truth fight in tyranny and for their selfish desire to oppress people (malignant aggression). So fight against those friends of Satan. Surely, Satan's plan is feeble because the selfish desire fails before the Divine Law of Requital. 

    4:77 Have you seen those who have been told, “Curb your hands, and establish the Divine System and set up the just Economic Order?” But as soon as the Command came to fight, some of them feared men as they should have feared God, or even more. They say, "Our Lord! Why have You ordained fighting for us? If only You had granted us a little more delay!" Say, “Brief is the enjoyment of this world, whereas the life to come is the best for those who live upright. None of you shall be wronged a hair’s breadth.” 

    4:78 Wherever you may be, death will find you, even if you live in fortified castles. When something good happens to them, they say, “It is from God.” And when affliction befalls them they say to each other, “This is from you O fellow-man!” Tell them, “All things happen according to God’s Laws.” What is amiss with these people, they do not understand a thing? 

    4:84 (O Messenger) Fight in the Cause of God. You are responsible only for yourself. Inspire the believers (to conquer all fear). God may well curb the might of the unbelievers (who are bent upon destroying the System). For God is the Strongest in Might, and Strongest in the ability to deter. [2:151]

    4:91 You will find others who desire peace for their people and make peace with you. But at the slightest opportune moment they come to fight against you. If they neither leave you alone, nor offer peace, nor hold their hands, subdue them regardless of which group they belong to. In their case, God has given you a clear Authority to fight. 

    5:33 The just punishment for those who wage war against God and His Messenger and endeavor to commit bloody crimes on earth, is that they be killed or crucified, or have their hands and feet severed on alternate sides, or be entirely banished from the land. Such is their disgrace in this world, and an awful suffering awaits them in the Hereafter.

    8:43 God made them few in your vision. Had He made them appear more numerous (and you got intimidated by their great numbers), you would have been discouraged. And you would have disputed among yourselves (whether fighting them at Badr was a good idea). But God saved you from faltering. He is fully Aware of what is in the hearts.

    8:44 When the two armies faced each other, He made them appear few in your eyes, and made you appear weak in their eyes (3:12). God willed that to be the Day of Distinction. All matters go back to God’s Laws as their source. 

    8:45 O You who have chosen to be graced with belief! Whenever you meet an army, be firm and remember God much, that you may be successful. [8:10]

    8:57 When you encounter them in war, deal with them to set an example for those who come after them, that they may remember. 

    8:59 Let not the rejecters suppose that they can get away with their violations. They cannot escape the Law of Requital. 

    8:60 Make ready for them all the power you can muster, and all the equipment you can mobilize so that you may deter the enemies of God, and your enemies. And others beside them whom you know not, God knows them. Whatever wealth and effort you spend on your defences, will be your spending in the Cause of God, and it will be repaid to you generously. And you shall not be wronged. 

    8:65 O Prophet! Inspire the believers (to conquer all fear of death) in times of war. If there be twenty of you who are patient in adversity, they shall overcome two hundred, and if there be one hundred of you, they shall overcome one thousand of those who are bent upon denying the Truth. This is because the rejecters of the Truth are people who cannot understand (the Eternal rewards that motivate the believers).

    8:66 For the time being, however, God has lightened your burden, for He knows that you are weak. And so, if there be one hundred of you who are steadfast in adversity, they should be able to overcome two hundred; and if there be one thousand of you, they should be able to overcome two thousand by God’s Leave. For, God is with those who are steadfast in adversity. 

    9:12 If they keep breaking their pledges after their treaty, and assail your System, then fight the chiefs of the disbelievers. They have no respect for their binding oaths. This action will help restrain them from aggression. 

    9:13 Will you not fight a folk who keep breaking their solemn pledges and did everything to drive out the Messenger, and did attack you first? What! Do you fear them? Nay, it is God alone Whom you should more justly fear, if you are truly believers. 

    9:14 Fight them! God will punish them at your hands, and He will humiliate them, and give you victory over them, and He will soothe the bosoms of those who believe. 

    9:16 Do you think that you will be left alone without God distinguishing those among you who strive in His Cause, and take none for ally except God, His Messenger, and the believers? And God is Aware of what you do. 

    9:29 Fight back against those who do not believe in God, nor in the Last Day, nor do they prohibit what God and His Messenger have prohibited, nor do they acknowledge the True Deen - among those who were given the Scripture, until they pay Jizya in humility. 

