Books and Documents

Islam and Sectarianism (20 Feb 2017 NewAgeIslam.Com)

Murderous Sectarianism in Islam: Salafi Ulema Should Not Only Condemn the Massacre at Lal Shahbaz Qalandar Shrine but Also the Ideology behind It

By Sultan Shahin, Founding Editor, New Age Islam

21 February 2017

The massacre of over a hundred devotees at Sufi shrine of Jhule Lal Shahbaz Qalandar at Sehwan in Sindh, Pakistan is neither the first such incident nor is it going to be the last. There are condemnations galore from Muslims of all hues including Salafi-Wahhabis. The general secretary of Indian Jamiat Ahl-e-Hadith, Maulana Asghar Ali Imam Mehdi Salafi, for instance, has condemned the incident in the strongest terms.

However, the problem is that contrary to all evidence Salafi-Wahhabis refuse to accept that it is their own theology that has created an environment in which such regular massacres have become possible. Indeed, the entire establishment and expansion of Wahhabism as a force to reckon with has been based on mass murders and destruction of shrines from early 19th century onwards.

Wahhabi vandalism started in 1802 when an army of 12,000 Najdi Salafi warriors called Ikhwan attacked Shia holy sites in the city of Karbala, slaying 4,000 of that city's inhabitants. In 1803 they attacked Makkah but the Makkans, having known the fate of Karbala, surrendered to Saudi Wahhabi rule. The Wahhabi Ikhwan then smashed Sufi shrines and the graves of even the closest companions of the Prophet. In Madina, they not only destroyed common grave-sites, but even attacked the tomb of Prophet Mohammed (pbuh).

Photo: Geo News

Since then the history of Islam has been a history of massacres of non-Wahhabi Muslims and destruction of holy sites. Presently the banner of forcible Wahhabi expansion is taken up by al-Qaeda, ISIS, Taliban, Lashkar-e-Taiba, Lashkar-e-Jhangawi, Al-Shabab, Boko Haram, etc. 

Muhammad ibn Abdul Wahhab (1703–1792), the founder of Saudi Arabia’s Wahhabi-Salafi creed declared all rationalist and mystic Muslims as mushrik or polytheists and thus “wajibul qatl” (deserving death). In a long discourse in Kashaful Shubhat, he explained why all Muslims despite their claim to believe in one God are polytheists whose lives and property are halal (permitted) for Wahhabi Muslims. He concluded his discourse: “… You now understand that these people's (non-Wahhabi Muslims’) accepting tauheed (oneness of God) does not make them Muslim; the fact that they expect intercession from others than God (Sufi saints) makes them liable to be killed and their property to be looted." ----- Kashaful Shubhat, p.9, Maktaba al-salafia bil Madina Munawwara, 1969 CE)

Another Abdul Wahhab quote necessary to understand the current conflict is the following: “Even if the Muslims abstain from shirk (polytheism) and are muwahhid (believer in oneness of God), their faith cannot be perfect unless they have enmity and hatred in their action and speech against non-Muslims (which for him includes all non-Wahhabi Muslims). (Majmua Al-Rasael Wal-Masael Al-Najdiah 4/291).

The problem with Indian Salafi ulema like Maulana Imam Mehdi Salafi is that while they condemn specific terrorist incidents, they do not denounce the Wahhabi-Salafi ideology that they actually follow. This is a self-contradictory stance. You denounce terrorism and follow the ideology from which it emanates. From the time of the Mohammad bin Abdul Wahhab - Muhammad bin Saud pact in 1744, Salafi-Wahhabis have been following this murderous ideology which calls all non-Wahhabi Muslims mushrik (polytheist) and Wajibul Qatl (deserving death).

If Ahl-e-Hadith and other Salafi Muslims are sincere in condemning sectarian terrorism they need to also denounce and renounce the Wahhabi-Salafi ideology that calls for murder, destruction and looting of property. They only need to do what Abdul Wahhab’s father and brother did. In fact, his brother Shaykh Sulayman ibn 'Abd al-Wahhab wrote a book refuting his arguments. Abdul Wahhab was able to propagate his ideas freely only when his father, a Qazi of the region, passed away. 

Although Sufi-oriented Muslims, rationalists, Shias, etc have been a victim of Salafi-Wahhabi terrorism, it would be wrong to conclude that extremism is limited to Wahhabis. The recent murder of Pakistani Punjab’s Governor Salman Taseer and the deification of his Brailvi murderer by millions of Muslims shows that extremism is widespread across all sects of Islam. All Muslims who sincerely denounce terrorism need to introspect and brainstorm together how to weed out ideologies within Islam that lead to such massacres of Muslims and non-Muslims alike.

We also need to expose the hypocrites within Islam. There are people who denounce terrorism in public and teach in their madrasas that early peaceful and pluralistic verses of Quran have been abrogated by the later war-time verses asking us to kill the kafir and mushrik. Of course, war-time verses had come in a certain context which no longer exists and so these instructions can no longer apply to us. The first task before us is to come out of denial, accept that our theology and jurisprudence have been corrupted and then start thinking of changing our mindset, so that we can live as peaceful citizens of this inter-connected twenty-first century world. 


