Books and Documents

Islamic Society (31 Aug 2017 NewAgeIslam.Com)

Eid-ul-Adha at Bhopal 2014: A Reflection

By Syed Rizvi, New Age Islam

31 August 2017

< >

Just 3 years ago, 2014, at this time of the Muslim month of the Eid ul Adha, when Muslims all over the world mercilessly slaughter 100s of millions of gentle animals by slitting their throats over a period of three days while animal being fully conscious as prescribed by the Islamic law of Sharia to please their God, three women from an animal rights organization PeTA-India were going to set up a table outside one of India’s largest mosques at an India’s major city of Bhopal. These women were carrying signs “Happy Eid” please try vegan dish and had vegan recipe to hand out.

 One of these women was a Muslim girl dressed in Muslim outfit made of vegetable and leaves. No sign they carried said anything like stop animal slaughter as reported by some news media. But before these women got theirs table set at a spot for which they had gotten the permission from the authorities, a mob (estimated to be 8,000) armed with sticks and knives attacked these three women shouting Allah u Akbar, They carried well design and previously prepared signs implying these girls' action was a anti Islam. Sadly enough one of the three women while running away from the scene got left behind but had it not been for the brave police officers who protected this lady I can imagine her fate would not have been any different from Mashal Khan’s whose body was literally crushed at the premises of a Pakistani University campus for saying something on the Face Book that could qualify as blasphemy.

The question why the Muslims did not ask PeTA not to bring their signs and set up the table unless it was the intention of the Muslim crowd to show their anger through violence, I am sure PeTA wouldn’t have sent its volunteers in harm’s way. I myself being a founding member of PeTA have never seen PeTA getting involved in any violent confrontation with any group or individual. All PeTA demonstration and protests have been nonviolent keeping up with the teachings of Martin Luther King and Mahatma Gandhi. I have posted only one video here showing the intensity and the confrontational strength of the opposition. There are many more on the You Tube and Google that can be easily found there.

Obviously what we see here is not something that could have emerged sporadically; it in fact was a well thought out and pre planned event. Also the Muslim crowd did not look like the turbaned rugged Talibans from Afghanistan Mountain, or the vicious Isis terrorists from the Iraqi deserts which our so called main stream moderate Muslims take no time in distancing themselves from. The crowd we see is the just every day main stream Muslims we meet them at our work place or markets, or in our homes. This could happen in Pakistan as well, although unlike the India scene, no Pakistani police officer could have stepped in to protect the lady while putting his own life in harm’s way.

It is not a surprise that no Muslim leader or clergy condemned this action of the Muslims but it is deplorable that no lefts, liberals, or secularist said a word against this despicable behaviour of the main stream India’s Muslims.

Syed Rizvi is a Physicist and Founder/President of Engineers and Scientists for Animal Rights. He is a vegan and writes on ethical issues that relate Humans, Animals, and the Environment.  Syed lives with his two cats Navaz and Tiger in his two-bedroom house in the heart of the Silicon Valley, California, USA.

URL: http://www.newageislam.com/islamic-society/syed-rizvi,-new-age-islam/eid-ul-adha-at-bhopal-2014---a-reflection/d/112397

New Age IslamIslam OnlineIslamic WebsiteAfrican Muslim NewsArab World NewsSouth Asia NewsIndian Muslim NewsWorld Muslim NewsWomen in IslamIslamic FeminismArab WomenWomen In ArabIslamophobia in AmericaMuslim Women in WestIslam Women and Feminism


  • Slaughter must not be wasteful or unduly painful to the animal or unhygienic or an ugly sight in public view.

    PETA folks have every right to be vegetarian but they should respect the food habits of others and not act 'holier-than-thou'.

    Carnivorousness is the law of nature for perhaps the vast majority of animal species.

    By Ghulam Mohiyuddin - 8/31/2017 12:37:29 PM

  • Dear Syed Rizvi,
    Have you also protested mass scale slaughter of cattle in automated meat processing plants for no meat can be produced without  slaughtering a cattle-head - though it goes without saying that slaughtering of cattle in urban setting is a nuisance and in the sight of those who love or worship cattle - very cruel.

    By muhammd yunus - 8/31/2017 6:39:06 AM

  • The Qur'an's take on animal slaughter is summed up in the following excerpt from my exeg work, Essential Message of Islam:

    [The Qur'an states]: "Neither their flesh nor their blood reaches God, but your heedfulness (taqwa) does indeed reach Him. Thus, He has subjected them to you, that you glorify God as He has guided you; and give good news to the compassionate ” (22:37).

    In the nomadic society of pre-Islamic Arabia, cattle head constituted the main instrument of asset. They were treated with honor, and sacrificed to please various deities. The Qur’an permitted the continuation of this rite, but reserved it only for God.

    Today, the pilgrim does not personally slaughter the cattle, nor does he eat its meat or share it with the poor (22:36). Besides, God’s bounty has multiplied exponentially and a cattle head is hardly a cherished asset as in the earlier times. It is therefore worth pondering whether mere slaughtering of cattle by arranging through a bank or agent, and then a state sponsored processing and distribution of the meat to poor nations really meets the letter or the spirit of the Qur’an - or there could be better ways to helping the world’s needy, such as through the generation of an International Hajj Relief Fund. God knows best!"
    Ch. 47.1

    By muhammd yunus - 8/31/2017 6:27:10 AM

Compose Your Comments here:
Email (Not to be published)
Fill the text
Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in the articles and comments are the opinions of the authors and do not necessarily reflect that of NewAgeIslam.com.