    9:32 They (Jews and Christians) seek to extinguish God’s Light (the Qur’an) by their utterances. But God will not allow this to pass, for He has willed to spread His Light in all its fullness even though the rejecters may detest it. 

    9:33 He it is Who has sent His Messenger with Guidance and the True Religion (Deen = The System of Life), that He may cause it to prevail over all religions and systems of life, even though the idolaters may detest it. [9:31-33, 13:31, 14:48, 18:48, 41:53, 48:28, 51:20-21, 61:8-9]

    [Commentary by Dr. Shabbir Ahmed: “the Qura’nic Deen will prevail over all other systems of life. This refers to religions such as Christianity, Judaism, Hinduism and all other forms of religion, including the sects that are now present in Islam. But next to religions, the Qur’anic Deen will also prevail over all political systems of the world such as Communism, Secular Democracy, Theocracy, Monarchy and it will rule over all ways of life as Humanism, Socialism and so on. This will happen as humanity willingly realizes the supremacy of The Qur’an”.]  


    9:36 God has ordained twelve months in one year. This has been God’s Ordinance since the day He created the heavens and the earth. Four of these Months are Sacred, forbidden for all warfare. This is the Firm Religion, the right way. So, do not wrong yourselves by fighting during the Sacred Months. However, you may fight the idolaters in any or all these months if they fight against you in any or all of them (2:194). And know that God is with those who restrain themselves. 

    9:38 O You who have chosen to be graced with belief! What is amiss with you that, when called upon, “Go forth in the Cause of God,” you cling heavily to the ground? Do you choose pleasure in the life of this world rather than in the life to come? The enjoyment of this life is but a paltry thing compared to the Hereafter. 

    9:39 If you did not go forth in God’s Cause, He (His Law) will afflict you with a painful doom. He will replace you with another nation. You cannot harm Him in the least. All things transpire according to the Laws appointed by God. [Only the competent nations live honorably on earth. 21:105, 24:55] 

    9:41 Go forth lightly armed, or heavily armed and strive with your wealth and person in the Cause of God. This is best for you if you but knew.

    9:44 Those who have conviction in God and the Last Day, do not ask you for exemption from striving with their wealth and persons. And God is Aware of those who live upright.

    9:47 Even if they had gone forth they would have only caused trouble and run to and fro seeking sedition among you. In your ranks are some apt to listen to them and in your ranks are spies of the enemy. God knows the wrongdoers.

    9:48 They have sought to create dissension among you before, and raised difficulties for you (O Prophet). They did that till the Truth came and the Decree of God prevailed, though they detested it.

    9:49 Of them is he who says, “Grant me leave, and do not draw me into trial.” Have they not fallen into trial already? In fact, Hell is all around the disbelievers.

    9:52 Say, "Can you expect for us other than one of two things?" - (Victory or martyrdom). On the other hand, we expect for you that God will send His retribution from Himself, or by our hands. Wait then expectant, and we shall hopefully wait with you.”

    9:53 (Some hypocrites want to make financial contributions.) Tell them, "Your contribution is not accepted whether you pay willingly or unwillingly. You are a people who drift away from the System at the first opportune time."

    47:4 If you meet the disbelievers in battle, then, strike at their Command centres. Until you have subdued them, then, bind them firmly. And thereafter, must be an act of kindness or ransom when the battle lays down its weapons. And if God willed, He could indeed punish them Himself, but that He may let you test one by means of another (as to which nation remains vigilant.) And, as for those who are slain in the Cause of God, He does not render their actions vain.

    [8:37, 38:40. Commentary by Dr. Shabbir Ahmed (available at www.ourbeacon.com)]: “Free the captives as an act of kindness or ransom, such as in exchange for your men in their captivity. There is no third option. Fadharb ar-riqaab is usually rendered as ‘smite their necks.’ A little contemplation, however, makes it plain that in a battle of swords and arrows no commander would order his soldiers to aim for the necks alone. Therefore, the stated term has been used idiomatically, indicating knocking out the command centres. It is interesting to note that even in today’s encounters with high technology this principle is given a top priority.”

