Books and Documents

Islam and Politics (25 Feb 2012 NewAgeIslam.Com)

A Decade of Gujarat Carnage 2002

By Ram Puniyani

India has witnessed many an acts of communal violence. Starting from the Jabalpur riot of 1961 to the last major one of Kandhmal (August 2008). Many an innocent lives have been lost in the name of religion. Amongst these the Gujarat carnage is a sort of marker. It came in the backdrop of massive Anti Sikh pogrom of 1984, the anti Muslim violence of post Babri demolition and the horrific burning of Pastor Graham Steward Stains in Kandhmal. It was a quantitative and qualitative departure from the other major carnages which have rocked the country.

To begin with the burning of Sabarmati S 6 coach was cleverly projected to be an act done by neighboring Muslims and in turn the violence was directed against the Muslim population of Gujarat, on the ground that the Hindu sentiments are hurt. The section of Hindu community was deliberately incited by the decision of state to take the burnt bodies of victims in a procession, against the advice of the collector of the city. The Bandh call given by VHP created the ground for violence. Here the social engineering was at its display, and Dalits and Adivasis were mobilized to unleash the violence against the hapless innocent Muslims, accompanied by the propaganda which demonized the Muslim community as a whole. While in earlier acts of violence, the state police have been an accomplice and the silent onlooker to the violence, here a sort of active collusion of state machinery and the communal forces was on display.

The BJP ruled state Government had unrestricted run in the state as the Central Government was being ruled by BJP led NDA and the other allies of BJP were too enamored by the spoils of power to spoil the broth by speaking out. Modi had already instructed the officials to sit back when the Hindu backlash will take place. The leading light of socialist movement, George Fernandez, went to the extent of taking the violence against minority women in the stride by saying that rape is nothing new and it happens in such situations. What more was needed for the rioters to run amuck and to central BJP leadership to let the things go on. The pattern of violence against women was particularly horrific, targeting at their reproductive organs and shaming them to no end.

While the architect of Gujarat pogrom Narendra Modi kept saying that violence has been controlled in three days, and central BJP leadership patted him for this, the matter of fact was that violence went on and on painfully for a long time, uncontrolled and unrestricted. The attitude of the BJP controlled state was pathetic and showed the religious bias in relief and rehabilitation work. The compensations given to minorities were abysmally low, state quickly retreated from the refugee camps on the ground that the refugee camps are ‘child production centers’, hitting the minorities where it hurts most. The biases against them were on full display. The atmosphere was created by communal forces in such a manner that the riot victims could not go back to their houses as the people in their areas demanded a written undertaking from them, that they will withdraw the cases filed in the context of violence and that they will not file any cases. Most of the police as machinery either refused to file the FIRs or if registered they kept enough loopholes for the criminals to get away. It was in this atmosphere that the process of getting justice became a close to impossible task. The communalized state apparatus, the attitude of police and judiciary led the Supreme court to direct the shifting of cases away from Gujarat.

The investigation against Narendra Modi by the state police was an impossible task and so the Special Investigation team was constituted. Unfortunately, that also did not help the matters. Accompanying all this violence and attitude of state government the minorities started feeling extremely insecure. They were boycotted in trade and other social spaces. The result is the sprawling slum of Juhapura as the symbol of polarization of communities along the religious lines. The total dislocation of the monitories created multiple problems at the level of education and sources of livelihood for the minorities.

The religious polarization and section of media has created a Halo around Narendra Modi, while strictures against him are coming by, about his failure to protect places of religious worship of minorities, the malafide intentions of state in filing cases against social activist Teesta Setalvad, many another cases are still pending, crying for justice for the victims of Gujarat. Having consolidated the section of majority community behind him, assured of their ongoing support, Modi started the high profile propaganda about development and has been trying to distract the attention from the havoc which he has wrought in the state. The big capitalists are finding the state of Gujarat as a happy hunting ground for massive state subsidies, so the media controlled by them is singing praises and modulating popular opinion in his favor, creating a larger than life size image, development man, in order to suppress his role in the violence against minorities.

In this dismal scenario, there have been many an examples of victims and social activists standing for the cause of justice and doing the practically impossible task of getting justice for violence victims despite all the efforts to turn them hostile and protect the guilty of the communal crimes. While the massive propaganda and state policies are trying to turn the minorities into second class citizens, there are efforts which have gone on simultaneously to retrieve the democratic values in the face of such adverse intimidating situation created by the communal forces. Lately, apart from Court judgments, the civil society response has been picking up and the civil society is trying to overcome the stifling situation and trying to make its voice louder. While we are nowhere close to what should ideally be there in a democratic set up, the responses of civil society and social action groups are noteworthy in the matters of getting justice for victims and in the matters of recreating the liberal space which has been undermined by the communal forces. Times alone will tell if democratic values will be successfully brought in this ‘Hindu Rashtra in one state’

Source: Northern Voices Online

URL: http://newageislam.com/islam-and-politics/ram-puniyani/a-decade-of-gujarat-carnage-2002/d/6726


  • Satwa asks, "Does that mean the ethnic cleansing by kashmiri muslim are correct?"

