New Age Islam - Read About Islam, Islamic Religion and Muslims, Terrorism and Jihad
HOME ARCHIVES MULTIMEDIA URDU SECTION BOOKS DEBATE DICTIONARY
Name:
E-mail:
   Urdu Section
   Hindi Section
   Arabic Section
   French Section
   Multimedia
   Archives
   Books and Documents
   Islamic World News
   Radical Islamism and Jihad
   Islam,Terrorism and Jihad
   War on Terror
   Islam and the West
   Interfaith Dialogue
   The War Within Islam
   Islam and Politics
   Current Affairs
   Muslims and Islamophobia
   Islamic Ideology
   Islam and Human Rights
   Islamic Sharia Laws
   Ijtihad, Rethinking Islam
   Islam and Sectarianism
   Islam and Spiritualism
   Spiritual Meditations
   Islam, Women and Feminism
   Islamic Society
   Islam and Pluralism
   Islam and Tolerance
   Islamic History
   Islamic Personalities
   Islam and Science
   Islam and Environment
   Islamic Culture
   Debating Islam
   Interview
   Islam and the Media
   Letter to the Editor
   From the Desk of Editor
   Persian Section
   Bangla Section
Allama Sir Muhammad Iqbal
The Reconstruction of Religious Thought in Islam
Biography, Audio
Vivekananda
More Videos.. 
The Quran: A New Translation - The eternal present tense
Preface: The Reconstruction of Religious Thought in Islam By Dr. Muhammad Iqbal
Lecture 1: Knowledge and Religious Experience
More.. 
Focus on Islam, Jihad and Terrorism
Condemning "Islamist" terrorist attack on Mumbai in harshest terms
Can Ulema save Muslims from Radical Islamism?
Indian Ulema have no time to lose, must call warlike Quranic surahs obsolete.
Jihadism gets sustenance from verses of war in the Quran
More.. 
Dr. Zakir Naik on Yazeed and Osama bin Laden - A New Age Islam Debate
Unveiling Zakir Naik: Terror cannot be fought with Terror
Comments - 148
On Televangelist Zakir Naik: Don't give in to pretenders
Comments - 31
Beware of the Kafir-manufacturing factories: Maulana Nadeem-ul-Wajidi responds to the Fatawahs of Kufr against Dr. Zakir Naik
Comments - 41
Unity among Muslims and Dr. Zakir Naik's Evil: A Point of View
Comments - 163
This Islamic website offers facts about Islam and Muslims, Islam way and Islamic ideology. Online Islam - Latest Islamic World News, Articles on Radical Islamism & Jihad and Islam, Terrorism and Jihad
     
Radical Islamism and Jihad
03 Nov 2008, NewAgeIslam.Com
'Muslims should abrogate verses of war in Islamic Law'

By Ida Indawati Khouw

 

The Jakartapost.com

November 03, 2008

 

Although Islamic scholars have repeatedly explained that Koranic verses endorsing war and the use of violence only apply in specific circumstances, for example, in justifying defensive violence when fighting against repression, nonetheless contemporary hard-liners continue justifying violent acts using these sacred texts and seek to legitimize their own actions on religious grounds.

"We should think of a way to end this advocacy of violence in the name of Islam. Apologists argue that the problem lies in Muslims having misinterpreted these texts. They refuse to look at the religion in a critical way but suggest a method of contextualization in interpreting these texts (emphasizing that the verses are historically bound to the era in which they were revealed). But I have become tired with this approach."

"The problem is, fundamentalists create context," Guntur explains further: "For instance, they apply the word 'holy war' to the struggle against United States domination. Another example, the hard-liners extend the meaning of 'enemy of Islam' not only to followers of the Jewish faith and Christians but also to Muslims they consider to be cooperating with the 'infidels'. So, they are very 'contextual' in their arguments."

In order to 'rescue' Islam from being tarnished by violent acts, he suggests Muslims should dare to abrogate the Islamic law on war and the use of violence, an approach that is founded on Islamic tradition itself, "Islam acknowledges a method called nasakh, abrogation of law. It is not a popular approach but we can take the step when certain stipulations are no longer applicable to the contemporary context."

Applying nasakh does not mean to abrogate the holy texts, "texts endorsing war and violence will still be there but we will regard them as historical facts," says Guntur.

According to Guntur, the radicals have been using this method. He points out as an example that mujahidin fighters in Afghanistan, "abrogated verses that promote peace and tolerance so that they can wage war (in the name of Islam). So, why don't we reverse the approach; we should abrogate the verses that suggest violence and promote peaceful ones, instead?"