    By Sultan Shahin - 5/28/2016 7:22:09 AM

  • All these arguments and debates won't work anymore. I and many Hindus know that this has to be solved all over the world only through one means. Full scale war. Civil or nation. Muslims versus the rest. Christians are getting ready and Hindus will join them surely. 
    By Hindu reader - 5/28/2016 7:14:42 AM

  • May Sultan Shahin & his tribe prosper & multiply.
    By Dileep Kumar Sen - 5/28/2016 6:50:18 AM

  • It is not righteousness that you turn your faces Towards east or West; but it is righteousness- to believe in Allah and the Last Day, and the Angels, and the Book, and the Messengers; to spend of your substance, out of love for Him, for your kin, for orphans, for the needy, for the wayfarer, for those who ask, and for the ransom of slaves; to be steadfast in prayer, and practice regular charity; to fulfil the contracts which ye have made; and to be firm and patient, in pain (or suffering) and adversity, and throughout all periods of panic. Such are the people of truth, the Allah-fearing. (2:177)
    By Syed Ahmed Shah - 5/28/2016 6:13:42 AM

  • Commendable and brave indeed!
    By Rajeev Khullar - 5/28/2016 6:06:14 AM

  • As education will increase among Muslims, these types of thoughts will start emerging. That's what mullahs and moulvis fear the most. That's why they don't want that Muslims get modern education. That's why they want madarsas where they can make cutter muslims who obey their orders.
    By Deepak Sabarwal - 5/28/2016 5:58:00 AM

  • A nice piece of an intellectual thought that need be given due weightage in order to synthesize this burning issue arose before us.
    By Rajmani Tewari - 5/28/2016 5:57:20 AM

  • Pakistan me 14% Hindu the ab 1% bache h 426 mandir the ab 28 bache h roz 12 hindu ladkio ko uta le jate h Bangladesh me 29 % hindu the ab 6 % bache h karodo log kat dale gaye sirf Dharm ke nam par
    By Raj Srivastava - 5/28/2016 5:49:58 AM

  • Wonderful your mind set ! Muslims are not safe in the world , you can't feel it ? Why are you silent ? Raise against mass killing and injustice which severe pain of Muslims ? 
    If you are really Muslim then write something in such injustice .Don't try to irritating other caste against Muslims

    By Elan Munshi - 5/28/2016 5:48:18 AM

  • Mr Sultan Sahin I don't know who are you and what is your job but it is very much clear that you are international stooge of anti Islam forces but you put into your small mind that that Quran is never against to any religion. Saudi Arabia govt is not allowed to build any other religious building like church ;temple etc so you please note that it is a their diplomatic as well as political decision ; Islam has nothing to do with it. No where in Quran it is written that religious building would not be built in the such and such area .The question of co existence is concern then it is very much clear that wine;interest ;nude women ;dishonesty ;rape;corruption;injustice ;stereotype;etc will not co existed with Islam but unfortunately people like you without these mentioned things not able to survive; so Islam will not be suited to people like you and co existence is not possible to such people with Islam.
    By Mohd Yunus - 5/28/2016 5:46:59 AM

  • A satanic agent
    By Mohammad Qazim - 5/28/2016 5:45:00 AM

  • Some people are mad and talk nonsense but Sir why you?
    By AL Misbah Rehman - 5/28/2016 5:44:35 AM

  • Sane has no use for religion..insane understand life is a prison.
    By Kuldeep Pandita - 5/28/2016 5:44:13 AM

  • I have asked time and again point 1 mistake otherwise stop this. I dont know whom you are trying to please, but I can only pity you as you are unable to point a single mistake.
    By Mastan Shaik - 5/28/2016 5:43:33 AM

  • First of All there is nothing like New Age Islam, the thing that is 'New' is the New world order. Second thing is that nodoubt Islam teaches us to not Destroy Religious places of Quffaars in War but doesnot teach us to build ones. There are already Billions of people to protect their Temples but as Muslims, our soul mission first of all should be to Protect our own Eimaan than to guard the Mandirs, for that purpose, let them hire security personals not muslims. This guy is mistranslating the Aayat. Qaaba had 370 idols, where are they ? Did the Prophet not know Quran well so now you have found an aayat that he missed ?
    There were times when the Name of Allah was chanted in Churches but that was in the time of Jesus. In our times, we hear the calls of god the Son, god the fathrr, god the spirit, ram ram, kali, krishna, seeta from these places, Not the Name of One true Lord, so it is not our Job to protect them, but to Build our Faith to a level that when we Recite Allah hu Akbar, the idols bow down their heads on the Ground like the 370 Idols of Kaaba.

