New Age Islam - Read About Islam, Islamic Religion and Muslims, Terrorism and Jihad
   Urdu Section
   Hindi Section
   Bangla Section
   Assamese Section
   Malayalam Section
   Arabic Section
   Persian Section
   French Section
   Debating Islam
   Islamic Q and A
   Books and Documents
   Islamic World News
   Radical Islamism and Jihad
   Islam,Terrorism and Jihad
   War on Terror
   Islam and the West
   Interfaith Dialogue
   The War Within Islam
   Islam and Sectarianism
   Islam and Politics
   Islam and Spiritualism
   Current Affairs
   Spiritual Meditations
   Muslims and Islamophobia
   Islam, Women and Feminism
   Islamic Ideology
   Islam and Human Rights
   Islamic Society
   Islamic Sharia Laws
   Islam and Pluralism
   Islam and Tolerance
   Ijtihad, Rethinking Islam
   Islamic History
   Islamic Personalities
   Islam and Science
   Islam and Environment
   Islamic Culture
   Islam and the Media
   Letter to the Editor
   From the Desk of Editor
   Indian Press
   Pakistan Press
   Middle East Press
   World Press
Allama Sir Muhammad Iqbal
The Reconstruction of Religious Thought in Islam
Biography, Audio
More Videos.. 
The Quran: A New Translation - The eternal present tense
Preface: The Reconstruction of Religious Thought in Islam By Dr. Muhammad Iqbal
Lecture 1: Knowledge and Religious Experience
Focus on Islam, Jihad and Terrorism
Condemning "Islamist" terrorist attack on Mumbai in harshest terms
Can Ulema save Muslims from Radical Islamism?
Indian Ulema have no time to lose, must call warlike Quranic surahs obsolete.
Jihadism gets sustenance from verses of war in the Quran
Dr. Zakir Naik on Yazeed and Osama bin Laden - A New Age Islam Debate
Unveiling Zakir Naik: Terror cannot be fought with Terror
Comments - 148
On Televangelist Zakir Naik: Don't give in to pretenders
Comments - 31
Beware of the Kafir-manufacturing factories: Maulana Nadeem-ul-Wajidi responds to the Fatawahs of Kufr against Dr. Zakir Naik
Comments - 41
Unity among Muslims and Dr. Zakir Naik's Evil: A Point of View
Comments - 163
This Islamic website offers facts about Islam and Muslims, Islam way and Islamic ideology. Online Islam - Latest Islamic World News, Articles on Radical Islamism & Jihad and Islam, Terrorism and Jihad
Current Affairs
27 Jan 2012, NewAgeIslam.Com
Salman Rushdie Saga: A Trimmed Idea of India

By Srijana Mitra Das

Jan 27, 2012,

The banning of Salman Rushdie from appearing even via satellite link at the recent Jaipur Literature Festival (JLF) showcases two ideas of India. The first is embodied by the JLF. Stepping away from India's fascination with hierarchies, the fest avoids armed bodyguards, sleek millionaires and imperious politicians flinging namaskars into crowds.

Instead, it throws itself open to everyone; this includes readers, schoolchildren, writers, homemakers, domestic help, socialites and swamis, with the occasional politico. Everyone joins its carnival-like atmosphere, drinking tea on the venue's lawns, queuing for the same restrooms, hearing the finest words in the world.

Registering 1.22 lakh visitors in 2012, the JLF couldn't have become the success it has without this idea of India endorsed by its core audience - liberal Indians. The term 'liberal' doesn't mean a manicured handful of intellectuals discussing the Russian or Tamil Stalin at clubs and TV studios. It denotes thousands of people from diverse classes and languages, spread over distant cities and towns - often obtaining books from fading libraries and railway carts, debating poets in the low-voltage light of old homes, opposing the unjust hierarchies of Indian life. It is these liberals' idea of an equal and intellectual India that encouraged the JLF's organisers to invite Rushdie to discuss English becoming the deliciously tangy chutney all of us make it.

But events thereafter highlight another idea of India rising like bile - cynical, brutal and coarse, fuelled by the commingling of politics with vociferous bullies of any community. Within this idea, hierarchy must be privileged. Such hierarchy could be social, economic or sexual, or based on physica-lity where the threat of bodily violence overwhelms the most beautiful ideas. To pump muscle into threat, an underemployed male underclass is pointed at those it wrongly resents.

