Books and Documents

The War Within Islam (20 Apr 2017 NewAgeIslam.Com)

The Lynching of Mashal Khan Proves Pakistan is Dystopic


By Arshad Alam, New Age Islam

20 April 2017







Mashal, a 23-year-old journalism student


A university as a space is supposed to nurture critical ideas: ideas which have the potential to challenge the existing mores of society and at times force it to think in newer ways. Increasingly, that space is shrinking all around us. Whether in India or in Pakistan, right wing groups have increasingly taken recourse to the pernicious logic of hurt feelings to shut out and punish those who have dared to speak up their convictions. Eventually, a society which stops thinking is dead and that’s what it happening in Pakistan today. Mashal Khan, pulled out from his room, dragged and then shot dead because he was an Ahmadi and allegedly had views which was different from the mainstream Muslim society, is the latest victim of the deadly mutation which has taken place in the heart of Islam. Killing for blasphemy seems to be becoming one of the favourite sport in Pakistan. Whether it is a personal rivalry, the greed for land or business, charging anyone with blasphemy is all that you have to do if you want to settle scores with that person. If that person happens to be a minority or an Ahmadi, then all the more easier as the law and society are also prejudiced against them.

The problem gets compounded when the state itself becomes partisan. After all, it is the Pakistani state which is the upholder of such a discriminatory law. But no one has the strength or the conviction to openly say that the law itself is the problem and that its high time that the law should be repealed. But who wants to take that risk after seeing the fate of Salman Taseer who was shot dead because he spoke against this law. Who wants to meet the fate of several brilliant lawyers who have lost their lives defending Muslims and others accused of blasphemy. So what we do have is the usual condemnation of the killers for taking the law into their hands. This is a clever deception since it deliberately does not raise the source of the problem which is the law itself. It is not that the lives of those accused of blasphemy who have not been killed is any better. Arrest is mandatory and the law takes years to run its course. Even when the person is acquitted, their lives have been destroyed beyond repair.

But then it is pretty hard for any state to perhaps go against the popular sentiments of the people. We also need to understand that the Pakistani state hardly enjoys the kind of hegemony which other states like India enjoys due to its uninterrupted rein of democracy. In this kind of situation, the Pakistani state can hardly do anything to upset the popular sentiment in that country. And that popular sentiment actually tells us that an apostate or a blasphemer has to be killed. There is a near consensus that Ahmadis are non-Muslims because they do not believe in the finality of Prophet Muhammad and are therefore liable to killed. It is a sentiment which is present all across Muslim societies from Morocco to Indonesia. Anyone deemed to have insulted the Prophet must die.

And yet the Prophet himself gave us a very different message. One of the stories about him is that he was daily abused by a woman when he used to preach the message of Islam. The Prophet never rebuked her but actually went to her house and inquired about her health when she fell ill. That message seems to have been lost on his followers. They want to do what the Prophet never taught. Perhaps this generation of Muslims understand Islam much better than the Prophet himself. Allah definitely warns all those who insult the Prophet, but then he goes on to say that He is the only one to judge them. But today, Muslims have themselves become the judge, the jury and the executioner in cases related to blasphemy.

As I write these lines, news has just come of another murder in Pakistan: this time of a retired university professor. She was also an Ahmadi. If one is expecting that Pakistan is doing any rethinking on this law, then we are mistaken. If anything, they are making this law more stringent by mounting greater surveillance on the social media and practically snooping on whether anyone is posting content deemed to be blasphemous. People will keep dying: just for their conviction, just because they want to breathe free under a blue sky or just because they havea poster of Karl Marx in their hostel rooms. A new video has emerged which shows students who participated in the lynching of Mashal Khan shouting God is great. The terror of that slogan is such that the university authorities have now instituted an inquiry against the corpse of Mashal Khan. Long live Pakistan!