    By Jahan Zeb - 5/28/2016 5:41:16 AM

  • Dear Admin
    Your 95% fellow brethern doesn't want change!! Liberalism can't be accepted in your society where fundamentalism is so deep in its roots. Always ignoring mindset never let them change.

    By भागीरथ गोदारा - 5/28/2016 5:38:27 AM

  • Mr.Shahin.is your magazine available on bookstalls? I want your I'm book form.
    Pl reply.

    By U.p. Ojha - 5/28/2016 5:37:38 AM

  • When talking about the war-related verses as contextual, the Sufi-Sunni clerics and great theologians of the past have already called them contextual. So we should not say “no clerics have done that”. We Muslims are indebted to these great scholars who produced the science of absab-e-nuzul and context. This is their guidance as a result of depth study of Islam that has enabled me and others so far to write numerous articles on refutation of the modern terrorism. This is the guidance whereby the Sufi-Sunni minded Muslims around the world have refuted the theology of ISIS, Taliban, Boko Haram etc, putting their lives at stake. Most of them have even lost their lives. In Syria and Iraq, such scholars and clerics are the target of the terrorism of ISIS, Al-Qaeda, Boko Haram. So, we should not ignore that the reason of fight between ISIS and the Sufi-Sunni clerics is the doctrinal difference. If there had not been any such difference, the militants of ISIS would not have killed the clerics.

    By Ghulam Ghaus غلام غوث - 5/28/2016 2:18:06 AM

  • Yes, the war-related verses are contextual applicable only for defence after no option is left for Muslims as a community except to defend their life. In that sense, if any scholar like Dr. Tahirul Qadri calls these verses applicable to us even today, I find no state of astonishing. Every country has right to defence. With this point we understand that as long as our beloved country India has democracy, peace-treaty among us and constitution based on justice regardless of religion, it is compulsory to abide by the rule of India. It is also worthy to note that if any oppression is done at individual level or  any unjust interfere is done in our religious matter, it is still necessary to fight for defence and our right to freely practice our religion, in a democratic way as much as our Indian constitution allows us.
    By Ghulam Ghaus غلام غوث - 5/28/2016 2:07:27 AM

  • Of course, there is not a single “intolerant” verse in the holy Quran.

    It is merely a cause of misunderstanding or wrong to use the bad word ‘intolerant’ with any verses of the holy Qura'n.

    The war-related verses are defensive in nature. But unfortunately not only do the modern terrorists misuse these verses for their intolerant pieces of work but even some “progressive Muslims” too painfully present these verses with the tag of “intolerant”. If our ‘progressive Muslims’ continue to call these verses ‘intolerant’, they have no ground to defend Islam. They should stop calling ulemas or any anyone to refute the terrorists’ anti-Islamic theology. To me, this way our ‘progressive Muslims’ can only strengthen the propaganda of the modern terrorism/kharijisim.

    The sense that our “progressive Muslims” are unfortunately using to understand these verses and call them ‘intolerant’ will not let them get free from their own intolerant attitude. From that sense, I see everyone in the world is intolerant. If both defensive and offensive attitude are meant to be intolerant, then no one is free from this intolerant attitude. 

    By Ghulam Ghaus غلام غوث - 5/28/2016 1:54:10 AM

  • Sultan shahin...you're the great...atleast there is someone who can understand islam...and showing the path of humanity... sir..never give up..humans(not7th century muslims) are with you..
    By Vishesh - 5/27/2016 8:39:10 AM

  • GREAT work, Mr. Sultan Shahin.  Please do keep doing it despite the brickbats (and the risk).  Just please be safe.  After the killings by Islamists in Bangladesh, every Reformist Muslim must be very very careful.  Your points are being proved right, right here in the comments!  Other than Ghulam Mohiyuddin, I don't see any Muslim-named commenter in any mood to introspect.  You are ABSOLUTELY right:  a huge huge majority of Believing Muslims live in the 7th Century CE.  I wish you had also mentioned that Indians Muslims enjoy more benefits as Muslims than do non-majority-faction-Muslims in Islamic countries: what is the level of religious freedom of Shia Muslims in Saudi Arabia, of Sunni Muslims in Iran, and in Pakistan, of Ahmadi Muslims (yes, they ARE Muslims, because THEY call themselves Muslim- who the hell is anyone else to call them non-Muslim?)  I wish you the best, and hope that some Muslims listen to you and strengthen the voice for reform.  For if not, the world will be divided in only two classes, Believing Muslims, and those hating Believing Muslims. And much to the chagrin of today's Mainstream Muslims, the latter class will have a good number of those born in Muslims families!  WAKE UP MUSLIMS...  or you'll find that there will be few believers like Sultan Shahin trying to reform you and many more people like me who are no more scared of telling to your face that ALL ideologies including yours are false.  Please wake up.
    By Owais Khan - 5/27/2016 7:39:08 AM