 

Return to the pre-Madina teachings of Muhammad

Guntur says that peaceful Islam was evident during the Meccan era, when Islam was not yet fully institutionalized and when followers of the Prophet Muhammad were held together primarily as a spiritual community.

"Thus I have a dream, that contemporary Muslims would practice Islam as it was in the pre-Medina era when Islam was in the private realm. In my opinion, that is the era of the hanif Islam (the straight Islam). Peaceful Koranic verses were revealed during this Mecca era," the alumnae of the Department of Creed and Philosophy of Al Azhar University adds, "In Mecca, Muhammad's followers were not very distinctive from Jews or Christians, as the three shared the same stories and (spiritual) genealogy as the offspring of Abraham."

Prophet Muhammad hijra (migrated) from Mecca to Medina in AD 622 to avoid bloodshed, as the Prophet was not popular among the powerful Quraish clan who rejected his tauhid (monotheistic) teaching. The migration is understood as the date for the beginning of the Islamic Hijri calendar.

Guntur elaborates further: "Identity Islam was shaped, later in Medina, when the religion intersected with political power. It was in this context that verses related to war were revealed.

Asked whether he was afraid if his thoughts would be labeled as being blasphemous, Guntur answers: "In fact, I used to be a fundamentalist myself during mypesantren (Islamic boarding school) year in Madura (East Java). I was influenced by the ideology of my teachers."

Thanks to the respected figure Abdurrahman Wahid (Gus Dur) Guntur became religiously enlightened. "Gus Dur visited my school. Before raising issues with him, I challenged him to first take up the argument that Islam was the most correct religion.

"Gus Dur responded: the faith of this santri (Guntur, the student) is in crisis. Those confident with their faith and religion do not need to make the claim that Islam is supreme. Those whose faith is shallow are those with the biggest mouths."

Gus Dur's remarks "hit" Guntur deeply.

http://old.thejakartapost.com/detailfeatures.asp?fileid=20081102.C02&irec=4

URL: http://www.newageislam.com/radical-islamism-and-jihad/-muslims-should-abrogate-verses-of-war-in-islamic-law-/d/951

 

 

Forward to a friend | Print
COMMENTS
G.Vishvas

Muslims must come to terms with the fact that islam does not have and will not and cannot have a positive context and constructive role in the 21st century. So long muslims practise self-deceit and think islam can be reformed and made modern, we all will continue to suffer. Context is a very flexible argument and suits more to those who wish to enforce fascism and emotionalism and are ready to die or kill for their beliefs. That the kuran contains such weak points is proof enough that it not a divine book - nor a book of peace nor knowledge. Excessive praise of anything or anyone leads to fascism, irrationality and extremism and islam is thus a Mohammad-centred and Kuran-centred fascism. Unfortunately islamic education causes muslims to become cowards and opportunists and they cannot aparently overcome their fears and come to the correct conclusion that islam is a dangerous-evil case now (in the 21st century). Muslim cowardice manifests itself in their love for violence. Practising collective violence under a fascist leader is a way of hiding ones cowardice, opportunism and foolishness. I read the kuran and found it to be a book of totalitarian manipulation of those who are timid and weak of intelligence. Islam is an instrument of arab imperialism and hegemony also. Non-arabs should certainly shun islam. Even for the arabs islam has become a heavy millstone around the neck. A bit of doctoring here and there will not do. Islam has become a scourge upon mankind and things will become worse if muslims keep fooling themselves and others into thinking that islam can be made better. Every attempt to reform islam has only ended up strengthening islamic fascism. Everything good that non-muslims gave to the muslims (even to muslim liberals) ended up in the hands of the islamofascists. Face these facts courageously and honestly now.

Govind Sharma

Dear Readers,

First of all I am delighted to see that there is an Islamic website which respects the views of other believers. Normally I have seen Muslims do not like criticism and therefore intelligentsia normally avoids such discussions with them. So the first comment made by me is to acknowledge that when we are prepared to listen to the criticism we are prepared to improve.

In my opinion we should know that the purpose of any religion is to help develop individual, society, countries and the humanity as a whole. Therefore any religion  which creates hatred between the people is not a religion but the creation of devil. Islam, Hinduism or Christianity should preach that they all are here to respect God because the ultimate aim of every religion is the same. 

Sultan Shahin

Dear Aamir Mughal Sahab,

 

Thanks for sharing these posts with us. They are very educative and contain quotations from authorities on the subject. So I am posting them separately on another page for NewAgeIslam.com readers.