    Did I say that? Read my comment again.

    By Ghulam Mohiyuddin - 2/28/2012 8:34:30 PM

  • Abdul shukur kummethi It is not the past but of the present in kashmir india and other part of world where the majority muslim kill and eliminate the minority. Pakistan total minority had fallen from 8 to 2 percent in just six decades is the greatness of peace practice by muslim majority
    By satwa gunam - 2/27/2012 8:37:05 PM

  • @ghulam Does that mean the ethnic cleansing by kashmiri muslim are correct. Who started the same. What is the fate of the refugees. Why are the forum silent about the same. What was the role of kashmiri muslim to protect the rights of kashmiri pandits. Finally see the difference in the attitude in the following site : http://koausa.org/koa/ Anyhow moving further is too much to ask from a belief system which has not moved away from 7th century incidence and hatred. However these type of selective argument will only alienate the common hindu away for the cause of common muslim as anybody can see the double standard.
    By satwa gunam - 2/27/2012 8:35:21 PM

  • Satwa says, "Similar blood bath did happen in kashmir." Yes, Kashmir is a sad story. 219 Kashmiri Pandits have been killed since 1989. Between 50,000 to 90,000 Kashmiri Muslims have been killed in the same period.
    By Ghulam Mohiyuddin - 2/27/2012 3:02:43 PM

  • Our Hindu brethern in Gujarat have been fully brainwashed to hate muslims.Even the government machinery including police,lawyers,doctors and judiciary think that muslims are not one among them.Muslims are not human beings but lowly creatures to be snuffed out.Presnt day muslims are being penalised for the sins and excesses commited by the past muslim rulers long long ago.
    By Abdul shukur kummethi - 2/27/2012 11:36:35 AM

  • Similar blood bath did happen in kashmir. Neither the majority muslim there fought for the rights of the minority nor stood up against the muslim fundamentalist. Ram punyani has selective sense of judgement.
    By satwa gunam - 2/27/2012 9:09:07 AM

  • Gujrat massacre is a great shame, mischievous bloodbath, a vicious circle of torture for the innocent Muslims at the hand of Jansanghis.
    By Raihan Nezami - 2/26/2012 10:06:30 AM

  • How is that kashmiri muslim alone can create havoc to the society at a news of a muslim death on custody or any other slightest provocation. Does that also mean that they are always ready to create violence for some reason. Majority of India is under risk. Already north eastern states and kerala no more hindu majority. Hindus have to work hard to keep the Abraham religion at bay to keep their identity safe. It is a open proxy war by Christian missionaries. Following is by tehelka which cannot be hopefully categorized as rss or jansanghi : http://www.tehelka.com/story_main.asp?filename=ts013004shashi.asp
    By satwa gunam - 2/25/2012 8:41:08 PM

  • While Hindu rage after the Godhra train fire is understandable, the readiness of the Bajrang Dal to mount a statewide offensive which had all the hallmarks of prior planning was both a surprise and a shock. Continued existence of armed or rowdy Hindutva groups such as the Bajrang Dal, ABVP, Sanatan Sanstha, Jai Vande Matram, Hindu Janajagruti Samiti etc poses risks. Their existence in a modern democracy is unusal. Why should an 85% majority community need or want such protection?

    Training of police officers must include an important component similar to the Nuremberg principles which would require police officers to perform their professional duty ignoring any unlawful orders that they may receive from their civilian bosses.

    The fact that the Raghavan SIT turned out to be unashamed apologists out to give a clean chit to Modi is the final insult added to an unspeakable injury.

    By Ghulam Mohiyuddin - 2/25/2012 2:32:08 PM

  • The issue is collective punishment for the alleged crimes of a few, complicity of the authorities, and the present state of affairs due to that terrible carnage. On these counts alone, Mr Punyani is right.
    By Mubashir - 2/25/2012 9:23:34 AM

  • Punyani is always in hurry to state that all short coming are of the hindus and hindu rulers. He does not have guts to talk about the happening in Kashmir or any place where Muslim are at majority and their civil practices. Probably either he is doing this to vent out his frustration or for his paying master, god only knows.
    By satwa gunam - 2/25/2012 9:00:31 AM

Compose Your Comments here:
Email (Not to be published)
Fill the text
Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in the articles and comments are the opinions of the authors and do not necessarily reflect that of NewAgeIslam.com.