  • No religion is by Allah or God or Bhagwan..What they call religion is the bullshit by the intelligent masters to befool them...Islam is for Arabs and their slaves who live in other parts of the world..
    By moonis - 5/27/2016 6:31:33 AM

  • Sultan Shahin's agenda is to make Hindus happy at the cost of losing his religion and inspiring violent Hindus to fight against Muslims because ''they are terrorists'' and living in 7th century. when he is not for his Muslims how can he be for Hindus?
    He speaks against Islam and says ''he should respect all''
     He is simply creating chaos and hatred among muslims and hindus. 
    Many countries have banned this site, majority of muslims do not want to open this site, they hate Sultan Shahin and his hypocricy.  
    As for Qadyanis and Ahmadis, they are kaafir becuase of their blasphemous and apostate acts. 
    after reading the verses as given below, The hypocrisy of sultan shahin is very understood. 
    "2:11        When it is said to them, "Make not mischief on the earth. They say, Why, we only want to make peace!"

    2:12        Of a surety, they are the ones who make mischief, but they realize (it) not.

    2:13        When it is said to them, "Believe as the others believe." They say "Shall we believe as the fools believe?" Nay, of a surety they are the fools, but they do not know.

    2:14        When they meet those who believe, they say We believe. But when they are alone with their shayateen, they say We are really with you. We (were) only jesting.

    2:27        Those who break Allah's covenant after it is ratified, and who sunder what Allah Has ordered to be joined, and do mischief on earth; these cause loss (only) to themselves."
    Muslims of all sects of India must be united to fight against fitna of sultan shahin along with fighting against fitna of terrorism across the world. 

    By Abid Raza - 5/27/2016 1:10:02 AM

  • Who is Allah ? What the world made first time . Who Allah made messenger of Allah ' Mohammed , what is message , hate the people who don't believe me (Mohammed ) as pagember . What equality given in Islam to my Muslims sisters mothers and other believes and in the name and ordered by Allah to convert all world to accept the mohemmed as pagember ' this is only Islam ..
    No it is not acceptable in any condition it the hatest false in the name of actual god .. listen all the jehadis you stop to make would ,s people make foolish . And come in your originally Islamic ageda written by Allah or your holly pagember or sahabas .. 
    Sun moon earth not changed gods difination of god chaneged by a man , and no any other knowngeble further come or send by god .
    How entersting .

    By Sushil Kumar Goel - 5/26/2016 9:17:16 PM

  • @SN MishraWhich needs reforms by humans it cannot be rellegion, rellegion is from Almighty, cannot develop such faults which humans can repair.
    By DrMohammed Farooq Kalas - 5/26/2016 9:14:49 PM

  • Today world needs scholars in all religions to elucidate the true meanings of scriptures.
    Semi literate muscle men craving for pelf and power to gratify their lust are controlling the spheres where only accredited scholars are entitled to enter.
    If all the religions declare that only persons with superior academic credentials with study of at least two different religions can hold any right to control and guide the followers of any religion, the shape of things will undergo a sea change.

    By Bharat Bhushan Bagga - 5/26/2016 9:13:15 PM

  • @Gyanendra pratap singh If prophet freed his slave and told others if they free their slaves that will be in heaven what does it mean It all depends on geographical areas can I tell me what is legal and of marrying in different countries at presen including USA.epitome of modern mindset
    By Neel Fayaz Dar - 5/26/2016 9:04:41 PM

  • @Neel Fayaz Also would you say that child marriage is not allowed in Islam? say marrying less that 14 year to be precise?
    By Gyanendra Pratap Singh - 5/26/2016 9:01:56 PM

  • @Neel fayaz do you want to say that slavery is not legal in Islam?
    By Gyanendra Pratap Singh - 5/26/2016 9:00:12 PM

  • The day Islamists stop multiplying and learn to be grateful to the earth to preserve its resources, the world shall become a heaven.
    By Hanuman Goyal - 5/26/2016 8:55:32 PM

  • We are Muslims with the extreme mercy of Allah but not to lose our religious dignity for the sake of coexistence.