Knowing how to Interpret Quran correctly is important and certainly useful and necessary. But it still doesn’t solve our problems regarding the Holy Quran’s war-like verses. These verses were situational. They are instructions given in a certain context. Some of them certainly are of a universal nature. But in some other cases that context does not obtain today and cannot obtain today or in future. Time machine or not, we are not going to live in the 6th century Arabia and fight those wars again. Enemies of Islam both within and without are using these surahs to propagate that Islam breeds or justifies terrorism. A virtually new religion has come into existence that I have been calling Jihadism, but it claims to be Islam and derives sustenance from these verses. Its practitioners too are outwardly Muslim and claim to be true Muslims, indeed the only Muslims who deserve to go to Heaven. Jihadism has indeed distorted the very beautiful concept of Jihad fi sabilillah.  Mainstream Islam is not contradicting these claims loudly and widely enough. This inevitably creates suspicions in the minds of our neighbors, people belonging to other religions who do not understand the situational nature of Quranic verses, particularly as they are told that every word, comma and full stop in the Holy Quran is immutable and of universal significance. This also makes the task of Jihadists easier. In the absence of adequate response from mainstream Islam, the Jihadists are able to easily brainwash our youth, even those who are highly educated and intelligent.

We cannot delete these verses from the Quran, of course, but we can certainly make it clear that they do not apply to us any more. I hope you will seriously consider the question and come up with a response. Living in Pakistan, the very hub of terrorism, you have probably become inured to Qital in a way that Muslims in more peaceful societies are not. The article

 

Muslims should abrogate verses of war in Islamic Law

available at: 

 

http://newageislam.com/radical-islamism-and-jihad/-muslims-should-abrogate-verses-of-war-in-islamic-law-/d/951

was a cry of despair from an Indonesian Muslim who is watching his peaceful Islamic country gradually turning into an inferno of Jihadism. I made a similar plea in

Indian Ulema have no time to lose, must call warlike Quranic surahs obsolete   

 

[available at: 

for the same reason. Indian Prime Minister took pride not long ago in the fact that not a single Muslim from this country was found to be a part of the international Al-Qaeda network. We can no longer do so and Jihadism is gaining ground here too. Mainstream Islam must respond to the challenge of Jihadism that is based on verses from Quran that no longer apply. Let us come out and say so.

 

Sultan Shahin

 

Reference: 

http://newageislam.com/radical-islamism-and-jihad/-muslims-should-abrogate-verses-of-war-in-islamic-law-/d/951

 

Aamir Mughal

Dear Sultan Sahab,

There is a photo of a poet i.e. Allama Iqbal on your website and it would be appropriate to quote him on Quran, by the way I dont like poet very much [Iqbal is also included] but since his photo is on your website so I mentioned Iqbal!

Khud badaltay nahin Quran ko badal detay hain

Some words on abrogation of Quran.

1 - How to Interpret Quran? - 1

http://chagataikhan.blogspot.com/2008/10/how-to-interpret-quran-1.html

2 - How to Interpret Quran? - 2

http://chagataikhan.blogspot.com/2008/10/how-to-interpret-quran-2.html

3 - How to Interpret Quran? - 3

http://chagataikhan.blogspot.com/2008/10/how-to-interpret-quran-3.html

 

Total Comments: 4
     Compose Your Comments here:
Name
Email (Not to be published)
Bold
Italic
Underline
Strike Through
Superscript
Subscript
Undo
Redo
Cut
Copy
Paste
Left Align
Center
Right Align
Justify
Change Text Direction
Ordered List
Unordered List
Decrease Indent
Increase Indent
Font Color
Background Color
Insert Link
Remove Link
Horizontal Rule
Please use the browser Internet Explorer to post your comments.
In case of difficulty, please post your comments to: Editor@NewAgeIslam.com
Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in the articles and comments are the opinions of the authors and not necessarily reflect that of NewAgeIslam.com.
FAIR USE NOTICE:
This site contains copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in our efforts to promote Co-Existence and Dialogue of Religions and Civilisations, and advance understanding of Islam and Democracy, Pluralism, Terrorism, Human Rights, Islamic Laws and Ideology, etc. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner. The material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes. New Age Islam has no affiliation whatsoever with the originator of these articles nor is New Age Islam endorsed or sponsored by the originator of these articles. For more information go to: http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml
Copyright 2008 - 2009 NewAgeIslam.Com All Rights Reserved.
Site best viewed in 1200 x 900 pixels or higher display resolution.
Editor and Publisher: Sultan Shahin, E-22, Indra Prastha Apts., 114, I. P. Extension, New Delhi – 110092
Phone No. (+91-11) 222 44 868 E-mail: Editor@NewAgeIslam.com
Home | About Us | Contact Us | Disclaimer | Donate | Submit Articles | Privacy Policy