Sultan Shahin is the founding editor of a Delhi-based progressive Islamic website NewAgeIslam.com.

This article appeared first in Mail Today on 21 February 2017.

URL: http://www.newageislam.com/islam-and-sectarianism/sultan-shahin,-founding-editor,-new-age-islam/murderous-sectarianism-in-islam--salafi-ulema-should-not-only-condemn-the-massacre-at-lal-shahbaz-qalandar-shrine-but-also-the-ideology-behind-it/d/110142



New Age IslamIslam OnlineIslamic WebsiteAfrican Muslim NewsArab World NewsSouth Asia NewsIndian Muslim NewsWorld Muslim NewsWomen in IslamIslamic FeminismArab WomenWomen In ArabIslamophobia in AmericaMuslim Women in WestIslam Women and Feminism



  • Bhat we are Muslims that is final don't try to separate us from each other
    By Tanveer Ul Islam - 3/2/2017 11:48:40 PM

  • Mr. Sudhir Bharti: You know nothing about a believer of Islam. It's ridiculous that you claim to understand Makki and Madani Surah. You can't understand a single Kalmah of Quran as your intentions are negative and destructive. Last month an RSS minded police officer had disclosed that all the fake encounters were plannings of evil minded that made Mr Modi reach to Delhi. Likewise, Godhra train fire was lit was Sanghis to polarise the Hindus with an eye on forthcoming elections in 2002. 
    By Raihan Nezami - 2/26/2017 10:49:45 AM

  • Mr Sudhir Bharti: Recently a great number of Hindus are arrested in MP who are linked with ISIS. Furthermore, the RSS, ABVP, RAM SENA. DURGA VAHINI and associates
    are trading in hatred in various temples of learning to earn vote and support for their creators.  

    By Raihan Nezami - 2/26/2017 8:45:09 AM

  • I have read quran and know the difference between makki sura and madani sura. I know what it says about unbelievers. In terms of islam believer in not a person who believes in the supreme power and is at liberty to establish link with him in his desire...See More
    By Sudhir Bharti - 2/26/2017 8:01:22 AM

  • Unbelievers see the world with their eyes as they are not blinded by a mere belief. Peace and tranquility among its followers is the basic sign of a Dharma. Muslims through out the world are deprived of it. Thanks to its theory of Taqfirism and self proclaimed soldiery of Allmighty which they call Allah.
    By Sudhir Bharti - 2/26/2017 8:00:56 AM

  • @Naeem you deliberately skipped mentioning the valor of those brave men who burnt unarmed and unsuspecting Hindus in train compartment at Godhara. It had triggered all unpleasant incidents. I know it does not suit you.

    By Sudhir Bharti - 2/26/2017 8:00:36 AM

  • Non believers should be dealt politly and humbly bro ....u dont see what media says and what a muslim does....see islam as what is written
    By Tasaduq Hussain Dar - 2/26/2017 7:59:59 AM

  • And message me if u have any doubt abt islam Sudhir Bharti and do tag me when u comment
    By Tasaduq Hussain Dar - 2/26/2017 7:57:18 AM

  • @Naeem Ahmed, you have turned blind eye towards Supreme Court which said RSS was not involved. Either you are ignorant or lying blatant.
    By Sudhir Bharti - 2/26/2017 7:33:32 AM

  • Sura al Qafiroon. Mr Dr. What does it read? What is prescribed for a Qafir in quran by Allah? What treatment should be done with those who discard Islam? Please explain it to kafirs. Let us know how peaceful Islam is. Practical proof is visible through out the world. Where ever Islam reached it brought bloodshed and destruction.
    By Sudhir Bharti - 2/26/2017 7:23:43 AM

  • Tariq Fateh ...lol...
    Ask him the meaning of vajid...i bet he won't know.
    He has been kicked out by 4 countries.

    By Ishfaq Pir - 2/26/2017 7:20:52 AM

  • @Sudhir Bharti, Your are totally lying. How many RSS workers are arrested with Bomb and other material, they have killed Mahatma Gandhi. With goverment support they are set freed and evidence against them removed.
    By Naeem Ahmed - 2/26/2017 7:20:02 AM

  • Debating with unbelievers is useless , Allah says he guides those whom he wills . Quran and Hadiths are there in the world and they are enough 
    By Tabrez Ali - 2/26/2017 7:18:51 AM

  • Salafism is the root cause of terrorism.
    By Mammad Koya Kp - 2/25/2017 2:51:33 AM

  • @New Age Islam You can't change Radical mind.
    By Sudheer Sha - 2/25/2017 2:43:23 AM

Compose Your Comments here:
Email (Not to be published)
Fill the text
Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in the articles and comments are the opinions of the authors and do not necessarily reflect that of NewAgeIslam.com.