    By Saifullah Khan - 5/26/2016 4:48:40 PM

  • Sultan Shahin You are a bloody idiot person. You want Quran to be edited according to your whims & fancies . Many a times you idiot shy away from my question and start beating about bush. I think you remember my name on your anti-Islamic website.
    You supp
    ort atrocities done by Jews / Zionists on Philistines . You demonize even holy prophet Muhammad ( PBUH) .You support Ahmadis ( anti-Muslim jamaat who misuse Islam by declaring themselves Muslims and the same Ahmadis / Mirzayis / Qadiani worked hand in hand with the Britishers against freedom movement of India ) Sultan Shahin and your bunch of idiots should surf your website to read my comments & feedbacks and you always loosing against me.

    By Shahid Sayyidain - 5/26/2016 4:35:46 PM

  • Quran is not a book.
    God did not ask prophet to compile the sayings az a book.
    Later i followers compiled those into a book
    They did not have the intelligence to compile in the order of revelation.
    If any one of you  have intelligence ,then re compile  it in the proper order and study.You will find many contradictions  and thus realise that Muslims were cheated all these  years. God willing some day you will realise.

    By Pcs - 5/26/2016 4:04:28 PM

  • I fully agree ! I have a question for those who are in business of conversion and who project their faith as Only Gateway to Salvation/Paradise :
    If matters of life n death are in the hands of Allah/God, then all those who are born to any faith come with His approval !
    Why then interfere in His will ??

    By Umesh Sharma - 5/26/2016 1:15:23 PM

  • Sultan Shahin seems to have no belief in Quran and the prophet which is why he makes fun of Islamic teachings and its laws of 7th century just like Ahmadis. Muslims know and believe that Quran cannot be changed nor the sayings of the prophet. These are relevant for all times. They have solutions to all the problems plaguing mankind today.
    By Serajuddin Khurram - 5/26/2016 1:13:58 PM

  • The problem is not 7th century mindset. The real problem with Muslims is that they do not follow the Quran which is why they appear to be intolerant. The Quran says: "No compulsion in religion" (2:256). But many outfits of Muslims ignore these words of the Quran. So these outfits are responsible for the mischief and their inability to mingle and coexist with followers of other faiths and not Islam which teaches tolerance and good behaviour. Many so called Islamic outfits have been created by the West and Zionists which apparently are Islamic but these have nothing to do with Islam as these have been created to malign and distort Islamic teachings and bring a bad name to this most tolerant faith on earth.
    By Serajuddin Khurram - 5/26/2016 1:13:22 PM

  • Thre is only GOD based religion ...that is islam..itz ideal 4 all of us..its a guide to everyhuman being ...and a solution of un solved matters nd solutions...its the advanced way of living....but now thre wre entrng some fraud persons and doing wrng in the name of muslims.....whethr that propagandists is in any muslim country...whtr iz that a saudi..pakistan indonasia ..mlasia iran and canada...basically i hve no wrds to disscs all that things ..wich is going on but its totally the diplomacy are playing by israel trynst...and also sum other countried are involung in this huge crime.....they suported to them 4 spreading the ....menacing in all islamic countries ....on the name of muslims...
    By Kaiser Aasifi - 5/26/2016 1:12:19 PM

  • Very brave of Sultan Shahin to come to the crux of the problem. It is the belief in the immutable underlying doctrine that prevents Islamists from tolerating, leave alone respecting other faiths. Whatever a believer does is sanctified and whatever an infidel does is anathema. More and more people have to introspect for the world to co exist in peace.
    By Ranjeet Chordia - 5/26/2016 1:09:33 PM

  • @Umesh Sharma 
    Sorry sir.but your interpretation about mindset of seventh century Muslims is wrong.they were very ahead of time who were successful in coexisting from Europe to Asia .who gave women's the equality.who laid foundation of abolishing slavery.who made people aware of knowledge and believed in spreading knowledge. This mind set you are talking is medieval centuries which was created by kings .sultans.priests .clerics for their personal gains out of which we have to come.