Political groups use this tactic repeatedly to strengthen the status quo and prevent any change - economic, gendered, and intellectual - from shaking their place in the established hierarchy. The Sri Ram Sene used this underclass to attack women at Bangalore pubs. Congress elements used this underclass to protest Joseph Lelyveld's biography of Gandhi and guard our most-garlanded, least-heard saint. And recently, political interests fuelled an angry underclass, directing it to threaten a festival of the most democratic ideas. These events make it imperative for Indian liberals to re-evaluate their position on all threats and those who make them.

Traditionally, the Indian liberal has opposed obvious hierarchies - class, caste, gender - challenging even the superiority writ into the very act of banning where a patronising political class considers itself best-equipped to decide what its citizenry may read, see or write. But there is one glaring omission in the Indian liberal's opposition - opposing a violent underclass because it hails from an otherwise disadvantaged section of society. To illustrate - the darkness from the Rushdie controversy stretches back into the 1980s when, before banning The Satanic Verses, Rajiv Gandhi's government overturned a legal ruling favouring a divorced Muslim woman. Minority appeasement, screamed the Hindu right as Shah Bano lost her maintenance before far more vociferous Muslim men. Repulsed by Hindutva's aggression and tongue-tied before those it traditionally defended, the Indian liberal stepped back - a huge error.

In The Argumentative Indian, Amartya Sen points out the only people 'appeased' by the Shah Bano ruling were Muslim men, making the Muslim woman a thoroughly vulnerable being. Yet, frightened for minorities already savaged in Bhagalpur and other places, the Indian liberal said and did little for Shah Bano. Today, that hesitation has returned to mock the blank screen where Rushdie's image could have played.

Had the Indian liberal used logic and not courtesy then, arguing for justice, opposing any threats of violence from fringe elements whether Hindu or Muslim, perhaps those fringes would not have grown to be the problem they are today. Perhaps we could have seen a JLF where anti-Rushdie groups shouted slogans and waved placards - their democratic right - but feared threatening violence in place of severe censure. Perhaps we would have had a situation where, realising targeting artists wasn't going to win elections; politicians - both Hindu and Muslim - would have ensured the Muslim community got its fair share of jobs and education. Perhaps we might have had a JLF where Rushdie spoke and those who abhorred him turned up their noses - but didn't even think of raising their fists. Perhaps a timely trim in liberal tolerance might have led to a less violent nation.

Yet, events actually show the first idea of India is gaining ground. The strong support, particularly from younger people, for Rushdie's right to speak, the impromptu debate that occurred inviting an anti-Rushdie representative to explain opposition, media and internet criticism, all show the idea of India loved by liberal Indians is losing its early hesitation. As more Indians transcend boundaries, challenge ridiculous bans and show the finger to anyone who threatens violence, we will have more festivals of literature, ideas and art where liberal and illiberal will use only their words - beautiful, polished, haunting or taunting - to make points or refute them.

Source: The Times of India, New Delhi



Forward to a friend | Print
1/27/2012 3:58:01 PM Ghulam Mohiyuddin
Good thoughts, but the reality is different. Everything gets politicized, and politicization leads to hardening of positions on all sides.
Total Comments: 1
     Compose Your Comments here:
Email (Not to be published)
Strike Through
Left Align
Right Align
Change Text Direction
Ordered List
Unordered List
Decrease Indent
Increase Indent
Font Color
Background Color
Insert Link
Remove Link
Horizontal Rule
Please use the browser Internet Explorer to post your comments.
In case of difficulty, please post your comments to:
Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in the articles and comments are the opinions of the authors and not necessarily reflect that of
This site contains copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in our efforts to promote Co-Existence and Dialogue of Religions and Civilisations, and advance understanding of Islam and Democracy, Pluralism, Terrorism, Human Rights, Islamic Laws and Ideology, etc. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner. The material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes. New Age Islam has no affiliation whatsoever with the originator of these articles nor is New Age Islam endorsed or sponsored by the originator of these articles. For more information go to:
Copyright 2008 - 2009 NewAgeIslam.Com All Rights Reserved.
Site best viewed in 1200 x 900 pixels or higher display resolution.
Editor and Publisher: Sultan Shahin, E-22, Indra Prastha Apts., 114, I. P. Extension, New Delhi – 110092
Phone No. (+91-11) 222 44 868 E-mail:
Home | About Us | Contact Us | Disclaimer | Donate | Submit Articles | Privacy Policy