Arshad Alam is a social and political commentator and a www.NewAgeIslam.com columnist

URL: http://www.newageislam.com/the-war-within-islam/arshad-alam,-new-age-islam/the-lynching-of-mashal-khan-proves-pakistan-is-dystopic/d/110839

New Age IslamIslam OnlineIslamic WebsiteAfrican Muslim NewsArab World NewsSouth Asia NewsIndian Muslim NewsWorld Muslim NewsWomen in IslamIslamic FeminismArab WomenWomen In ArabIslamophobia in AmericaMuslim Women in WestIslam Women and Feminism



  • This is to express ones disgust at this sordid affair generated by blasphemy law anywhere in Muslim world!

    Historically Muhammad the Messenger of God during his mission of spreading the message of Quran had suffered boycott, torment, taunts and ridicule at the hands of the Makkans--vouchsafes Quran in many verses-- yet forgave them all when he conquered the city.

    Muslims in general and Pakis in particular take pride in reminding the world at large of this magnanimity of the person they call reverentially Muhammadur-Rasullullah. Though they seldom add the fact that he returned to Madinah, the city of his refuge, leaving the Makkans to live unmolested in their own ways as they wished, and that is according to Qurans instructions.

    This sort of treatment was inflicted on all the previous Messenger, says Quran. We know what happened to Jesus!

    The savagery depicted in this sordid affair in Pakistan, of taking law in their own hands and in falsifying Quran’s message of walking away from blasphemous confrontation is committing blasphemy against the Messenger and his message of Quran.

    Therefore, those who take the law in their own hands; knowingly or in utter ignorance and savagely or not, and all those in authority to have enacted the law of blasphemy should – according to their own belief in their religious laws – be humanely shot dead and then cremated!

    There is a responsibility on every citizen of the world to live in harmony.

    By Rashid Samnakay - 4/27/2017 1:44:53 AM

  • “Whither we are headed”?  A quote from Abraham Lincoln says, “If we could first know where we are, and whither we are tending, we could then better judge what to do, and how to do it.”

    I am glad that Ghulam knows “Where we are”.  It is pathetic that Islamic theologians or Ulema do not know where they are. Obviously they are tending towards anarchy and inevitably the world will also move in the same direction. Since there is no central authority like Pope and no system to excommunicate the errant and the extremist Mullahs, who in competition with others, issue irrelevant, inconsistent and incompatible fatwas from time to time, anarchy would prevail in many parts of the world. In another 50 years’ time, in this interconnected world, many would leave Islam. It is imperative that Ulema should invite theologians from 76 sects of Islam and find consensus in “What to do and how to do” to stop the internecine killings and other urgent matters.



    By Royalj - 4/23/2017 6:32:02 PM

  • Arshadji,
    Your sensitive and accurate rendition of growing intolerance both within the country and outside implores us all to think critically about our belief and value systems.

    By Meera - 4/21/2017 1:56:38 AM

  • If the Islamic theologians or ulema have explained the right perception of Allah these problems would not have cropped up.

    Since Allah is a non-religious being, therefore, all hate is abhorrent to Allah.

    Allah being a Allah of moral perfection therefore, every one has the total and complete right to find his/her own way to Allah or not.

    Allah being a Allah of moral perfection therefore Allah is not a racist, slaver, no man is the property of another man.

    Allah being a Allah ofmoral perfection therefore Allah gave man a free will to do good or evil, to explore the truth of any question including His existence.

    Allah being a Allah of moral perfection therefore Allah is all pure mercy. Allah is all pure compassion. Allah is all pure forgiveness. Allah does not permit the killing of any human being. When the state executes criminals, the state is committing murder. In short, the state itself becomes a murderer. Mankind does not have the right to kill mankind

    By Royalj - 4/21/2017 12:36:47 AM

  • Right wing intolerance has become increasingly rabid and violent throughout the subcontinent. Killing in the name of the Prophet or in the name of the cow is an insult to the religion of the killers. Voices of reason and moderation are being shunted aside. Whither are we headed?

    By Ghulam Mohiyuddin - 4/20/2017 12:31:50 PM

Compose Your Comments here:
Email (Not to be published)
Fill the text
Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in the articles and comments are the opinions of the authors and do not necessarily reflect that of NewAgeIslam.com.