    By Neel Fayaz Dar - 5/26/2016 1:08:35 PM

  • Quran 18:29 & 10:99 - tht freedom of religion is God given right
    By Umesh Sharma - 5/26/2016 1:07:31 PM

  • Harmony and peaceful coexistence of all mankind is only solution; as our Vedas declare.
    By Akhilesh Kumar - 5/26/2016 1:06:37 PM

  • @Israr Shah Also read verse, inna deena indallah el Islam, the only rellegion acceptable by Allah is Islam, and what Islam is that practiced by prophet.

    By DrMohammed Farooq Kalas - 5/26/2016 1:04:47 PM

  • You are right brother.
    Nazir Ahmad Bhat.

    By Jawed Iqbal - 5/26/2016 1:02:54 PM

  • @Israr Shah...i never asked u be interested, iam just responding the politically oriented question than question based on religion..plz keep your commitment and sublime valued views alive..thx..
    By Nazir Ahmad Bhat - 5/26/2016 1:02:15 PM

  • @Nazir Ahmed Bhat Muslim... n I am not intrested in Nazir. 

    Coz I read quran myself. O people of religion.... (not Muslim only) many times U should read too.

    By Israr Shah - 5/26/2016 12:58:56 PM

  • @Ranjeet Chordia..i already said under the name of religion, you are dragging the religion with your hate motive. in pak or bangla for whom i am least bothered to represent if unfortuntately minorities are disturbed how come it is attributed to islam and muslims 
    By Nazir Ahmad Bhat - 5/26/2016 12:57:35 PM

  • Best example if you really are interested. You can read The Conquest of Jeuraseulam by Muslims of 7th century under leadership of Umar bin khatab r.a .by any non Muslim authour then you will come to know about The Mindset of Seventh Century Muslims.Even in modern times I mean present you won't have any such example of the character.discipline.moral values and not harming others.after doing research on this subject if you are man of any moral values should apologise for your views.
    By Neel Fayaz Dar - 5/26/2016 12:56:42 PM

  • Islam came to us as a dynamic and reformative new wave and it should continue as a dynamic and reformative force. Being a "Religion of the Book" does not mean that we have to be tied down by the Book to a point of stagnation. The Book should be seen as an affirmation of continuing evolution and progress. . . .

    True Muslims should have no problem incorporating scientific advances, human rights principles, gender equality, respect for the belief systems of others and the concept of humanity being one big family. We must categorically reject intolerance, violence and jihadism. We must appreciate and honor the UN's Universal Declaration of Human Rights as well as the Constitution of India.

    By Ghulam Mohiyuddin - 5/26/2016 12:56:26 PM

  • #RajkamalGoswami ji Molvi sahab ko awaam Quran parh ker bata deti hai.
    Jab imaam namaz parhatey hain aur kahin kuchh bhool jatey hain to peechhey namaz parhney wale unko sahi bata dete hain.

    Musalman tab banta hai jab poora Quran parh leta hai.
    Kewal Muslim ke ghar paida honay se Musalman nahin hota hai.

    Kewal Hindu ke ghar paida honay se Hindu ho sakta hai. Dharmik pustak parhna awashyak nahin Hindu ke liye.

    By Jawed Iqbal - 5/26/2016 12:54:52 PM

  • Hats off to Sultan Shahin for speaking the truth. May his tribe FLOURISH, may Jihadist Terrorist be terminated , persecution of Hindus in Pakistan be stopped.
    By Sachchidanand Paradkar - 5/26/2016 12:51:42 PM

  • @Nazir Ahmad Bhat Two wrongs do not make a right . Let each one live according to his belief and give up the divinely ordained mission to convert the world to what you consider the true faith and the problem disappears. You may be right about the motive of the author but at least listen to his message. Who is to blame for the blood letting among the different sects within the faith? Intolerance will lead us nowhere.
    By Ranjeet Chordia - 5/26/2016 12:32:32 PM

  • ..all the viewrs are requested to be aware of this person who quotes himself as some SULTAN and under the title New Age, he is pisionoiusly propogating against the basics of islam, earlier he touched topic of tripple talak but simaltemnousely wanted entire reformation of holy quran allowing others to doubt its authenticity on scientific basis. to my undrstanding he is well inducted and planned by the anti islamic agencies including Israeli spying agencies to attack and create confusions under social front.
    if some political government in Bangla or Pak is doing wrong, it shall never be attributed to holy quran or religion of islam, the way in India, killing of inter se communities is neither supported by religion of any caste, the spy inducted author had forgotten to remind bible or torah when in Bosnia the Muslims were mulilated by christain serbs or in plestine thousnads of homes are bulldozed in occupied land, till date more than one lac childern had alone been killed in plestione and this paid agent forgot to remind his masters doing something against their holy book...all the conscientious brothern must join to resist his faciast move which is aimed at to disintegrate the muslims on the name of religion..
    while being cosmetic champion and smpathisier of minorities, how come he forgot to remind myanmar president who spoke her open hate against muslim jounalist, besdies, seeing thousands of muslims being brutally killed by none other than peaxceful budhists...beaware of this dangerous person..

    By Nazir Ahmad Bhat - 5/26/2016 12:25:38 PM

  • If a religion can't be reformed, quit it . Very simple !
    By SN Mishra - 5/26/2016 12:23:11 PM

  • @Umesh Sharma 
    I see even praying as an interference in his will 

    By Tabish Umar Ansari - 5/26/2016 12:00:38 PM

  • I fully agree ! I have a question for those who are in business of conversion and who project their faith as Only Gateway to Salvation/Paradise :
    If matters of life n death are in the hands of Allah/God, then all those who are born to any faith come with His approval !
    Why then interfere in His will ??

    By Umesh Sharma - 5/26/2016 11:56:59 AM

  • The day Islamists stop multiplying and learn to be grateful to the earth to preserve its resources, the world shall become a heaven.
    By Hanuman Goyal - 5/26/2016 11:52:19 AM

  • Qur'an kaun parhta hai, maulvi sahab jo kahte hain wohi Islam hai.
    By Rajkamal Goswami - 5/26/2016 11:46:34 AM

  • @Shariq Aman, Janab Aman Saheb, According to you there is no need to introspect and all evil resides in others who do not share your faith. This exactly lies at the heart of the problem. All humans , Muslims included have flaws. They should try to improve themselves rather than reforming the world at gun point.
    By Ranjeet Chordia - 5/26/2016 11:38:55 AM

  • If Muslims were that evil , Marwaris may have not been in the Gulf especially Dubai and Hinduja bros in Iran.Your doctrine is Na baap bada na bhaiya,sabse bada rupaiya. See how marwaris have looted and ravishid Nepal. A Nepali national hates marwaris most ad Germans hate jews to this day.Marwaris indulge in Hawala rackets in Nepal that's an open secret.
    By Shariq Aman - 5/26/2016 11:35:57 AM

  • Nazir Ahmad Bhat what you have written is a verse delivered before the Hijra . Verses before Hijra advocate peace . But verses delivered after Hijra call for armed jihad against those who don't accept Islam . You know the truth but you are hiding it for vested interests .
    By SN Mishra - 5/26/2016 11:32:49 AM

  • Nazir Ahmad Bhat, Thank you for quoting that Sura. But the zealots quote many other verses to justify what they are doing. Extreme views by anyone are unacceptable in this age where weapons of mass destruction abound. Times have changed since the days of sword and lance fighting. Wars today destroy everyone Momeen and Kafir alike. Live in mutual respect because the alternative is death for all.
    By Ranjeet Chordia - 5/26/2016 11:28:25 AM

  • ..dear bro, ranjeet, hope you will refresh your memories away from any pre-oppression on the issue which by and large is based on political pungent and hate..holy quran categorically states..LUKUM DENA KUM WAILYA DEEN.. you to your religion me to my religion. There is nothing written in Islam which could allow plundering or disrespecting the faith of others..Arabs have history of co-existence with other communities so is the case in sub-continent..

    By Nazir Ahmad Bhat - 5/26/2016 11:26:58 AM

  •  Very brave of Sultan Shahin to come to the crux of the problem. It is the belief in the immutable underlying doctrine that prevents Islamists from tolerating, leave alone respecting other faiths. Whatever a believer does is sanctified and whatever an infidel does is anathema. More and more people have to introspect for the world to co exist in peace.

    By Ranjeet Chordia - 5/26/2016 11:24:25 AM

  • A thought provoking article which should reach every Muslim household so that they understand what is India and how well they are looked after ! Strangely, Believets believe that "cause" of everything which happen in universe is because of Allah then by this logic if we are born in non Muslim homes then it's Allahs' will ! Why challenge His order ???
    By Umesh Sharma - 5/26/2016 10:26:14 AM